| PLAYER | YEAR | POSITION | COLLEGE |
| MARCUS ALLEN | 1981 | RB | USC |
| TIM BROWN | 1987 | WR/KR | NOTRE DAME |
| BILLY CANNON | 1959 | RB | LOUISIANA STATE |
| DESMOND HOWARD | 1991 | WR/KR | MICHIGAN |
| VINCENT " BO " JACKSON | 1985 | RB | AUBURN |
| JIM PLUNKETT | 1970 | QB | STANFORD |
| CHARLES WOODSON | 1997 | CB/KR | MICHIGAN |