"Garcia's defining quality, the thing that makes him linger in your mind after his 15 minutes of fame should have expired, is not any particular physical attribute or vocal inflection, but rather a certain perfect strained look that seems to belong to a man who just found out that the world is not a perfect and just place. That's the look that seems to figure at some point into all of Garcia's best performances, but it is with "Night Falls on Manhattan" that Garcia makes us realize how much that expression is uniquely his, and it makes him perfect."
