William C. Westmoreland Is Dead at 91;
General Led
U.S.
Troops in
Vietnam
By CRAIG R. WHITNEY and ERIC
PACE
Published:
July 20, 2005
Gen.
William C. Westmoreland, the Army artilleryman and paratrooper who
failed to lead United States forces to victory in Vietnam from 1964 to
1968 and then made himself the most prominent advocate for recognition
of their sacrifices, spending the rest of his life paying tribute to his
soldiers, died Monday night in a retirement home in
Charleston
,
S.C.
, his son, James Ripley Westmoreland,
announced.
The
general was 91.
Westy,
as he became known while a
West Point
cadet, led fast-moving artillery
battalions in World War II and became a paratrooper as the Army prepared
in the 1950's for the new kind of war he would face in
Vietnam
.
There,
he presided over a vast buildup from 16,000 troops when he arrived to
more than 500,000 in 1968, when a devastating Communist offensive caused
President Lyndon B. Johnson to lose confidence in the strategy and
replace the general.
Though
he was dogged by antiwar protestors and denounced as a war criminal
when, as Army chief of staff from 1968 to 1972, he tried to speak on
college campuses, after passions cooled General Westmoreland led a march
of
Vietnam
veterans to their memorial in
Washington
in 1982 and, tearfully, a gathering of
200,000 veterans in
Chicago
in June 1986.
He
never understood the war as a Vietnamese nationalist struggle against
French and later American domination. Ho Chi Minh and his Communist
successors believed they could out-suffer and outlast those they saw as
foreign invaders supporting a "puppet" South Vietnamese
regime; General Westmoreland believed that hundreds of thousands of
American troops could root out the Communist insurgents and enable
freedom and democracy to grow in
Vietnam
, but that
Washington
lost its nerve, and lost the war.
"Had
President Johnson changed our strategy and taken advantage of the
enemy's weakness to enable me to carry out the operations we had
prepared over the preceding two years in Laos and Cambodia and north of
the demilitarized zone, along with intensified bombing and the mining of
Haiphong harbor, the North Vietnamese doubtlessly would have
broken," he wrote in his memoirs.
Instead,
as he saw it, "The United States in the end abandoned
South Vietnam
."
President
Richard M. Nixon did not take decisive steps to win, and after most
United States
troops withdrew in 1973 after a
cease-fire, Communist tanks rolled into
Saigon
(now
Ho Chi Minh City
) in 1975. "Despite the final
failure of the South Vietnamese, the record of the American military
services of never having lost a war is still intact," General
Westmoreland wrote.
His
firm jaw, bushy eyebrows and ramrod military bearing made the
six-foot-tall William Childs Westmoreland the very image of a general,
though he said he learned from an early encounter with a soft-spoken
major named Omar Bradley that there was more than one way to command.
In
later years, he often spoke to veterans' groups, his son said, getting
to all 50 states. "That became, in effect, his raison d'ętre,"
Mr. Westmoreland said in a comment quoted by The Associated Press.
"He did have a point of view on
Vietnam
, but he did not speak about that. He was
not trying to justify anything."
A
Bright Early Career
General
Westmoreland's rise to command in
Saigon
came after an early career that caught
the eye of senior officers who later became influential during the
Kennedy administration, notably Gen. Maxwell D. Taylor, who was
commanding the 82nd Airborne Division in
Sicily
when they first met in 1943 and later
influenced President John F. Kennedy's thinking on counterinsurgency
warfare.
The
general was born on
March 26, 1914
, near
Spartanburg
,
S.C.
, where his father was a cotton-mill
manager who later became an investment banker. His paternal ancestors
included soldiers who had served during the Revolutionary War and with
the Confederate Army, but after graduating from high school in Pacolet,
he went to The Citadel, the state military college, in 1931. His father
wanted him to study law after graduation, General Westmoreland wrote in
his memoir, "A Soldier Reports" (Doubleday, 1976).
KWAME HOLMAN: Westmoreland always maintained that the
U.S.
military did not lose in
Vietnam
, the most controversial American conflict since the Civil War. He arrived
in
Saigon
to command a few thousand American troops, mostly advisors, in 1964.
When he left four years later, there would be more than a half-million
Americans on the ground waging a war of attrition against North Vietnamese
forces hardened to sustain massive troop losses. Nevertheless, in November
1967, Westmoreland maintained a positive tone.
