| Year | Player | Award |
| 2006 | Colin Parker | 2nd Team All League |
| 2006 | Anthony Weidman | Honorable Mention All League |
| 2006 | Colin Parker | CBW Most Valuable Player |
| 2006 | Alex Smith | CBW Most Improved |
| 2006 | Steve Hopkins | CBW Dedicated |
| 2006 | Kevin Eiser | CBW Longest Tenure |
| 2006 | Mike Ziegler | CBW Most Versitle |
| 2006 | Anthony Weidman | CBW JV Most Valuable Player |
| 2006 | Riley Down | CBW JV Most Dedicated Award |
| 2005 | Andrew Huynh | Suburban 1 All League |
| 2005 | Andrew Huynh | CBW Most Valuable Player |
| 2005 | Kevin Eiser | CBW Most Dedicated Award |
| 2005 | Mike Ziegler | CBW Most Improved Player |
| 2005 | Sam Bolstein | CBW JV Most Valuable Player |
| 2005 | Shane Moss | CBW JV Most Dedicated Award |
| 2005 | Kyle Smith | CBW JV Most Improved Player |
| 2004 | Chris Wilson | 2nd Team District One |
| 2004 | Bill Stanert | 3rd Team District One |
| 2004 | Chris Wilson | 1st Team National Conference |
| 2004 | John Booth | 2nd Team National Conference |
| 2004 | Pete Karasev | 3rd Team National Conference |
| 2004 | Chris Wilson | CBW Most Valuable Player |
| 2004 | Dan Roman | CBW Coaches Award |
| 2004 | Bill Stanert | CBW Most Improved Player |
| 2004 | Phil Saxby | CBW JV Most Valuable Player |
| 2004 | Kevin Eiser | CBW JV Most Improved Player |
| 2003 | Jon Williams | 1st Team District One |
| 2003 | Jarad Fonash | 2nd Team District One |
| 2003 | Jon Rose | 3rd Team District One |
| 2003 | Jarad Fonash | 1st Team National Conference |
| 2003 | Jon Williams | 1st Team National Conference |
| 2003 | Jon Rose | 2nd Team National Conference |
| 2003 | John Booth | 3rd Team National Conference |
| 2003 | Chris Wilson | 3rd Team National Conference |
| 2003 | Jon Williams | CBW Most Valuable Player |
| 2003 | Andrew Huynh | CBW Coaches Award |
| 2003 | Jarad Fonash | CBW Most Improved Player |
| 2003 | Mike Rose | CBW JV Most Valuable Player |
| 2002 | Jon Williams | 2nd Team District One |
| 2002 | Frank Sharp | 3rd Team District One |
| 2002 | Jon Williams | 1st Team National Conference |
| 2002 | Frank Sharp | 1st Team National Conference |
| 2002 | Jarad Fonash | 3rd Team National Conference |
| 2002 | Frank Sharp | CBW Most Valuable Player |
| 2002 | Jarad Fonash | CBW Most Improved Player |
| 2002 | Matt Dennis | CBW Coaches Award |
| 2002 | John Booth | CBW JV Most Valuable Player |
| 2002 | Chris Wilson | CBW JV Most Improved Player |
| 2001 | Dave Schmoyer | 3rd Team District One |
| 2001 | Scott Terry | 3rd Team District One |
| 2001 | Dave Schmoyer | 1st Team National Conference |
| 2001 | Scott Terry | 2nd Team National Conference |
| 2001 | Matt Wurtenberger | 3rd Team National Conference |
| 2001 | Jon Williams | 3rd Team National Conference |
| 2001 | Scott Terry | CBW Most Valuable Player |
| 2001 | Jon Williams | CBW Most Improved Player |
| 2001 | Frank Sharp | CBW Coaches Award |
| 2001 | Stehan Szygiel | CBW JV Most Valuable Player |
| 2001 | Matt Dennis | CBW JV Most Improved Player |
| 2000 | Kenny Eiser | 2nd Team All State |
| 2000 | Kenny Eiser | 1st Team District One |
| 2000 | Dan Schmoyer | 2nd Team District One |
| 2000 | Jason Jones | 3rd Team District One |
| 2000 | Kenny Eiser | 1st Team National Conference |
| 2000 | Dan Schmoyer | 2nd Team National Conference |
| 2000 | Jason Jones | 3rd Team National Conference |
| 2000 | Evan Chalk | 3rd Team National Conference |
| 2000 | Kenny Eiser | CBW Most Valuable Player |
| 2000 | Scott Terry | CBW Most Improved Player |
| 2000 | Scott Terry | CBW Coaches Award |
| 2000 | Evan Chalk | CBW Four year Varsity Award |
| 2000 | Jason Jones | CBW Three year Varsity Award |
| 2000 | Kenny Eiser | CBW Three year Varsity Award |
1999 | Kenny Eiser | 2nd Team District One |
| 1999 | Kenny Eiser | 1st Team American Conference |
| 1999 | Zach Rowand | 1st Team American Conference |
| 1999 | Dan Schmoyer | 1st Team American Conference |
| 1999 | Evan Chalk | Honorable Mention American Conference |
| 1999 | Kenny Eiser | The Intelligencer/Record Rookie of the year |
| 1999 | Kenny Eiser | CBW Most Valuable Player |
| 1999 | Dan Schmoyer | CBW Most Improved Player |
| 1999 | Zach Rowand | CBW Coaches Award |
| 1999 | Tim Frank | CBW Three year Varsity Award |
| 1998 | Kyle Chalk | 2nd Team All-State |
| 1997 | Chad Leuz | 3rd Team All-State |