- 1 -
A Hoard of Hebrew Manuscripts 1
I
The Genizah, to explore which was the object of
my travels in the East (1896 - 1897), is an old Jewish
institution. The word is derived from the Hebrew
verb ganaz, and signifies treasure-house, or hiding-
place. When applied to books, it means much the
same thing as burial means in the case of men.
When the spirit is gone, we put the corpse out of
sight to protect it from abuse. In like manner, when
the writing is worn out, we hide the book to pre-
serve it from profanation. The contents of the book
go up to heaven like the soul. "I see the parchment
burning, and the letters flying up in the air," were the
last words of the martyr R. Chanina ben Teradyon,
when he went to the stake wrapped in the scrolls of
the law. The analogy of books with men was so
strongly felt that sometimes the term "hide" was
used even in epithaphs: "Here was hidden (nignaz or
nitman) this man." When R. Eliezer the Great was
buried, they said, "a scroll of the Law was hidden."
It was probably this feeling that suggested the in-
junction to hice worn-out copies of the Pentateuch in
the grave of a scholar. More often, however, they
dug a grave for the dead books themselves in the
- 2 -
cemetary, or hid them in some sort of shed adjoining
the synagogue.
Happily for us, this process of "hiding" was not
confined to dead or worn-out books alone. In the
course of time the Genizah extended its protection to
what we may call (to carry on the simile) invalid
books; that is, to books which by long use or want
of care came to be in a defective state, sheets being
missing at the beginning, in the middle, or at the end,
and which were thus disqualified for the common pur-
poses of study. Another class of workes consigned to
the Genizah were what we may call disgraced books,
books which once pretended to the rank of Scriptures,
but were found by the authorities to be wanting in
the qualification of being dictated by the Holy Spirit.
They were "hidden." Here our term "Apocrypha"
for writings excluded from, or never admitted into,
the Canon. Of course, such books came into the
Genizah in sound condition; but the period at
which synods and councils were able to test the
somewhat indefinable quality of inspiration is now so
remote that these "external works" have met, by
reason of long neglect, with the same fate of decom-
position that awaited sacred books, by reason of long
and constant use.
Besides these sacred and semi-sacred books the
Genizah proved a refuge for a class of writings that
never aspired to the dignity of real books, but are
none the less of the greatest importance for Jewish
history. As we know, the use of the sacred language
- 3 -
was, among the Jews, not confined to the sacred liter-
ature. With them it was a living languge. They
wrote in it their letters, kept in it their accounts, and
composed in it their love-songs and wine-songs. All
legal documents, such as leases, contracts, marriage
settlements, and letters of divorce, and the proceed-
ings as well as the decisions of the courts of justice,
were drawn up in Hebrew, or, at least, written in
Hebrew letters. As the Jews attached a cretain
sacredness to everything resembling the Scriptures,
either in matter or form, they were loth to treat
even these secular documents as mere refuse, and
when they were overtaken by old age, they disposed
of them by ordering them to the Genizah, in which
they found a resting-place for centuries. The Geni-
zah, of the old Jewish community thus represents a
combination of sacred lumber-room and secular record
office.
It was such a Genizah that I set out to visit in the
middle of December, 1896. My destination was Cairo.
The conviction of the importance of its Genizah had
grown upon me as I examined the various manuscripts
which had found their way from it into English pri-
vate and public libraries, and which had already led
to important discoveries. I therefore determined to
make a pilgrimage to the source whence they had
come. My plan recommended itself to the authori-
ties of the University of Cambridge, and found warm
supporters in Professor Sedgwick, Dr. Donald Mac-
Alister, and especially Dr. Taylor, the Master of St.
- 4 -
John's College. To the enlightened generosity of this
great student and patron of Hebrew literature it is due
that my pilgimage became a regular pleasure trip to
Egypt, and extended into the Holy Land.
Now that the sources of the Nile are being visited
by bicycles, there is little fresh to be said about Cairo
and Alexandria. The latter, at which I landed, is
particularly disappointing to the Jewish student.
There is nothing in it to remind one of Philo, whose
vague speculations were converted into saving dogmas,
of the men of the Septuagint, whose very blunders
now threaten to become Scripture. Nor is any trace
left of the principal synagogue, in whose magnificent
architecture and tasteful arrangements the old Rabbis
saw a reflex of "the glory of Israel." Cairo is not
more promising at the first glance that one gets on
the way from the station to the hotel. Everything in
it is calculated to satisfy the needs of the European
tourist is sadly modern, and my heart sank within me
when I reflected that this was the place whence I was
expected to return laden with spoils, the age of which
would command respect even in our ancient seats of
learning. However, I felt reassured after a brief inter-
view with the Reverend Aaron Bensimon, the Grand
Rabbi of Cairo, to whom I had an introduction from
the Chief Rabbi, the Very Reverend Doctor Herman
Adler. From him I soon learnt that Old Cairo would
be the proper field for my activity, a place old enough
to enjoy the respect even of a resident of Cambridge.
