Make your own free website on Tripod.com
Last updated 29 April 2001

HOME

Ties Talk Index

Culture Directory

JA*Net

NAJC

JA*Net Ties Talk
Mottainai

Subject: Mottainai

'Mottainai', an old-fashioned Japanese value that is familiar to most Nikkei-jin, seems to have been forgotten in modern Japan, to the point that a food recycling law had to be introduced recently. North Americans who have spent expat time in Japan tell stories of being able to nicely furnish entire apartments with the things today's Japanese people throw away.

The op ed piece below from the Yomiuri Shimbun warns of the consequences of forgetting this aspect of Japanese heritage.

'Mottainai' holds key to food conservation

By Masaharu Asaba

About a quarter of the food served at wedding receptions is left on plates and thrown away, according to a survey released by the Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries Ministry shortly before the food recycling law went into effect on 01 April, 2001.

Most Japanese people over a certain age would describe such wastefulness as "mottainai." It will be extremely mottainai if that word, as well as a concept it represents, is discarded like leftover food.

Mottainai is often used in everyday life to describe wastefulness. For example, throwing away clothes is mottainai if they still can be worn. Japanese language dictionaries define mottainai as:

  • "A regrettable situation in which something is treated wastefully or is not effectively utilized."
    (Sanseido Co.'s Daijirin.)

  • "A regrettable situation in which something is wasted without its value being fully utilized."
    (Iwanami Shoten's Kojien.)

  • "A situation in which something still usable is thrown away, something dispensable is used, or someone who can still work has not yet displayed his or her ability."
    (Shogakkan's Kokugo Daijiten.).

    It is not easy to translate mottainai into English.

    There is a story about translating the word into English. When officials of the former Environment Agency explained the meaning of mottainai to Morris Strong, secretary general of the Earth Summit conference in 1992, Strong suggested, after a little thought, that "sophisticated modesty" might be an appropriate translation, given its spirit.

    Mottainai is different from "kechi" (stingy). Mottainai fully recognizes the value, ability or cultural nature inherent in things. It contains a strong message that things should not be wasted. I remember a number of occasions in my childhood when I was scolded by my parents with "mottainai!" for my wastefulness. The word was so strongly instilled in me that I flinched every time my parents uttered the word.

    The concept of mottainai was deeply rooted in the everyday life of ordinary Japanese people during the Edo period (1603-1868). Cotton kimono were washed and dyed time and again until they were worn out. After the clothes shrank from repeated washing, they were used to make clothes for children. When they were worn out, they were used as washcloths or mats. When they became tattered, they were burned, and the ash was spread over the vegetable fields. The ash helped the to promote new life.

    It was a perfect recycling society, nothing was wasted. This spirit was more or less maintained in Japan until the end of World War II.

    We cannot blame the disruption of the tradition merely on the influence of U.S. culture, which extols mass production and mass consumption.

    Let us return to the issue of leftover food.

    The Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries Ministry recently conducted a survey on 1,000 households and 3,560 business operators, including restaurants, about food wastage. The amount of food discarded was highest at wedding receptions, at 23.9 percent, which far outnumbered 7.7 percent at households and 3.6 percent at restaurants.

    The food recycling law requires food-processing and food-distribution companies, restaurants and other businesses, which potentially discard excess food, to recycle at least 20 percent of food destined for garbage dumps.

    We must keep it in mind that more than half of the food consumed in this country is imported. Japan annually imports 2.7 million tons of grain, or 73 percent of the national requirement.

    The country also relies on imports for 20 percent of its vegetables and 50 percent of its meat and fruit products. A large quantity of quality seafood products are also imported. However, the supply of imported food supplies is inextricably linked to a number of global environmental problems.

    Firstly, by importing food we are exhausting foreign countries' valuable water resources.

    The production of 1 ton of wheat requires 1,000 tons of fresh water. This equates to Japan, despite having plentiful reserves of fresh water, importing 27 billion tons of water from the United States and developing countries in Asia. Mathematically, the volume of water is equivalent to the volume of water flowing down the Shinanogawa river, the nation's longest river, in two years.

    Effective use of that amount of water would produce food for about 480 million people. That would save millions of children from hunger and prevent international disputes over water rights.

    Japan, for its part, can no longer remain complacent about food supplies from the viewpoint of national security, in case food imports are disrupted, or if food prices rise dramatically. We must try to increase our food production to a level approaching self-sufficiency.

    Germany, which was isolated and experienced severe food shortages during the two world wars in the 20th century, is very conscious of food supplies. It is said that 20 percent of the vegetables Germans eat at home are grown in their backyards.

    Japan can learn from Germany in this respect.

    How many people could be saved and how well could food resources be distributed, if Japan economized on food consumption?

    Mottainai has a deep meaning: It not only teaches us the importance of not wasting food, both at home and throughout the country, but also prompts us to think of what goes on in other parts of the world.

    Talk of food leftovers may spoil the festive mood of wedding receptions, but I am positive that this bitter pill will turn out to be nourishment for people in the future.

[Back to TOP]


[HOME] [NAJC] [JA*Net] [Ties Talk Index]