GEN. WILLIAM WESTMORELAND: I've never been more encouraged during my
entire, almost four years in this country. Everybody is very optimistic
that I know of who is intimately associated with our effort there.
KWAME HOLMAN: That outward optimism was dealt a severe blow just more
than two months later.
GEN. WILLIAM WESTMORELAND: The enemy, very deceitfully, has taken
advantage of the Tet truce in order to create maximum consternation within
South Vietnam
, particularly in the populated areas.
KWAME HOLMAN: The 1968 Tet Offensive, though a military disaster for
the Communists, helped shift American public opinion against the war.
Westmoreland was recalled to
Washington
as army chief of staff. He retired in 1972.
A decade after his retirement, Westmoreland would fight one last battle
over
Vietnam
. In 1982, he filed a $120 million libel suit against CBS after their
documentary accused him of willfully deceiving the civilian leadership
during his command of forces in
Vietnam
. CBS and Westmoreland settled the case before it was sent to a jury; both
sides claimed victory.
In a NewsHour interview, Westmoreland discussed the toll the war had
taken on him.
GEN. WILLIAM WESTMORELAND:
Vietnam
has, by virtue of the fact that I've been in the center of the controversy
-- it has been an albatross around my neck for years and years and years.
I have conducted myself in accordance to my best conscience, and now I
would like to close the books and fade away.
Vets,
Just a reminder that the 7/15th FA Assoc. is having our 6th
REUNION
on Aug. 18-21 in
Middleburg Heights
,
OH
. More info will follow
in our next newsletter due in your hands July 1st.
This year our host Dan Gillotii has planed a mix of field trips ( your
choice ) in the
Cleveland
OH
. area. This is unlike
our normal “Military” fort programs. So it’s a break from the norm,
but may be right up your alley?
The newsletters go out to about 720 Vets at this time. I’ll be
cold-calling Vets up to the end of July and a few in the
Cleveland
area even later.
Cut-off date for $ discount rooms is July 28. See our website for details http://www.landscaper.net
Please consider attending, call a friend to meet you there.
Every reunion motto: “BABE”….Bring a Buddy Everyone!
Dave “Davo” Holdorf, C/7/15th FA, 15th FA Assoc.
Grp. Leader
'Ghost of
Bataan
' still helping vets
Monday, July 4, 2005
By
Ruth Ann Dailey
Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
When a neighbor told
me where to find Abie Abraham, my throat tightened a bit.
A reader had phoned to
relay Abie's inspiring story two weeks before, and some cranial lightning
bolt returned it to my mind last Thursday night. Friday morning, I sifted
through dozens of phone messages to find the right one. I called the
reader back, and he had Abie's address. A colleague worked Internet magic
to unearth Abie's unlisted number, but no one answered the phone.
Determined to share
this heroic veteran's story on Independence Day, I drove to
Connoquenessing, searched an unpaved road for his unnumbered house,
knocked and knocked, trespassed on his property shouting
"Hello!" at various groundhogs -- all to no avail. But a
neighbor quieted his riding mower long enough to say, rather alarmingly,
"I know where you can find Abie. He's at the VA hospital down the
road. Just ask for him at the front desk."
Abie Abraham will turn
92 at the end of this month. He not only survived the Bataan Death March
but endured hellish years as a prisoner of war, chronicled the deaths of
hundreds of soldiers and remained in the
Philippines
after the war -- at Gen.
Douglas MacArthur's request -- to find the bodies of American dead.
But that epic effort
ended 55 years ago. Old heroes are aging quickly. Word that this local
hero was at the
Butler
Veterans
Affairs
Medical
Center
made me worry -- until a
helpful employee pointed me to Abie's outpost, the outpatient entrance
information desk.
At 91 years and
330-some days of age, retired U.S. Army Sgt. Abie Abraham shows up at the
hospital at
6:45 a.m.
five days a week, eight
hours a day, to volunteer. He's explaining his work when an attractive
young woman walks by and calls out, "Hi, Abie!"
"I love
her," he tells me, then calls to her, "You love me?" She
laughs and tosses a "Yes" over her shoulder.
It turns out this
tireless worker, this "Ghost of Bataan," this first-generation
American of Syrian descent, is a beloved rascal.
