Catcher |
PB | GmC | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Earl Grace (1929-1937) | 12 | 557 | |
2 | Johnny Estrada (2001-nn) | 15 | 571 | |
3 | Marc Hill (1973-1986) | 17 | 687 | |
4 | John Wathan (1976-1985) | 19 | 572 | |
5 | Gene Desautels (1930-1946) | 19 | 699 | |
6 | Mike Redmond (1998-) | 20 | 591 | |
7 | Jeff Newman (1976-1984) | 20 | 513 | |
8 | Charlie O'Brien (1985-2000) | 21 | 782 | |
9 | Eddie Perez (1995-2005) | 22 | 501 | |
10 | B.J. Surhoff (1987-2005) | 24 | 704 |
Catcher |
PB | GmC | PB/Gm | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Buddy Rosar (1939-1951) | 28 | 934 | .0300 | |
2 | Brad Ausmus (1993-nn) | 55 | 1810 | .0304 | |
3 | Dan Wilson (1992-2005) | 41 | 1281 | .0320 | |
4 | Sherm Lollar (1946-1963) | 53 | 1571 | .0337 | |
5 | Al Lopez (1928-1947) | 66 | 1918 | .0344 | |
6 | Ray Mueller (1935-1951) | 32 | 917 | .0349 | |
7 | Chris Hoiles (1989-1998) | 29 | 819 | .0354 | |
8 | Phil Masi (1939-1952) | 39 | 1101 | .0354 | |
9 | Rick Dempsey (1969-1992) | 61 | 1633 | .0374 | |
10 | Clyde McCullough (1940-1956) | 37 | 989 | .0374 |
Catcher |
PB | GmC | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Joe Sugden (1893-1912) | 100 | 708 | |
2 | Morgan Murphy (1890-1901) | 108 | 550 | |
3 | Mike Grady (1894-1906) | 110 | 525 | |
4 | Boileryard Clarke (1893-1905) | 128 | 739 | |
5 | John Grim (1888-1899) | 151 | 578 | |
6 | Heinie Peitz (1892-1913) | 163 | 958 | |
7 | Charlie Ganzel (1884-1897) | 180 | 578 | |
8 | Jack Ryan (1889-1913) | 182 | 526 | |
9 | Pop Schriver (1886-1901) | 194 | 654 | |
10 | Malachi Kittridge (1890-1906) | 201 | 1196 |
Catcher |
PB | GmC | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Pop Snyder (1873-1891) | 877 | 744 | |
2 | Silver Flint (1875-1889) | 602 | 743 | |
3 | Doc Bushong (1875-1890) | 553 | 668 | |
4 | Deacon McGuire (1884-1912) | 495 | 1609 | |
5 | Wilbert Robinson (1886-1902) | 491 | 1316 | |
6 | Jack Clements (1884-1900) | 417 | 1073 | |
7 | King Kelly (1878-1893) | 417 | 583 | |
8 | Bill Holbert (1876-1888) | 409 | 538 | |
9 | Jocko Milligan (1884-1893) | 407 | 585 | |
10 | Barney Gilligan (1875-1888) | 377 | 459 |
Catcher |
PB | GmC | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Lance Parrish (1977-1995) | 192 | 1818 | |
2 | Ted Simmons (1968-1988) | 182 | 1771 | |
3 | Benito Santiago (1986-2005) | 157 | 1917 | |
4 | Ernie Lombardi (1931-1947) | 152 | 1544 | |
5 | Steve O'Neill (1911-1928) | 145 | 1532 | |
6 | Rick Ferrell (1929-1947) | 142 | 1806 | |
7 | Frankie Hayes (1933-1947) | 139 | 1311 | |
8 | Gus Triandos (1953-1965) | 138 | 992 | |
9 | Tim McCarver (1959-1980) | 132 | 1387 | |
10 | Wally Schang (1913-1931) | 131 | 1435 |
Catcher |
PB | GmC | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Ed Whiting (1882 Bal-AA) | 105 | 72 | |
2 | Bill Traffley (1885 Bal-AA) | 104 | 61 | |
3 | Mike Hines (1883 Bos-NL) | 99 | 59 | |
Pop Snyder (1881 Bos-NL) | 99 | 60 | ||
5 | Sleeper Sullivan (1882 Stl-AA) | 97 | 51 | |
6 | Doc Bushong (1886 Cle-NL) | 95 | 62 | |
Fred Carroll (1886 Pit-AA) | 95 | 70 | ||
8 | Jackie Hayes (1883 Pit-AA) | 93 | 62 | |
9 | Charlie Reilley (1879 Tro-NL) | 89 | 49 | |
10 | Wilbert Robinson (1886 Phi-AA) | 87 | 61 |
Catcher |
