Watership DownMain Watership Down Page:Characters: Plot: Lapine Glossary: Lapine Mythology: Tales From Watership Down:
Where to Now?My main page:My book page: My music page:
|
In 1978, the international best seller was released as an animated film after two years of work. The 98 minute film touched on most of the story's plot, although like any book turned film, it left out sections that readers of the novel may well consider essential. Nevertheless, there is a certain joy to seeing the charcters come to life; to watch them act out the story and live through their adventure. While no substitute for reading the novel, the movie is enjoyable viewing for anyone who has either read the book or simply enjoys a great story. Plot Differences Following are some of the differences (some major, some minor) between the novel version of Watership Down and the animated version in no special order: The inclusion of a doe named Violet, who escapes from Sandleford with the other rabbits. She is later killed by a hawk in the field where Pipkin is attacked by a crow in the novel. Needless to say, in the novel no does left Sandleford with the group. The lack of the lapine myths with the exception of The Blessing of El-ahrairah told as an introduction. While including the stories who would have no doubt made the film twice as long, it's sad to see such a rich part of the novel trimmed. The complete lack of mention of the characters Speedwell, Acorn, Hawkbit, Bluebell, and Strawberry. Hardly a major flaw though since the five rabbits were such minor characters. The lack of mention of Silverweed. While it can be argued that Silverweed was even a more minor character than the three rabbits listed above, he represented the 'spiritual' aspect of the Warren of Shining Wires. Hardly a major point, but in the novel Cowslip is described as a large sleek rabbit who is obviously well fed and perhaps dangerous due to his size. In the movie he becomes an effeminate fop. There is no diplomatic mission from Watership Down to Efrafa. Instead, by the time the companions find Holly in a ditch, he had already visited Efrafa on his solo travels. This again, was most likely done in the interest of speeding the plot along. Hyzenthlay is the final rabbit in the 'dog chasing rabbit to the down' scene in the film. In the novel, the rabbit was Dandelion who was established previously as an exceptionally fast fellow. The fight against the rats is elaborated upon in the film, or at least described in present tense as opposed to a memory. Also, in the film the fight occurs in a cemetary tool shed as opposed to a barn. The timing of the raids on Nuthanger Farm are different in the film. Also, the rabbits taken from the farm are more or less effectively ignored for the rest of the film with the exception of Clover's den during the Efrafan seige. Hardly a difference since the book does not come provided with sound effects, but I've always hated it when cartoon characters are given stupid voices. The line "Can you run? I think not" when delivered by the cat in the novel was one of the most chilling, actually leading me to believe upon my first reading of the novel that Hazel was indeed finished. In the film, the cat just sounds dumb. The death of Blackavar,who is killed by Woundwort during the Efrafan siege. In the novel,Blackavar is not killed. Not a major difference,seeing as the novel doesn't come with visual portions,but it still annoyed me. The fact that two of the most exciting parts of the story,Bigwig's escape from Efrafa and the Efrafan seige of Watership,are very much belittled.
|