Frank Chance (1B), elected 1919 view profile
Fred Clarke (CF), elected 1919 view profile
Billy Hamilton  (CF), STLN elected 1913 view profile
Willie Keeler  (CF), BRO elected 1915 view profile
Nap Lajoie  (2B), elected 1918 view profile
Dan McGann  (1B), elected 1916 view profile
Joe McGinnity  (P), elected 1918 view profile
Deacon Phillippe  (P), elected 1916 view profile
Cy Seymour  (LF), elected 1917 view profile
Jimmy Slagle  (CF), elected 1917 view profile
Chick Stahl (LF), elected 1919 view profile
Jesse Tannehill  (P), elected 1917 view profile
Roy Thomas  (RF), elected 1917 view profile
Fred Tenney (1B), elected 1916 view profile
Cy Young (P), PHIA elected 1912 view profile

Frank Kitson  (P), eligible 1916 view profile
Ned Garvin (P), eligible 1918 view profile
Red Donahue (P), eligible 1918 view profile

John McGraw (3B), eligible 1920
Danny Green (RF), eligible 1920
Honus Wagner (SS), eligible 1920
Eddie Plank (P), eligible 1920
Ginger Beaumont (CF), eligible 1920
Danny Murphy (2B), eligible 1920
Pop Foster (LF), eligible 1920
Mordecai Brown (P), eligible 1920
Johnny Kling (C), eligible 1920
Bill Donnovan (P), eligible 1920
Mike O'Neill (P), eligible 1920
Case Patten (P), eligible 1920
Elmer Stricklett (P), eligible 1920
Emmett Heidrick (CF), eligible 1921
Jack Chesbro (P), eligible 1921
Nixey Callahan (P), eligible 1921
George Browne (LF), eligible 1921
Chick Stahl (1B), eligible 1921
Harry Bay (LF), eligible 1921
Rube Vickers (P), eligible 1921
Harry McIntire (P), eligible 1921

Cy Morgan (P), eligible 1922
Vic Willis (P), eligible 1922
Elmer Flick (RF), eligible 1922
Jimmy Sheckard (RF), eligible 1922
Ed Seiver (P), eligible 1922
Doc Gessler (Lf), eligible 1922
Roger Bresnahan (C), eligible 1922
Gus Dorner (P), eligible 1922
Tom Hughes (P), eligible 1922
George Mullin (P), eligible 1923
John Titus (RF), eligible 1923
Matty McIntyre (LF), eligible 1923
Art Devlin (3B), eligible 1923
Dode Paskert (RF), eligible 1923
Mike Donlin (LF), eligible 1923
Carl Lundgren (P), eligible 1923
Miller Huggins (2B), eligible 1923
Doc White (P), eligible 1923
George Stone (CF), eligible 1923
Jim Delahanty (3B), eligible 1923
Noodles Hahn (P), eligible 1924
Howie Camnitz (P), eligible 1924
Rube Waddell (P), eligible 1924
Bob Rhoads (P), eligible 1924
Irv Young (P), eligible 1924
Bob Wicker (P), eligible 1924
Patsy Dougherty (LF), eligible 1924
Christy Mathewson (P), eligible 1924

1910: E.Burke(9), J.Burkett(3), H.Duffy(4), T.Daly(0)
1911: S.Brodie(0), E.Burke(8), C.Child(1), J.Grim(0), H.Reitz(2)
1912: E.Burke(7), B.Dahlen(1), E.Delahanty(2), J.McCarthy(0), C.Young(12)
1913: J.Beckley(9), E.Burke(5), K.Carsey(5), G.Davis(4), C.Fraser(1), B.Hamilton(13),
    C.Lachance(5), K.Nichols(11), S.Seybold(0)
1914: J.Beckley(8), J.Collins(2), H.Long(8), K.Nichols(7)
1915: J.Anderson(0), J.Beckley(6), T.Breitenstein(0), C.Fraser(1), C.Griffith(0),
    P.Hawley(0), W.Keeler(13), S.Leever(1), H.Long(4), S.Mertes(0), K.Nichols(6), F.Tenney(9)
1916: J.Beckley(6), K.Douglas(1), T.Hartsel(3), B.Keister(6), F.Kitson(8), H.Jennings(3),
    T.Lewis(2), E.McFarland(0), D.McGann(14), K.Nichols(4), D.Phillippe(16), F.Tenney(12)
1917: J.Beckley(6), H.Davis(2), B.Keister(0), F.Kitson(10), N.Lajoie(9), A.Orth(1), A.Rusie(4),
    C.Seymour(16), J.Slagle(14), E.Smith(1), R.Thomas(13), J.Tannehill(13), J.Taylor(3)
1918: selected by president (no votes) N.Lajoie, J.McGinnity
1919: F.Chance(14), F.Clarke(12), G.DeMontreville(5), R.Donahue(6), N.Garvin(7), J.Kelley(2),
    F.Kitson(7), B.Lange(2), W.Piatt(5), K.Selbach(4), C.Stahl(16), J.Weimer(1), J.Williams(5)