I must remark here that the Genizah, like the rest
- 5 -
of the property of the synagogue in Cairo, is vested
in the Rabbi and the wardens for the time being. To
this reverend gentleman and to Mr. Youssef M. Cat-
taui, the President of the Jewish Community, my best
thanks are due for the liberality with which they put
their treasures at my disposal, and for the interest
they showed, and the assistance they gave me in my
work.
I drove to this ancient Genizah accompanied by
the Rabbi. We left our carriage somewhere in the
neighbourhood of the "Fortress of Babylon," whence
the Rabbi directed his steps to the so-called Synagogue
of Ezra the Scribe. This synagogue, which in some
writings bears also the names of the prophets Elijah
and Jeremiah, is well known to old chroniclers and
travellers, such as Makreese, Sambari, and Benjamin
of Tudela. I cannot here attempt to reproduce the
legends which have grown up around it in the course
of time. Suffice it to say that it has an authentic
record extending over more than a thousand years,
having served originally as a Coptic Church (St. Mi-
chael's), and been thereafter converted into a syna-
gogue soon after the Mohammedan conquest of
Egypt. Ever since that time it has remained in the
uninterrupted possession of the Jews. The Genizah,
which probably always formed an integral part of the
synagogue, is now situated at the end of the gallery,
presenting the appearance of a short windowless and
doorless room of fair dimensions. The entrance is on
the west side, through a big, shapless hole reached
- 6 -
by a ladder. After showing me over the place and
the neighbouring buildings, or rather ruins, the Rabbi
introduced me to the beadles of the synagogue, who
are at the same time the keepers of the Genizah, and
authorized me to take from it what, and as much as
I liked.
Now, as a matter of fact, I liked all. Still, some
discretion was necessary. I have already indicated
the mixture of the Genizah. But one can hardly
realise the confusion in a genuine, old Genizah until
one has seen it. It is a battlefield of books, and the
literary productions of many centuries had their share
in the battle, and their disjecta membra are now
strewn over its area. Some of the belligerents have
perished outright, and are literally ground to dust
in the terrible struggle for space, whilst others, as if
overtaken by a general crush, are squeezed into big,
unshaply lumps, which even with the aid of chemical
appliances can no longer be separated without serious
damage to their constituents. In their present condi-
tion these lumps sometimes afford curiously sugges-
tive combinations; as, for instance, when you find a
piece of some rationalistic work, in which the very
existence of either angels or devils is denied, clinging
for its very life to an amulet in which these same
beings (mostly the latter) are bound over to be on
their good behaviour and not interfere with Miss Jair's
love for somebody. The development of the romance
is obscured by the fact that the last lines of the amulet
are mounted on some I.O.U., or lease, and this in
- 7 -
turn is squeezed between the sheets of an old moralist,
who treats all attention to money affairs with scorn
and indignation. Again, all these contradictory mat-
ters cleave tightly to some sheets from a very old
Bible. This indeed, ought to be the last umpire be-
tween them, but it is hardly legible without peeling off
from its surface the fragments of some printed work,
which clings to old nobility with all the obstancy and
obtrusiveness of the parvenu.
Such printed matter proved a source of great
trouble. It is true that it occasionally supplied us
with loose sheets of lost editions, and is thus of consider-
able interest to the bibliographer. But consider-
ing that the Genizah has survived Gutenberg for nearly
five centuries, the great bulk of it is bound to be com-
paretively modern, and so is absolutely useless to the
student of palaeography. I had, therefore, to confine
my likings to the manuscripts. But the amount of
printed fragment is very large, constituting as
they do nearly all the contributions to the Genizah of
the last four hundred years. Most of my time in
Cairo was spent in getting rid of these parvenus, while
every piece of paper or parchment that had any claim
to respectable age was packed into bags and conveyed
to the forwarding agent to be shipped to England.
