Conundrum of Duty

AROUND 3:30PM (AFTER A LATE LUNCH) LOGAN AND BRISCOE RETURN TO THE 
 NAPOLEAN HOTEL. BEFORE ASKING TO HAVE KENNKONG PAGED AGAIN, THE
 DETECTIVES ASK THE CLERK WHO WAS WORKING THE DOOR AROUND SIX PM LAST
 NIGHT, THE CLERK POINTS OUT EUGENE 
Logan: Were you working this door around 6pm last night? 
Eugene: Yes Sir! 
Logan: Is the only entrance for guests to go through? 
Eugene: Yep! 
Briscoe: Did you see this girl (showing the picture) go through this
 door with any man last night while you were working? 
Eugene: Not through this door sir! 
Logan: $hit! 
Eugene: I did escort her to and through the employee door in the back
 which leads to the ally! 
Briscoe: Just her? 
Eugene: Yes Sir! 
Logan: Who made you do this? 
Eugene: My boss, Mr Noth! 
Briscoe: Why didn't Mr. Noth do it himself? 
Eugene: You need a key to unlock the door and he had clocked out. The
 only person with a key that can unlock the door is the doorman and
 the manager on duty! 
Briscoe: Thanks Eugene, you've been a big help! 
Eugene: Am I in trouble? 
Logan: No the only person in trouble is your boss! 
(To Briscoe) Lets arrest this lying sack of $hit! 

ENTERING KENNKONGS OFFICE, BRISCOE AND LOGAN TAKE HIM INTO CUSTODY
 AND READ HIM HIS MIRANDA RIGHTS. TWENTY MINUTES LATER (DUE TO
 TRAFFIC) LOGAN AND BRISCOE HAVE KENNKONG IN AN INTERROGATION ROOM AT
 THE STATION 
Logan: So are you going to stop screwing around with us and tell us
 what you know about the death of Joystar? 
KennKong: Who is that? 
Briscoe: It's the women that you had Eugene escort through the back
 employee door to the ally where you picked her up and took her out!
 The same women we found dead in you basement Mr. Noth! 
KennKong: I want my attorney! 

ONE HOUR LATER, CLAIRE (THE GODDESS OF L&O) SHOWS UP AT THE STATION
 AFTER KENNKONG AND HIS ATTORNEY HAVE FINISHED DISCUSSING THE
 POTENTIAL CHARGES AGAINST HIM OF MURDER! 
Claire: (To Logan) So why have we arressted this man for an apparent
 suicide? 
Logan: Were not sure it wasn't a forced suicide and this guy hasn't
 been straight with us at all! 
Briscoe: He has been lying from the onset! 

CLAIRE ENTERS THE INTERROGATION ROOM WITH LOGAN AND BRISCOE AFTER A
 KNOCK ON THE WINDOW 
Mr. Dixon: Hello Ms Kincaid, I'm Mr Noth's attorney and he is now
 willing to cooperate in order to clear up this misunderstanding! 
Claire: I'm Waiting! 
KennKong: Look, My wofe was out of town for a few days. I'm human! I
 met Joystar earlier in the day at work and I asked her out for the
 evening because I didn't think my wife was getting back until today!
 We went out and had a wonderful time! Then I asked her if she wanted
 to come back to my place and she accepted my invitation. When we got
 back to my place we had a few more drinks and then started to fool
 around! Then unexpectedly I heard my wife's car pull into the
 driveway. I had to tell Joystar the truth! I asked her to go into
 the basement and wait until my wife was asleep and I came to get
 her! As I was rushing her down the stairs to the basement, I saw her
 take some pills with her wine! I didn't know what kind of pills they
 were! 
Claire: Some Pills Mr Noth! She had over 20 in her stomach! You
 didn't think that was strange her taking that many pills! 
KennKong: I wasn't watching that closely, I saw her take alot of
 pills as I was rushing her intoi the basement but, I was distracted!
 My wife had came home unexpectedly! her taking a pills was the least
 of my problems...I was trying to save my marriage! 
Claire: Then what? 
KennKong: Well around 1 am my wife fianally was sound asleep and I
 went to the steps of the basement and called for Joystar! She didn't
 answer so I assumed that she had got out earlier in the evening
 while my wife and I were distracted! 
Claire: So you didn't see her on the floor? 
KennKong: I never turned on the light, I didn't want to wake my wife! 
Mr. Dixon: See Ms Kincaid, my client has cooperated and other than
 cheating on his wife, he did nothing to affect the womens actions
 and her death! So can my client go home to his wife? 
Claire: That's just it Mr Dixon, your client didn't do anything, and
 in this state that is MANSLAUGHTER! 
KennKong: WHAT! 

KENNKONG IS TAKEN AWAY AND ARRAIGNED LATER THAT EVENING! 

THE NEXT DAY IN ADAM SCHIFF'S OFFICE 
Jack: DO you really think we can make this manslaughter charge stick
 in court? 
Claire: This man admits seeing Joystar take the pills and he just let
 her do it! All he was concerned about was hiding his infidelity from
 his wife! KennKong let a women die because he failed to get her a
 doctor because if he would of done so his wife would havrriage would
 probably be over! 
Jack: But Mr Noth doesn't have to stop this women from commiting
 suicide! The fact that this women was in the defendant's house
 created no legal duty which requires him to help this women and stop
 her from commiting suicide! He has no contol over the women's
 actions, regardless is she is in his house or in Wolf park! 
Claire: But his lying to her is the reason she commited suicide Jack! 
Adam: Save it for Philosophy class! Just get a conviction or drop the
 case! 


THE CASE DOES GO TO TRIAL AND YOU ARE THE JURY! SHOULD HE BE
 CONVICTED OF THE CHARGE AGAINST HIM>>>MANSLAUGHTER? WHY OR WHY NOT?


LOFers have turned off L&O to read this page times.