Another volunteer
stops to chat, and Abie mentions his upcoming birthday. "I'm angling
for a party," he confides.
His 29,000 hours of
service began 17 years ago. "I visited a friend of mine here and he
cried," Abie recounts simply. "I saw the suffering. Then I
started volunteering. You have to give something in life."
Abie already has given
far more than most.
Having enlisted in
1932, he'd achieved the rank of sergeant by 1941 and was stationed in the
Philippines
with his young family
when
Japan
attacked. He was among
the estimated 70,000 American and Filipino soldiers who surrendered to the
Japanese on the
Bataan
Peninsula
in 1942.
Exhausted and unfed,
the prisoners of war were forced to march most of the 100 miles to an
inland camp. Villagers who approached the prisoners with food and water
were "clubbed, stabbed, shot to death," Abie recalls.
"They're good people, and they loved the Americanos."
While estimates place
the death toll of the Bataan Death March at 10,000 to 20,000, Abie
chronicled hundreds more deaths in three years at Cabanatuan Camp. He kept
notes first on food can labels, later in tiny notebooks that American
mechanics who were forced to help the Japanese managed to smuggle to him.
When rescued in 1945, only 513 POWs had survived.
Abie's wife and three
young daughters spent the war in an internment camp, and just weeks after
they were reunited, MacArthur asked Abie to lead the effort to find the
bodies of Americans who'd died on the march or in the camps. His family
refused to return to the
United States
without him; they didn't
come home until 1948, to the small farm near
Butler
where Abie, now a
widower, still lives.
In recent years, Abie
has chronicled the unimaginable suffering in two books: "Ghost of
Bataan Speaks," in 1971, and "Oh, God, Where Are You?" in
1997. He's given "hundreds of speeches" -- as many as five in a
week -- to make sure younger generations know what life and liberty have
cost.
"I always tell
the kids, 'When you meet a veteran, shake his hand and thank him for his
sacrifice.' "
Abie's sacrifice
lasted long after the war. "The first body I dug up, I just
shook," he recalls. "But you just have to make up your mind and
do what's needed."
This is the
indomitable spirit of independence we celebrate.
Soldier
shared patriotism with youth
By
Reid R. Frazier and David Conti
Sunday,
July 3, 2005
When
he wasn't busy flying helicopters for the Special Forces, Maj. Steve Reich
made time to talk about patriotism with students at a Shaler school.
"You could hear a
pin drop when he spoke -- which is amazing for a group of eighth- and
ninth-graders," his aunt, Becky Shanko, an activities secretary at
Shaler
Intermediate
School
, said Saturday.
"You could just tell that he loved this country."
Reich, 34, was among
the 16 soldiers who died when a U.S. MH-47 Chinook helicopter crashed in
eastern
Afghanistan
last week.
"He was a hell of
a kid," recalled his uncle, Jerry Shanko, of Shaler. "It's just
a shame. It's just a shame for all those guys over there, but especially
when it hits so close to home."
Though he grew up in
Washington
,
Conn.
, Reich has family ties
to
Pittsburgh
. His mother, Suzanne, is
from
Penn Hills
. Most of the family
still lives in the
Pittsburgh
area, Jerry Shanko said.
This morning, all of
the churches in
Washington
,
Conn.
, plan to meet in one
place for a prayer service as the entire town mourns, Becky Shanko said.
On Monday, two Chinook helicopters will hover over the town's annual
Fourth of July festivities in Reich's honor.
"He was so
humble. If he knew all of this was being done for him, he'd be
mortified," his aunt said.
Reich was on his
fourth tour of duty when the U.S. Special Forces helicopter he was aboard
was shot down, according to relatives. He had been a company commander in
the 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment at Hunter Army Airfield in
Georgia
. He was married just
four months earlier.
As a young man, Reich
was a star pitcher for the U.S. Military Academy and represented Team
USA
in 1993 at the
World
University
games on a team that
included several future major leaguers. He pitched briefly in the
Baltimore Orioles system in 1996 before being recalled to active duty.
David McQuade,
principal at
Shaler
Intermediate
School
, recalled Reich's visit
as inspirational.
"What struck me
was that it wasn't about him. It was about what he was doing for the
country," McQuade said yesterday.
"This is someone
who dedicated his life to this country. When we lose one like this, it's
really quite heartbreaking," he said.
|