The task was by no means easy, the Genizah be-
ing very dark, and emitting clouds of dust when its
contents were stirred, as if protesting against the dis-
turbance of its inmates. The protest is the less
to be ignored as the dust settles in one's throat,
- 8 -
and threatens suffocation. I was thus compelled to
accept the aid offered me by the keepers of the place,
who had some experience in such work from their
connexion with former acquisitions (perhaps they
were rather depredations) from the Genizah. Of
course, they declined to be paid for their services in
hard cash of so many piastres per diem. This was a
vulgar way of doing business to which no self-re-
specting keeper of a real Genizah would degrade him-
self. The keepers insisted the more on bakhshish,
which, besides being a more dignified kind of remu-
neration, has the advantage of being expected also for
services not rendered. In fact, the whole population
within the precincts of the synagogue were constantly
coming forward with claims on my liberality - the
men as worthy colleagues employed in the same
work (of selection) as myself, or at least, in watching
us at our work; the women for greeting me respect-
fully when I entered the place, or for showing me
their deep sympathy in my fits of coughing caused by
the dust. If it was a fĂȘte day, such as the New Moon
or the eve of the Sabbath, the amount expected from
me for all these kind attentions was much larger, it
being only proper that the Western millionaire should
contribute from his fortune to the glory of the next
meal.
All this naturally led to a great deal of haggling
and barganing, for which I was sadly unprepared by
my former course of life, and which involved a great
loss both of money and time. But what was worse,
- 9 -
was, as I soon found out, that a certain dealer in an-
tiquities, who shall be nameless here, had some mys-
terious relations with the Genizah, which enabled him
to offer me a fair number of fragments for sale. My
complaints to the authorities of the Jewish community
brought this plundering to a speedy end, but not be-
fore I had parted with certain guineas by way of pay-
ment to this worthy for a number of selected frag-
ments, which were mine by right and on which he put
exorbitant prices.
The number of fragments procured by me amounts,
I think, to about a hundred thousand. The closer
examination of them has begun since my return to
England, but it will take a long time before an ade-
quate account of them is possible. Here I can offer
only a few brief remarks about their general character,
which, of course, must be taken with due reserve.
The study of the Torah, which means the revela-
tion of God to man, and the cultivation of prayer,
which means the revelation of man to God, were the
grand passion of old Judaism; hence the Bible (Old
Testament) and liturgy constitute the larger part
of the contents of the Genizah. The manuscripts of
the Bible, though offering no textual variations of
consequence, are nevertheless not devoid of points of
interest; for some fragments go back as far as the
tenth century, and are thus of great value, if only as
specimens of writing; others are furnished with mar-
ginal glosses, or are interspersed with Chaldaic and
Arabic versions; whilst some are provided with quite
- 10 -
a new system of punctuation, differing both from the
Eastern and Western. Regarding the Apocry-
phia, I will here refer only to the fragment of the orig-
inal of Ecclesiasticus, which it was my good fortune
to discover on May 13, 1896, in the Lewis-Gibson
collection of fragments. The communications which
were then made by Mrs. Lewis to the press led to the
discovery of further fragments at Oxford. All these
undoubtely come from a Genizah, and justify the
hope that our recent acquisitions will yield more
remains of these semi-sacred volumes. As to liturgy,
the Genizah offers the remains of the oldest forms of
the worship of the synagogue, and these throw much
light on the history of the Jewish prayer-book. The
number of hymns found in the Genizah is also very
great, and they reveal to us a whole series of latter-
day psalmists hitherto unknown.
Next to these main classes come fragments of
the two Talmuds (the Talmud of Babylon and the
Talmud of Jerusalem) and Midrashism (old Rabbinic
homolies). They are of the utmost importance to the
student of Jewish tradition, giving not only quite a
new class of manuscripts unknown to the author of
the Variae Lectiones, but also restoring to us parts of
old Rabbinic works long ago given up as lost for-
ever. It is hardly necessary to say that both Bible
and Talmud are accompanied by a long train of com-
mentaries and super-commentaries in Hebrew as well
as in Arabic. It is the penalty of greatness to be in
need of interpretation, and jewish authoritative works
have not escaped this fate.
- 11 -
The number of autograph documents brought to
light from the Genizah is equally large. They ex-
tend over nearly seven hundred years (eight century
to the fourteenth). What a rich life these long rolls
unfold to us! All sorts and conditions of men and
situations are represented in them: the happy young
married couple by their marriage contract; the mar-
riage that failed by its letter of divorce; the slave by
his deed of emancipation; the court of justice by its
legal decisions; the heads of the schools by their
learned epistles; the newly-appointed "Prince of the
Exile" by the description of his installation; the rich
trader by his correspondence with his agents in Mala-
bar; the gentleman-beggar by his letters of recom-
mendation to the great ones in Israel; the fanatics by
their thundering excommunications; the meek man
by his mild apologies; the fool by his amulet; the
medical man by his prescriptions; and the patient by
his will. To these may be added a vast amount of
miscellaneous matter, philosophical and mystical as
well as controversial, which is the more difficult to
identify as almost every fragment bears witness to the
existence of a separate work.
All these treasures are now stored up in the Libra-
ry of the University of Cambridge, where they are
undergoing the slow process of a thorough examina-
tion. The results of this examination will certainly
prove interesting alike to the theologian and the his-
torian.
|