PB | GmC | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Geno Petralli (1987 Tex-AL) | 35 | 63 | |
2 | J.C. Martin (1965 Chi-AL) | 33 | 112 | |
3 | Earl Williams (1972 Atl-NL) | 28 | 116 | |
4 | Gus Triandos (1959 Bal-AL) | 28 | 125 | |
5 | Ted Simmons (1975 Stl-NL) | 28 | 154 | |
6 | Bob Didier (1969 Atl-NL) | 27 | 114 | |
7 | Mike MacFarlane (1995 Bos-AL) | 26 | 111 | |
8 | John Henry (1911 Was-AL) | 25 | 51 | |
9 | Bob Uecker (1967 Atl-NL) | 25 | 59 | |
10 | Nig Clarke (1907 Cle-AL) | 25 | 115 | |
11 | Dick Dietz (1970 SF-NL) | 25 | 139 | |
12 | Jason Varitek (1999 Bos-AL) | 25 | 140 |
Catcher |
PB | GmC | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Johnny Estrada (2004 Atl-NL) | 0 | 133 | |
Brian Schneider (2004 Mon-NL) | 0 | 133 | ||
3 | Al Todd (1937 Pit-NL) | 0 | 128 | |
4 | Bill Dickey (1931 NY-AL) | 0 | 125 | |
5 | Darrell Porter (1975 Mil-AL) | 0 | 124 | |
6 | Johnny Bench (1975 Cin-NL) | 0 | 121 | |
7 | Toby Hall (2004 TB-AL) | 0 | 119 | |
8 | Al Lopez (1941 Pit-NL) | 0 | 114 | |
9 | John Flaherty (1995 Det-AL) | 0 | 112 | |
10 | Milt May (1977 Det-AL) | 0 | 111 |
The
short answer is yes. For the data availability period of 1967-68 (A.L.
only)
and 1969, 1974-2001 (N.L. & A.L.) there were 15 such
events:
Date Game & Score Inn Outs Catcher - Pitcher
8/8/1967 CHI (1) @ DET (2) 10 2 J.C. Martin - Hoyt
Wilhelm
4/30/1969 CHI (2) @ KC (3) 9 2 Duane Josephson - Wilbur
Wood
9/24/1974 ATL (1) @ LA (2) 10 2 Johnny Oates - Phil
Niekro
6/12/1975 CLE (1) @ KC (2) 10 1 John Ellis - Eric
Raich
9/17/1976 LA (0) @ ATL (1) 12 1 Ellie Rodriguez - Charlie
Hough
6/14/1977 PIT (2) @ LA (3) 9 1 Ed Ott - Goose
Gossage
7/23/1978 CAL (3) @ DET (4) 9 2 Brian Downing - Dyar Miller
6/5/1979 SF (4) @ STL (5) 9 0 Mike Sadek - Randy Moffitt
4/26/1986
CIN (0) @ HOU (1) 9 1 Bo Diaz - Bill Gullickson
6/16/1986 TEX (1) @ CAL
(2) 9 2 Orlando Mercado - Charlie Hough
9/20/1986 CHI (7) @ CAL (8)
9 1 Ron Karkovice - Dave Schmidt
10/5/1986 MON (1) @ PHI (2) 10 1 Dann
Bilardello - Curtis Brown
7/5/1989 CIN (2) @ PHI (3) 10 1 Jeff Reed -
John Franco
4/17/1991 TOR (4) @ DET (5) 10 2 Pat Borders - Duane
Ward
5/28/1993 CLE (6) @ MIN (7) 9 0 Lance Parrish - Eric Plunk
A quick scan of the list will show that several knuckleballers were on
the
mound at the time of the PB and that no catcher suffered the indignity
more
than once (during the data period). Detroit captured the honors of
benefiting
the most times (3) from the E-2 muff while the White Sox were
bitten three
times. Except for 1986, when the event happened four times, the
PB Scoring the
game-ending winning run only happened once (or none) in the
years in the data
spread. In only 1 of the 15 games were the bases loaded at
the time of the PB
and that was the ATL-LAN game on 9/24/1974. One special
game from the above
group was the 1986 near no-hitter between CAL &
TEX.
-------------------------------
Briefly that game's last inning &
last play were:
Charlie Hough (the Texas knuckleballer) was on the mound
and had a no-hitter
going into the bottom of the 9th the score TEX 1 CAL
0.
Ruppert Jones (pinch hitting for Bob Boone) called out on strikes [OUT
1]
Jack Howell (batting for Gary Pettis) reached on a three base error by
George
Wright and advanced to 3rd base.
