Catching Near Perfect Games

No-Hitters That Fell Short of Perfection

(By a Walk, Error or Hit Batsman)


Pitcher Catcher Date Opponent Score
Cy Young (BOS-A) Lou Criger 6/30/1908 NY Yankees 8-0

Walked first batter of the game on a 3-2 count. The runner was then thrown out in a steal attempt by Criger and the next 26 batters were retired.

George Wiltse (NYG-N) Roger Bresnahan 7/4/1908 Phillies 1-0

Wiltze pitched 10 innings and only yielded one base runner when, with two outs in the ninth, he hit Phillies pitcher George McQuillan with a pitch.

Chief Bender (PHI-A) Ira Thomas 5/12/1910 Indians 4-0

With two out in the fourth, Bender walked Terry Turner who was thrown out trying to steal second by Thomas.

Ed Walsh (CHI-A) Bruno Block 8/27/1911 Red Sox 5-0

Walsh surrendered a base on balls to Clyde Engle on a 3-1 pitch to lead off the fourth inning..

Joe Bush (PHI-A) Val Picinich 8/26/1916 Indians 5-0

Bush walked first batter of game on a 3-1 count before retiring the next 27 batters.

Dutch Leonard (BOS-A) Wally Schang 6/3/1918 Tigers 5-0

Bobby Veach walked with two out in first inning.

Walter Johnson (WAS-A) Val Picinich 7/1/1920 Red Sox 1-0

Second baseman Bucky Harris committed an error on Harry Hooper's ground ball to leadoff the seventh inning. This was Val Picinich's second no-hitter & second near perfect catching game.

Jesse Barnes (NYG-N) Earl Smith 5/7/1922 Phillies 6-0

Walked first batter Cy Williams in the fifth inning on a 3-1 pitch.

Clyde Shoun (CIN-N) Ray Mueller 5/15/1944 Boston Braves 1-0

With two outs in the third, Shoun walked opposing pitcher Jim Tobin.

Bill McCahan (PHI-A) Buddy Rosar 9/3/1947 Senators 3-0

Stan Spence reached second base with one out in the second inning when first baseman Ferris Fain tossed wildly to McCahan after fielding an easy grounder.

Carl Erskine (BRO-N) Roy Campanella 6/19/1952 Cubs 5-0

With two outs in the third, Erskine walked pitcher Willard Ramsdell on four pitches.

Don Cardwell (CHI-N) Del Rice 5/15/1960 Cardinals 4-0

With one out in the first inning, Cardwell walked Alex Grammas.

Lew Burdette (MIL-N) Del Crandall 8/18/1960 Phillies 1-0

Burdette hit Tony Gonzalez with a pitch with one out in the fifth inning.

Bill Monbouquette (BOS-A) Jim Pagliaroni 8/1/1962 White Sox 1-0

Al Smith walked with two out in the fifth inning.

Jack Kralick (MIN-A) Earl Battey 8/26/1961 K.C. A's 1-0

Kralick walked pinch-hitter George Alusik on a 3-2 pitch with two out in the ninth.

Sandy Koufax (LA-N) Doug Camilli 6/4/1964 Phillies 3-0

Dick Allen drew a base on balls with two out in the fourth inning on a 3-2 pitch.

Dave Morehead (BOS-A) Bob Tillman 9/16/1965 Indians 2-0

Rocky Colavito walked on a 3-2 pitch to start the second inning.

Vida Blue (OAK-A) Gene Tenace 9/21/1970 Twins 6-0

Harmon Killebrew walked with two outs in the fourth inning.

Rick Wise (PHI-N) Tim McCarver 6/23/1971 Reds 4-0

With one out in the sixth inning, Wise walked Dave Concepcion.

Milt Pappas (CHI-N) Randy Hundley 9/2/1972 Padres 8-0

Walked pinch-hitter Larry Stahl with two outs in the ninth on a 3-2 pitch.

Steve (Jim) Busby (KC-A) Fran Healy 6/19/1974 Brewers 2-0

Leading off the second, George Scott fell behind in the count 2-0 before drawing a walk.

Dick Bosman (CLE-A) John Ellis 7/19/1974 Oakland A's 4-0

With two out in the fourth, Bosman committed an error when Sal Bando hit a slow roller between the third base line and the mound.

John Montefusco (SF-N) Gary Alexander 9/29/1976 Atlanta Braves 9-0

Walked Jerry Roster on a 3-1 pitch to leadoff the fourth inning.

Jerry Reuss (LA-N) Steve Yeager 6/27/1980 SF Giants 8-0

Throwing error by shortstop Bill Russell with two out in the first inning allowed Jack Clark to be the only Giants base runner.

Bob Forsch (STL-N) Darrell Porter 9/26/1983 Expos 3-0

Hit Gary Carter with two out in the second inning.

Terry Mulholland (PHI-N) Darren Daulton 8/15/1990 SF Giants 6-0

In the seventh inning, leadoff batter Rick Parker reached first base on a throwing error by third baseman Charlie Hayes.

Ramon Martinez (LA-N) Mike Piazza 7/14/1995 Marlins 7-0

Walked Tommy Gregg on a 3-2 pitch with two outs in the eighth inning.

Kevin Brown (FLA-N) Charles Johnson 6/10/1997 SF Giants 9-0

With two outs in the eighth inning, Brown hit pinch-batter Marvin Bernard on an 0-2 pitch.

Jonathan Sanchez (SF-N) Eli Whiteside 7/10/2009 SD Padres 8-0

In the eighth inning, the 2nd batter, Chase Headley reached first on a throwing error by third baseman Juan Uribe. No walks or hit batsmen in the game.


NOTES:
On June 23, 1917, Ernie Shore of the Red Sox relieved starting pitcher Babe Ruth after Ruth walked the game's first batter for the Senators. Ruth was thrown out of the game for arguing and punching home plate umpire Brick Owens. Shore came on in relief with a man on first and no outs. The base runner was thrown out by catcher Sam Agnew trying to steal second and Shore went on to retire the remaining 26 batters in order.


On May 30, 1977, Cleveland's Dennis Eckersley tossed a no-hitter against the California Angels allowing one batter to reach base on a walk, Tony Solaita with two outs in the first inning. Another batter (Bobby Bonds) reached base in the eighth after striking out, but reached first when Indians catcher Ray Fosse allowed the third strike pitch to get away from him.


On September 8, 1993, Astros pitch Darryl Kile fell one batter shy of pitching a perfect game and a shutout. Kile no-hit the Mets, but in the fourth inning, walked Jeff McKnight with one out. After the next batter flied out, Kile uncorked a wild pitch that allowed McKnight to get to second. First baseman Jeff Bagwell retrieved the ball and threw to third to get McKnight who was still running. Bagwell's throw was wild and McKnight went on to score a run on a walk, wild pitch and error.

 
For a Complete List of No-Hitters see NO HITTERS



Hall Of Fame Catchers List of Catchers All-Star Catchers Post Season League Awards Batting Fielding Records Greatest Catcher 800 Games Caught HOME - Front Page Equipment Skills & Drills Articles About Catchers Trivia Quizes Quotes Rotisserie All-American Girls Professional Baseball Links 19th Century Current Catchers Ex-Catcher Managers Feedback HOME - Front Page HOME - Front Page Miscellaneous