All-Star Game Catchers
(Number of Starts & Reserves)
HOF Catchers List 19th Century League Awards Records Batting Fielding World Series All-Star Catchers Greatest Catchers 800 Games Caught Equipment Skills & Drills Articles Trivia Quiz Quotes Rotisserie AAGPBL Links Current Catchers Miscellaneous HOME Send an e-mail HOME  

The first All-Star Game was in 1933 and the AL/NL Managers chose the entire squad (Starters and Reserves) until 1946. From 1947 to 1957 Fans chose the Starters and from 1947 to the Present the Managers chose the Reserves. From 1958 to 1969 Players, Coaches and MLB Managers chose the Starters. Beginning in 1970 the Fans chose the Starters. Beginning in 2002 the Fans vote for the Final ASG slot for each League and if a catcher is selected then he becomes a Reserve.

Catcher   Starts Reserve Total Note
Ivan Rodriguez 12 2 14  
Yogi Berra 11 4 15 Hall-Of-Fame
Johnny Bench 10 3 13 Hall-Of-Fame
Mike Piazza 10 3 13  
Del Crandall 8 1 9  
Gary Carter 7 4 11 Hall-Of-Fame
Carlton Fisk 7 4 11 Hall-Of-Fame
Bill Freehan 7 4 11  
Bill Dickey 6 5 11 Hall-Of-Fame
Walker Cooper 6 2 8  
Roy Campanella 5 3 8 Hall-Of-Fame
Joe Torre 4 5 9 C until 1970 then 3B in 71-73
Earl Battey 4 0 4  
Ernie Lombardi 3 5 8 Hall-Of-Fame
Sandy Alomar Jr. 3 3 6  
Ed Bailey 3 3 6  
Gabby Hartnett 3 3 6 Hall-Of-Fame
Thurman Munson 3 3 6  
Joe Mauer 3 2 5 C in 1008-2010, 1B 2012
Benito Santiago 3 2 5  
Lance Parrish 2 6 8 Both A.L. & N.L.
Ted Simmons 2 6 8 Starts in Both A.L. & N.L.
Rick Ferrell 2 5 7 Hall-Of-Fame
Smoky Burgess 2 3 5 Both A.L. & N.L.
Rollie Hemsley 2 3 5  
Jorge Posada 2 3 5  
Buddy Rosar 2 3 5  
Terry Kennedy 2 2 4 Starts in Both A.L. & N.L.
Birdie Tebbetts 2 2 4  
Gus Triandos 2 2 4  
Yadier Molina 2 1 3  
Terry Steinbach 2 1 3  
John Romano 2 0 2  
Jimmie Wilson 2 0 2  
Elston Howard 1 8 9  
Brian McCann 1 5 6  
Frankie Hayes 1 4 5  
Bob Boone 1 3 4 Both A.L. & N.L.
Paul Lo Duca 1 3 4  
Mickey Owen 1 3 4  
Darrell Porter 1 3 4  
Darren Daulton 1 2 3  
Jason Kendall 1 2 3  
Javy Lopez 1 2 3  
Jason Varitek 1 2 3  
Jake Early 1 1 2  
Jerry Grote 1 1 2  
Russell Martin 1 1 2  
Mike Scioscia 1 1 2  
Alex Avila 1 0 1  
Mike Napoli 1 0 1  
Buster Posey 1 0 1  
Andy Seminick 1 0 1  
Geovany Soto 1 0 1  
Craig Biggio 0 7 7 C in 1991 then 2B in 92, 94-98
Sherm Lollar 0 7 7  
Jim Hegan 0 5 5  
Tony Pena 0 5 5  
Harry Danning 0 4 4  
Victor Martinez 0 4 4 DNP in 2010
Phil Masi 0 4 4  
Johnny Roseboro 0 4 4 Both A.L. & N.L.
John Stearns 0 4 4  
John Edwards 0 3 3  
Tom Haller 0 3 3  
Babe Phelps 0 3 3  
Manny Sanguillen 0 3 3  
Jim Sundberg 0 3 3  
Bruce Benedict 0 2 2  
Mickey Cochrane 0 2 2 Hall-Of-Fame
Jody Davis 0 2 2  
Bo Diaz 0 2 2 Both A.L. & N.L.
Bruce Edwards 0 2 2  
Andy Etchebarren 0 2 2  
Ray Fosse 0 2 2  
Rich Gedman 0 2 2  
Todd Hundley 0 2 2 Son of Randy
Charles Johnson 0 2 2  
Mike Lieberthal 0 2 2  
Stan Lopata 0 2 2  
Al Lopez 0 2 2  
Gus Mancuso 0 2 2  
Tim McCarver 0 2 2  
Clyde McCullough 0 2 2  
A.J. Pierzynski 0 2 2  
Ellie Rodriguez 0 2 2  
Mickey Tettleton 0 2 2  
Ozzie Virgil 0 2 2  
Wes Westrum 0 2 2  
Butch Wynegar 0 2 2  
Matt Wieters 0 2 2  
Toby Atwell 0 1 1  
Brad Ausmus 0 1 1  
Jose Azcue 0 1 1  
Bob Brenly 0 1 1  
John Buck 0 1 1  
Chris Cannizzaro 0 1 1  
Paul Casanova 0 1 1  
Dick Dietz 0 1 1  
Brian Downing 0 1 1  
Dave Duncan 0 1 1  
Dave Engle 0 1 1  
Johnny Estrada 0 1 1  
Darrin Fletcher 0 1 1  
Hank Foiles 0 1 1  
Ed Hermann 0 1 1  
Ramon Hernandez 0 1 1  
Randy Hundley 0 1 1 Father of Todd
Duane Josephson 0 1 1  
Ray Lamanno 0 1 1  
Tim Laudner 0 1 1  
Don Leppert 0 1 1  
Damian Miller 0 1 1  
Miguel Montero 0 1 1  
Jerry Moses 0 1 1  
Ray Mueller 0 1 1  
Dioner Navarro 0 1 1  
Jeff Newman 0 1 1  
Dave Nilsson 0 1 1  
Matt Nokes 0 1 1  
Ken O'Dea 0 1 1  
Greg Olson 0 1 1  
Tom Pagnozzi 0 1 1  
Biff Pocoroba 0 1 1  
Del Rice 0 1 1  
Aaron Robinson 0 1 1  
Carlos Ruiz 0 1 1  
Bob Schmidt 0 1 1  
Luke Sewell 0 1 1  
Hal Smith 0 1 1  
Mike Stanley 0 1 1  
Steve Swisher 0 1 1  
Gene Tenace 0 1 1  
Mike Tresh 0 1 1  
Hal Wagner 0 1 1  
Sammy White 0 1 1  
Ernie Whitt 0 1 1  
Dan Wilson 0 1 1  
Rudy York 0 1 1