Wally Joyner singled (FIRST HIT OF
THE GAME) scoring Howell to tie the game
1-1.
Catcher Mercado allowed a
passed ball (DeCinces batting) allowing Joyner to
move to 2nd.
DeCinces
struck out [OUT 2]
Reggie Jackson was walked intentionally.
George
Hendrick struck out [OUT 3], but Orlando Mercado allowed a Passed Ball
on the
SO and Joyner scored from second when Charlie Hough failed to
cover
home.
Final Score CAL 2 TEX 1 (Hough threw a 1-hitter and lost on
the Passed Ball).
-------------------------------
For the above 15
Catchers who allowed a Passed Ball to score the game-ending
winning run here
are their PB totals for the years that their ignoble events
occurred and how
many by their battery mate (in the PB Scoring Winning
Run
game):
Year PB Catcher
1967 16 J.C. Martin (6 of
them thrown by Hoyt Wilhelm)
1969 9 Duane Josephson (4 of them thrown
by Wilbur Wood)
1974 15 Johnny Oates (8 thrown by Phil
Niekro)
1975 7 John Ellis (1 thrown by Eric Raich - the event
ball)
1976 3 Ellie Rodriguez (3 thrown by Charlie Hough)
1977
8 Ed Ott (1 thrown by Goose Gossage - the event ball)
1978 2 Brian
Downing (1 thrown by Dyar Miller - the event ball)
1979 9 Mike Sadek
(2 thrown by Randy Moffitt)
1986 6 Orlando Mercado (5 thrown by
Charlie Hough)
1986 5 Ron Karkovice (1 thrown by Dave Schmidt - the
event ball)
1986 12 Bo Diaz (2 thrown by Bill Gullickson)
1986
6 Dann Bilardello (1 thrown by Curtis Brown - the event ball)
1989
5 Jeff Reed (2 thrown by John Franco)
1991 13 Pat Borders (2 thrown
by Duane Ward)
1993 3 Lance Parrish (1 thrown by Eric Plunk - the
event ball)
To flip the coin over, I now present the above pitcher's PB
totals when they
were on the mound for the years of the ignoble
events.
Year PB Pitcher
1967 10 Hoyt Wilhelm (6 muffed by
J.C. Martin)
1969 16 Wilbue Wood (4 muffed by Duane
Josephson)
1974 20 Phil Niekro (8 muffed by Johnny Oates)
1975
2 Eric Raich (1 muffed by John Ellis)
1976 6 Charlie Hough (1
muffed by Ellie Rodriguez)
1977 1 Goose Gossage (1 muffed by Ed Ott -
the event ball)
1978 1 Dyar Miller (1 muffed by Brian Downing - the
event ball)
1979 2 Randy Moffitt (2 by Mike Sadek)
1986 17
Charlie Hough (5 muffed by Orlando Mercado)
1986 1 Dave Schmidt (1
muffed by Ron Karkovice - the event ball)
1986 2 Bill Gullickson (2
muffed by Bo Diaz)
1986 1 Curtis Brown (1 muffed by Dann Bilardello -
the event ball)
1989 2 John Franco (2 muffed by Jeff Reed)
1991
2 Duane Ward (2 muffed by Pat Borders)
1993 1 Eric Plunk (1 muffed
by Lance Parrish - the event ball)
The total Passed Balls for MLB for the
above years (1967 A.L. only) and the
Catcher - Pitcher leaders in PBs (not
just battery mates):
Year PB Catcher(s) - Pitcher(s)
Leaders
1967 161 J.C. Martin & Joe Azcue (16) - Hoyt Wilhelm
(10)
1969 463 Bob Didier (27) - Phil Niekro (24)
1974 348 Fran
Healy (21) - Bruce DalCanton (22) - (20 w/Healy)
1975 352 Ted Simmons
(27) - Phil Niekro (24)
1976 306 Ed Hermann (13) - Phil Niekro
(26)
1977 289 Joe Ferguson (16) - Phil Niekro (34)
1978 301
Joe Nolan (14) - Phil Niekro (38)
1979 341 Lance Parrish (20) - Phil
Niekro (25)
1986 365 John Russell (17) - Charlie Hough
(17)
1989 333 Chad Kreuter (20) - Charlie Hough (15)
1991
369 Lance Parrish (19) - Tom Candiotti (17)
1993 366 Benito Santiago
(23) - Charlie Hough (17)
Clearly the knuckleballers caused (?) the
majority of the Passed Balls during
the period analyzed, although many
"straight forward" pitchers had their PB
troubles as well. On the other hand,
the catchers who led the majors in PB not
always could lay blame on the
knuckleballers. The majority of the catcher
leaders didn't pair up with a
knuckleballer when they led the MLB in PBs.