{# - # Indicate Innings Played}
American League | National League | ||
1933 | Bill Dickey {Injured}; Rick Ferrell {1-9} | Jimmie Wilson {1-5}; Gabby Hartnett {6-9} | |
1934 | Bill Dickey {1-5}; Mickey Cochrane {6-9}; Rick Ferrell | Gabby Hartnett {1-5}; Al Lopez {6-9} | |
1935 | Rollie Hemsley {1-9}; Rick Ferrell; Mickey Cochrane | Jimmie Wilson {1-6}; Gabby Hartnett {7-9}; Gus Mancuso {PH 3} | |
1936 | Rick Ferrell {1-6}; Bill Dickey {7-9}; Rollie Hemsley | Gabby Hartnett {1-9}; Ernie Lombardi | |
1937 | Bill Dickey {1-9}; Rick Ferrell; Luke Sewell | Gabby Hartnett {1-5}; Gus Manusco {6-9}; Ernie Lombardi | |
1938 | Bill Dickey {1-9}; Rudy York {PH 7}; Rick Ferrell | Ernie Lombardi; {1-9}; Gabby Hartnett; Harry Danning; Babe Phelps | |
1939 | Bill Dickey {1-9}; Rollie Hemsley; Frankie Hayes | Ernie Lombardi {1-9}; Harry Danning; Babe Phelps | |
1940 | Bill Dickey {1-3}; Frankie Hayes {4-6}; Rollie Hemsley {7-9} | Ernie Lombardi {1-3}; Babe Phelps {4-6}; Harry Danning {7-9} | |
1941 | Bill Dickey {1-7}; Frankie Hayes {8-9}; Birdie Tebbetts | Mickey Owen {1-2}; Al Lopez {3-6}; Harry Danning {7-9} | |
1942 | Birdie Tebbetts {1-9}; Bill Dickey; Buddy Rosar; Hal Wagner | Walker Cooper {1-6}; Ernie Lombardi {7-9}; Mickey Owen {PH 8} | |
1943 | Jake Early {1-9}; Bill Dickey; Buddy Rosar | Walker Cooper {1-5}; Ernie Lombardi {6-9}; Mickey Owen | |
1944 | Rollie Hemsley {1-3}; Frankie Hayes {4-9}; Rick Ferrell | Walker Cooper {1-8}; Ray Mueller {9}; Mickey Owen | |
No Game Played in 1945 due to wartime travel restrictions (Selections Only) | |||
1945 | Rick Ferrell; Frankie Hayes; Mike Tresh | Ernie Lombardi; Phil Masi; Ken O'Dea | |
1946 | Frankie Hayes {1-3}; Buddy Rosar {4-6}; Hal Wagner {7-9}; Bill Dickey {PH 6} | Walker Cooper {1-3}; Phil Masi {4-9}; Ray Lamanno {PH 8} |
American League | National League | ||
1947 | Buddy Rosar {1-9}; Aaron Robinson; Jim Hegan | Walker Cooper {1-6}; Bruce Edwards {7-8}; Phil Masi {9} | |
1948 | Buddy Rosar {1-3}; Birdie Tebbetts {4-9}; Yogi Berra | Walker Cooper {1-4}; Phil Masi {5-9}; Clyde McCullough | |
1949 | Birdie Tebbetts {1-3}; Yogi Berra {4-9}; Jim Hegan | Andy Seminick {1-3}; Roy Campanella {4-9}; Walker Cooper | |
1950 | Yogi Berra {1-3}; Jim Hegan {4-14}; Sherm Lollar | Roy Campanella {1-14}; Walker Cooper | |
1951 | Yogi Berra {1-9}; Jim Hegan {PH 9} | Roy Campanella {1-9}; Bruce Edwards | |
1952 Rain |
Yogi Berra {1-5}; Jim Hegan | Roy Campanella {1-5}; Wes Westrum; Toby Atwell | |
1953 | Yogi Berra {1-9}; Sammy White | Roy Campanella {1-9}; Del Crandall; Clyde McCullough; Del Rice; Wes Westrum | |
1954 | Yogi Berra {1-9}; Sherm Lollar | Roy Campanella {1-7}; Smoky Burgess {8-9}; Del Crandall | |
1955 | Yogi Berra {1-12}; Sherm Lollar | Del Crandall {1-5}; Smoky Burgess {6-7}; Stan Lopata {8-12}; Roy Campanella | |
1956 | Yogi Berra {1-6}; Sherm Lollar {7-9} | Ed Bailey {1-6}; Roy Campanella {7-9}; Del Crandall; Stan Lopata | |
1957 | Yogi Berra {1-9}; Gus Triandos | Ed Bailey {1-9}; Hank Foiles {PH 9}; Hal Smith |
American League | National League | ||
1958 | Gus Triandos {1-6}; Yogi Berra {7-9}; Elston Howard; Sherm Lollar | Del Crandall {1-9}; John Roseboro; Bob Schmidt | |
1959 1st Game |
Gus Triandos {1-7}; Sherm Lollar {8-9}; Yogi Berra | Del Crandall {1-9}; Smokey Burgess; Hal Smith | |
1959 2nd Game |
Yogi Berra {1-5}; Sherm Lollar {6-9}; Gus Triandos | Del Crandall {1-5}; Hal Smith {6-9}; Smokey Burgess | |
1960 1st Game |
Yogi Berra {1-5}; Elston Howard {6-9}; Sherm Lollar {PH 8} | Del Crandall {1-6}; Smokey Burgess {7-9}; Ed Bailey | |
1960 2nd Game |
