|
Last Updated: 03/15/04 06:40 PM
From:
arthur.teuscher@diab.ch
Sent:
Tuesday, April 06, 1999 3:01 AM
To: 'dggroves@earthlink.net'
Subject: beef insulin
and prions BSE
Dear Dave, here are some statements and
informations for you:
1. Adverse Drug Events ADA Acute death
(dead-in-bed-syndrome) is not rare in younger
diabetics, already before age 20! Thordarsonn
(ref. Diab. Med) (1) from
Norway states that we have to live with the fact
that about 6%(in the age group < 40) of all
death will have to be accepted as a cause of
insulin hypoglycemia. Thordarson works and lives
in a country where 100% of insulin is human. In
the whole of Scandinvavia national health
services are responsible for this deal (price
reduction?) taking place in 1988 in a very short
time.
2. I found out some time ago that (at least
one major HM insulin producer) genetically DNA
transferred E coli are cultured on the best
substrate for them: beef broth in gelatine -
ideal for prions.
Best regards
Arthur Teuscher
1. Sovik
O, Thordarson H, Diabetes Care 1999
Mar;22 Suppl 2:B40-2
---- Response ----
From: Dave Groves [dggroves@earthlink.net]
Sent: Tuesday, April 06, 1999 11:09 AM
To: diabetic@Lehigh. EDU; arthur.teuscher@diab.ch
Subject: RE: beef insulin and prions BSE
This is fascinating, Dr. Teuscher. Since Eli
Lilly holds the patents on the E. Coli rDNA
process it really seems to make them absolute
hypocrites for their raising the nonsensical BSE
risk charges against beef insulin with the FDA.
For the FDA to use the BSE arguments in their
letter to me shows just how far off the mark
they are on this issue. (I am going to publish
their letter to me as soon as I can.)
On the "dead in bed" matter, I am
staggered. I knew it was becoming a recognized
problem but had no idea that it was up to such
intolerable levels.
The DCCT group has admitted that 4-13% of
diabetic deaths are now due to "iatrogenic
hypoglycemia accidents" but are blaming
"tight control." It seems totally
ironic that "human" now appears to be
a proximate cause for all of the "other
causes" of hypoglycemia unawareness.
- As Jenny Hirst has suggested, the 4 hour
shift in "peak" activity for N
(isophane) and L (Lente) that the ADA
had denied for 15+ years, would
certainly cause the unexpected hypos
that have been linked to unawareness in
many studies.
- Lilly expressly warns that
"intensive therapy" (as
opposed to low A1c) which they define as
taking 3 or more injections per day,
causes less pronounced warning symptoms.
The ADA table shows that even human UL
will not reliably cover a diabetic for a
full 24 hour period meaning that the
only way a diabetic can expect to
achieve any level of reasonable control
is through using 3 or more injections if
human insulin is used.
- Even folks, like Dr. Bernstein, who
suggest that the total amount of and/or
speed of decrease in BG is a primary
symptom generator may eventually realize
that the inherent instability noted in
human by many who have compared human to
"animal," need to recognize
that there isn't just a single cause of
the unawareness problem. It certainly is
NOT duration of diabetes or neuropathy
all by itself, and it would appear that
human insulin, by its molecular
structure requires the user to expose
himself to a number of the
"other" risk factors.
- The "change" from animal to
human is clearly fraught with danger,
but I can see no reason or mechanism by
which human would be any more dangerous
for those started on animal than for
those started on human. The
"new" symptom list is a joke.
Most of the
"new" early warning symptoms
were defined as late stage signs of
hypoglycemia for years. Tragically, they
do the diabetic no good at all and may
actually serve to prevent his taking
appropriate corrective actions at the
first stages of hypoglycemia.
I have placed a link to your site at http://www.diab.ch/~teuscher/index.htm
on the links page of my site at http://members.tripod.com/diabetics_world
and will be adding it to my site shortly.
Clicking on the link below will take you to
"My Story" on Diabetics_World. I am
trying to get the copy on all 20 of the articles
I cite in that research piece so that I can set
them out as I have the Heine article and one of
the two Lesser articles. It seems to me that
having "read cite" buttons as I have
done on those two cites is a truly effective way
to teach the lessons we, apparently, must teach.
If you could transmit me, either hardcopy or
electronically, a copy of your work, "HYPOGLYCEMIA
UNAWARENESS IN DIABETICS TRANSFERRED FROM
BEEF/PORCINE INSULIN TO HUMAN INSULIN" A.
Teuscher and W. G. Berger, LANCET, p. 382-85,
August 15,1987, I would greatly appreciate being
able to include it. In composing my site, I've
not had much time for reviewing other sites that
deal with this important issue. If this and/or
any of your other articles are already available
on your site, the easiest method might be just
to link my pages to your articles on your site
(though that would keep me from bookmarking to
the precise location from which my cites
derive). If you can help me get in touch with
any of the other authors I cite, I will be
forever in your debt (not that I am not
already.)
Dave Groves
dggroves@earthlink.net
http://members.tripod.com/diabetics_world
(In discussions with
the author of the cited article, it was
clarified that the abstract reciting 2-6
"dead in bed syndrome deaths" per
100,000 years was, apparently a clerical
error. The actual is 2-6 in 10,000
diabetic years.)
|