1958: Noxapater 13-0 (at NW) MVP - Jimmy Clay (Noxapater)
1959: Noxapater 7-0 (at Nox) MVP - Cecil Boswell (Noxapater)
1960: Noxapater 14-7 (at NW) MVP - Bobby Hudson (Noxapater)
1961: Noxapater 13-6 (at Louisville) MVP - Charlie Young (Noxapater)
1962: Nanih Waiya 20-13 (at Louisville) MVP - Bob Beardon (Nanih Waiya)
1963: Nanih Waiya 21-0 (at Louisville) MVP - Chuck Goodin (Nanih Waiya)
1964: Noxapater 13-0 (at Louisville) MVP - Rudy Pope (Noxapater)
1965: Nanih Waiya 8-0 (at Louisville) MVP - Johnny Holdiness (Nanih Waiya)
1966: Nanih Waiya 37-0 (at Louisville) MVP - Johnny Lovorn (Nanih Waiya)
1967: Noxapater 21-12 (at Louisville) MVP - Jerry Ricks (Noxapater)
1968: Nanih Waiya 26-0 (at Louisville) MVP - Randall Rosemond (Nanih Waiya)
1969: Nanih Waiya 24-14 (at Louisville) MVP - Terry Moody (Nanih Waiya)
1970: Noxapater 28-6 (at Louisville) MVP - Freddy Woodward (Noxapater)
1971: Noxapater 19-12 (at Louisville) MVP - Larry Coburn (Noxapater)
1972: Noxapater 19-6 (at Louisville) MVP - Paul Coburn (Noxapater)
1973: Noxapater 17-0 (at Louisville) MVP - Ricky Haggard (Noxapater)
1974: Noxapater 26-0 (at Louisville) MVP - Alvin Moore (Noxapater)
1975: Noxapater 6-0 (at Louisville) MVP - Howard Tucker (Noxapater)
1976: Noxapater 19-14 (at Nox) MVP - Bennie Earl Moore (Noxapater)
1977: Nanih Waiya 30-14 (at NW) MVP - Charles Hickman (Nanih Waiya)
1978: Noxapater 16-12 (at Nox) MVP - Willie Glass (Noxapater)
1979: Noxapater 26-0 (at NW) MVP - Ricky Phillips (Noxapater)
1980: Noxapater 30-12 (at Nox) MVP - Willie B. Moore (Noxapater)
1981: Noxapater 12-6 (at NW) MVP - Kimball Nichols (Noxapater)
1982: Noxapater 32-12 (at Nox) MVP - Kimball Nichols (Noxapater)
1983: Noxapater 27-20 (at NW) MVP - Sedrick Jordan (Noxapater)
1984: Noxapater 21-6 (at Nox) MVP - Terry Daily (Noxapater)
1985: Noxapater 17-10 (at NW) MVP - Brian Young (Noxapater)
1986: Noxapater 33-0 (at Nox) MVP - Darryl Burnside (Noxapater)
1987: Nanih Waiya 22-8 (at NW) MVP - Warren McQueen (Nanih Waiya)
1988: Noxapater 14-3 (at Nox) MVP - Chris Hathorn (Noxapater)
1989: Noxapater 35-0 (at NW) MVP - Anthony Robertson (Noxapater)
1990: Noxapater 31-12 (at Nox) MVP - Tommy Glass (Noxapater)
1991: Nanih Waiya 28-7 (at NW) MVP - Sammy Patten (Nanih Waiya)
1992: Noxapater 10-0 (at Nox)
1993: Nanih Waiya 17-16 (at NW)
1994: Nanih Waiya 27-18 (at Nox)
1995: Noxapater 14-8 (at NW)
1996: Noxapater 33-6 (at Nox) MVP - Dewaski Burnside (Noxapater)
1997: Noxapater 34-0 (at NW) MVP - Dewaski Burnside (Noxapater)
1998: Noxapater 25-0 (at Nox) MVP - Donny Boatner (Noxapater)
1999: Noxapater 37-12 (at NW) MVP - Ryan Smith (Noxapater)
2000: Noxapater 47, Nanih Waiya 6 (at Nox) MVP - Corey Moore (Noxapater)
2001: Nanih Waiya 28-21 (at NW) MVP - Brent Blackwell (Nanih Waiya)
2002: Nanih Waiya 21, Noxapater 14 (at Nox)
Noxapater leads the series 32-13 overall, 13-2 at Noxapater, 10-5 at Nanih Waiya, and 9-6 at Louisville.