We had a branch of the Kitchs who, instead of moving to Mercer County, Pennsylvania, instead moved into the New Philadelphia / Dover, Tuscarawas, Ohio area around 1810 - 1815.  What follows are raw notes on them, from one day back in 1992 at the New Philadelphia library.

Jacob Kitch moved to Tuscarawas about 1810.

Jacob Kitch: On 4/8/1832, 67 persons partook in Communion [Lutheran Church alternated with Presbyterian], and 2 years later when it numbered 145 people, they decided to build a church (cornerstone laid 9/11/1834.) Building committee was Rev Greenwald, Judge Peter Williams, Charles Korns, JACOB KITCH, and Dr. Stough. Jacob KITCH was Sheriff from 1833 – 7.

David Kitch (died 1857): Miss Christina KITCH, daughter of DAVID and Lydia KITCH, who were early settlers of Tuscarawas County and came from Pennsylvania. Marriage to John Judy occurred 10/16/1864; she died 8/27/1869.

Martin Kitch: Township no. 9, R no. 3 Dover Township – 1875 had 145.5 acres in Plot 3; had 81.5 acres in York Twp. Lower ½, right ¼ of no. 7

John Cribbs: In 1850 Simon A. Myer married Catherine M., daughter of John & Anna B. Kitch Cribbs. Catherine M. was born 6/17/1830 in Goshen, but her parents were natives of Pennsylvania, whence they came to Tuscarawas at a much earlier date.

Above from Historical Atlas of Tuscarawas County, Ohio, published 1875 &1908 (combined volume), original published by L. H. Everts & Co., Philadelphia (1875). Volume in genealogy section of New Philadelphia Library
From History of Tuscarawas County, published 1884 in Chicago, by Warner Beers & Co.  Reprinted by Unigraphic Inc., Evansville, Ill. In 1972, we have:

J. W. KITCH: Goshen Twp. New school built 3/25/1850. J. W. Kitch was a teacher there. (Pg. 475)

David KITCH – Infirmary Director from 1853 – 6 (Pg. 367)

Justice of the Peace in Goshen twp. In 1833 was Jacob KITCH (Pg. 500)

David KITCH – (John Frey, farmer, on Reheboth Rd. In Goshen Twp., born Berne, Switz. – His father came in 1848 and bought 70 acres of land from Jesse Landes and 90 acres from David KITCH

Index of Wills in Tuscarawas County 1809 – 1902 by Ruth Dunlap, 6/1981 – Shelf Reference 312.5 at genealogy section of New Philadelphia Library

In Wills Book 6, Pg. 104 is the Will of Martin KITCH

Tuscarawas County Ohio Marriages 1808 – 1844 (from books 1, 2, 3) by Tuscarawas Genealogical Society, Inc. Found genealogy section of New Philadelphia Library

Name

Name

Date

Off.

Pg.

Ret.

David KITCH

Lydia Landes

1/17/1841

57

383

3060

David KITCH

Rebecca Landes

7/5/1821

17

52

416

John W KITCH

Susan Lang

4/20/1843

40

433

3460

Martin KITCH

Eliz. Coyle

6/2/1842

40

423

3378

Martin G. KITCH

Barbara Stickle

1/27/1842

65

413

3297

Anne KITCH

John Cribbs

10/12/1824

17

84

669

Anne KITCH

John Weldy

10/25/1825

17

97

769

Barbara KITCH

Frederick Mouse

2/19/1835

40

240

1919

Catherine Ann KITCH

Wm. Biddinger

10/19/1843

126

466

3725

Eliza KITCH

Francis Foster

5/1/1844

40

481

3842

Elizabeth KITCH

Adam Stickle

6/9/1842

65

425

3396

Sarah KITCH

Geo. Metzger

5/5/1842

141

411

3284
From Book 4, same source

Name

Name

Date

Off.

Pg.

Ret.

Daniel KITCH

Hannah Burnhill

6/12/1851

4

248

6079

David KITCH

Eliza McFerson

9/21/1851

40

253

6138

Geo. KITCH

Mary Unker

2/22/1852

12

268

6277

Jesse KITCH

Jane Eberhard

11/14/1850

4

227

5880

John W. KITCH

Catharine Shetler

3/14/1850

12

269

6289

William H. KITCH

Lydia Miller

11/24/1850

219

229

5894

Wm. Buraway

J. KITCH

9/20/1845

36

29

4371

Jesse Snyder

Kesiah KITCH

5/7/1846

7

50

4549

John KITCH

June Ervin

7/11/1856

547

157

7805

A. W. Linaberry

Almina KITCH

4/22/1858

374

211

8272

Andr. W. Linaberry

Barbara A. KITCH

7/27/1852

4

1

6356

Christian Burns

Eliz KITCH

6/22/1855

329

112

7376

Jacob Huck

Mary KITCH

9/10/1856

370

154

7776
Tuscarawas County, Ohio Cemeteries Vol. VII, City of New Philadelphia, by Tuscarawas Genealogical Society found genealogy section of New Philadelphia Library

Pg. 231 KITCH child of J. W. & S [probably Susan Long-JBG] 5/20/1853 (old part Block D)
Pg. 231 KITCH Jacob 5/13/1794 – 2/14/1858 (old part Block D)
Pg. 232KITG?? Lydia w/David 5/13/18?? 36yrs. 6m. (old part Block D)
They are buried at Fair Ave. Cemetery – G0151 – Oldest in New Philadelphia – From Square, take No. Broadway for 1 block to Fair Ave., turn right and go east

Tuscarawas County, Ohio Cemeteries Vol. II Dover Twp., by Tuscarawas Genealogical Society found genealogy section of New Philadelphia Library

KITCH Elizabeth wife of J. Martin 3/14/1798 – 8/18/1889 (91y 3 m 3 d)
J. Martin 3/17/1871 (91 y 1 m 20 d) [birth 1/25/1780-JBG]
Above at Crooked Run United Methodist Church Cemetery – D061 – Dover Twp.  Take county Rd #21 South from New Philadelphia. I-77 interchange at State 39 for 1 mile, turn right on County #52, go about 3 miles to the Church

We also find in Volume 4 (1847) of the Tuscarawas County Will Books the names Harbaugh, McLean and Bigler. My notes not great here, but names appearing are Anna Morris McLean, Jennet McLean, Joseph Bigler, William McLean as nephew of Anna Morris McLean and he is the brother of Alexander A. McLean.