Saturday September 2 11:45 AM ET
Jewish Groups to Protest Pius IX's Beatification

By Luke Baker

Reuters Photo
Reuters Photo

ROME (Reuters) - Jewish groups planned a protest in Rome on Saturday against the beatification of Pope Pius IX, a controversial and ultra-conservative 19th century head of the Roman Catholic church accused of anti-Semitism.
Polish-born Pope John Paul is due to beatify Pius IX, the last ''Pope King'' who reigned from 1846 to 1878 with the 20th century reformist Pope John XXIII on Sunday.
Beatification is the penultimate step before elevation to sainthood by the Roman Catholic church.
John XXIII, the reformist pope of the Second Vatican Council, was a much-loved figure but Jewish groups and their supporters, including members of Italy's Radical party, have called a peaceful demonstration against Pius IX's elevation.
Pius, who adamantly opposed religious tolerance and defined the doctrine of Papal infallibility, referred to Jews as ``dogs'' and once had a Jewish boy kidnapped from his home, forcing him to be brought up as a Roman Catholic.

On June 23, 1858, papal police in Bologna entered the home of the Mortaras, a Jewish family, snatched six-year-old Edgardo, and took him to Rome.

``Today, after almost a century and a half, the Italian Jewish community remains embittered by that assault on Judaism and parenthood,'' Seymour Reich, chairman of a collective of major U.S. Jewish groups, said in a letter to a cardinal on August 23.
Reich argued that Pius's actions could not be excused as the practice of the times. ``If saintliness is seen as the goodness, wisdom and courage to behave righteously and right wrongs regardless of when they occur, then Pius IX's conduct falls far short of saintliness,'' he said.
A group of traditionalists called Principe Ruspoli plan a separate demonstration in favor of Pius's beatification on Saturday evening. They argue that Pius did much to strengthen and enhance the Papal legacy.

 

Beatification Of ``Popes Apart''
Reuters Photo
Reuters Photo
John XXIII was a markedly different character. Sunday's ceremony has been referred to as the beatification of the ``Popes apart.'' John, born Angelo Giuseppe Roncalli, called the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965), which thrust the Church into the modern world, ended the Latin mass and gave bishops more power. While one of Pius's favorite phrases was ``I am the Church. I am the tradition,'' John liked to listen to new ideas and told visitors: ``Let's talk man-to-man. I have two eyes and two ears just like you.'' When John, dubbed ``the good Pope'' died in 1963, it seemed all of Rome was in tears. When Pius died, on the other hand, his coffin was mobbed by a group of nationalists, angry at his opposition to Italian unity, who tried to throw it into the Tiber. Pius was the last pope to have temporal power over large parts of central Italy and presided over the loss of territories known as the Papal States when the country was unified in 1870. Speculation on the reasoning behind the beatification of the two markedly different Papal characters has focused on the need to balance the Church's opposing wings. ``It can only be seen as a political move, designed to provide a conservative and reactionary counterweight to the beatification of John XXIII,'' wrote the British Catholic weekly The Tablet in an editorial. ``The conclusion is surely inescapable that the beatification of Pius IX is the work of a small group of ultra-conservatives.''

 


 

Copyright © 2000 Yahoo! Inc., and Reuters Limited. All rights reserved.
Republication or redistribution of Reuters content is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters.
Reuters shall not be liable for any errors or delays in the content, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon.
Questions or Comments