1968
Johnny Bench (CIN)
1990
Sandy Alomar Jr. (CLE)
1972
Carlton Fisk (BOS)
1993
Mike Piazza (LA)
1975
Gary Carter (MON)
1996
Jason Kendall (PIT)
1987
Benito Santiago (SD)
Baseball Digest All-Star Rookie Catchers Of The Year
1971
Earl Williams (ATL)
1987
Benito Santiago (SD)
1972
Carlton Fisk (BOS)
1988
Damon Berryhill (CHI)
1973
Darrell Porter (MIL)
1989
Joe Girardi (CHI)
1974
Steve Swisher (CHI)
1990
Sandy Alomar Jr. (CLE)
1975
Gary Carter (MON)
1991
Ivan Rodriguez (TEX)
1976
Butch Wynegar (MIN)
1992
Todd Hundley (NYM)
1977
Dave Skaggs (BAL)
1993
Mike Piazza (LA)
1978
Mike Colbern (CHI)
1994
Javy Lopez (ATL)
1979
Steve Nicosia (PIT)
1995
Charles Johnson (FLA)
1980
Dan Graham (BAL)
1996
Jason Kendall (PIT)
1981
Jody Davis (CHI)
1997
Scott Hatteberg (BOS)
1982
Tom Laudner (MIN)
1998
A.J. Hinch (OAK)
1983
Bob Kearney (OAK)
1999
1984
Mike Fitzgerald (NYM)
2000
1985
Mark Salas (MIN)
2001
1986
Andy Allanson (CLE)
2002