Yogi Berra {1-5}; Sherm Lollar {6-9}: Elston Howard | Del Crandall {1-4}; Smokey Burgess {5-7}; Ed Bailey {8-9} | |
1961 1st Game |
John Romano {1-8}; Yogi Berra {9}; Elston Howard {9-10} | Smokey Burgess {1-10}; John Roseboro | |
1961 2nd Game |
Johnny Romano {1-4}; Elston Howard {5-9} | Smokey Burgess {1-3}; John Roseboro {4-9}; Ed Bailey | |
1962 1st Game |
Earl Battey {1-6}; Johnny Romano {7-9}; Elston Howard | Del Crandall {1-9}; John Roseboro | |
1962 2nd Game |
Earl Battey {1-5}; Elston Howard {6-9}; Yogi Berra {PH 9}; John Romano | Del Crandall {1-3}; John Roseboro {4-9} | |
1963 | Earl Battey {1-5}; Elston Howard {6-9}; Don Leppert | Ed Bailey {1-4}; Johnny Edwards {5-9}; Joe Torre | |
1964 | Elston Howard {1-9}; Bill Freehan | Joe Torre {1-4}; Johnny Edwards {5-9}; Smokey Burgess | |
1965 | Earl Battey {1-5}; Bill Freehan {6-9}; Elston Howard | Joe Torre {1-9}; Johnny Edwards | |
1966 | Bill Freehan {1-5}; Earl Battey {6-10}; Andy Etchebarren | Joe Torre {1-7}; Tim McCarver {8-10}; Tom Haller | |
1967 | Bill Freehan {1-15}; Andy Etchebarren; Paul Casanova | Joe Torre {1-5}; Tom Haller {6-9}; Tim McCarver {10-15} | |
1968 | Bill Freehan {1-5}; Joe Azcue {6-8}; Duane Josephson {9} | Jerry Grote {1-5}; Tom Haller {6-8}; Johnny Bench {9} | |
1969 | Bill Freehan {1-6}; John Roseboro {7-9}; Ellie Rodriguez | Johnny Bench {1-5}; Randy Hundley {6-9}; Chris Cannizzaro |
American League | National League | ||
1970 | Bill Freehan {1-4}; Ray Fosse {5-12}; Jerry Moses | Johnny Bench {1-6}; Dick Dietz {7-12}; Joe Torre {PH 12} | |
1971 | Bill Freehan {1-7}; Thurman Munson {8-9}; Ray Fosse; Dave Duncan | Johnny Bench {1-9}; Manny Sanguillen | |
1972 | Bill Freehan {1-5}; Carlton Fisk {6-10}; Ellie Rodriguez | Johnny Bench {1-5}; Manny Sanguillen {6-10}; Ted Simmons | |
1973 | Carlton Fisk {1-5}; Thurman Munson {6-9}; Bill Freehan | Johnny Bench {1-6}; Ted Simmons {7-9} | |
1974 | Thurman Munson {1-9}; Ed Herrmann; Carlton Fisk; Darrell Porter; Jim Sundberg | Johnny Bench {1-8}; Jerry Grote {9}; Ted Simmons | |
1975 | Thurman Munson {1-5}; Gene Tenace {6-9}; Bill Freehan | Johnny Bench {1-9}; Manny Sanguillen | |
1976 | Thurman Munson {1-4}; Carlton Fisk {5-9}; Butch Wynegar {PH 7} | Johnny Bench {1-4}; Bob Boone {5-9}; Steve Swisher | |
1977 | Carlton Fisk {1-5}; Butch Wynegar {6-9}; Thurman Munson {PH 9} | Johnny Bench {1-3}; Ted Simmons {4-8}; John Stearns {9} | |
1978 | Carlton Fisk {1-5}; Jim Sundberg {6-9}; Darrell Porter {PH 9}; Thurman Munson | Ted Simmons {1-6}; Bob Boone {7-8}; Biff Pocoroba {9}; Johnny Bench | |
1979 | Darrell Porter {1-6}; Brian Downing {7-9}; Jeff Newman | Bob Boone {1-4}; Gary Carter {5-9}; Johnny Bench; Ted Simmons; John Stearns | |
1980 | Carlton Fisk {1-4}; Darrell Porter {5-7}; Lance Parrish {8-9} | Johnny Bench {1-3}; John Stearns {4-6}; Gary Carter {7-9} | |
1981 | Carlton Fisk {1-6}; Bo Diaz {7-9}; Ted Simmons {PH 6} | Gary Carter {1-6}; Bruce Benedict {7-9}; Terry Kennedy {PH 5} | |
1982 | Carlton Fisk {1-4}; Lance Parrish {5-9} | Gary Carter {1-5}; Tony Pena {PR, 6-8}; John Stearns {9} | |
1983 | Ted Simmons {1-3}; Lance Parrish {4-8}; Bob Boone {9} | Gary Carter {1-5}; Bruce Benedict {6-9}; Terry Kennedy | |
1984 | Lance Parrish {1-4}; Jim Sundberg {5-9}; Dave Engle | Gary Carter {1-6}; Jody Davis {7-8}; Tony Pena {9}; Bob Brenly {PH 6) | |
1985 | Carlton Fisk {1-5}; Ernie Whitt {6-7}; Rich Gedman {8-9}; Lance Parrish | Terry Kennedy {1-3}; Ozzie Virgil {4-6}; Tony Pena {7-9}; Gary Carter | |
1986 | Lance Parrish {1-7}; Rich Gedman {8-9} | Gary Carter {1-7}; Jody Davis {8-9}; Tony Pena {PR 9} | |
1987 | Terry Kennedy {1-6}; Matt Nokes {7-13} | Gary Carter {1-4}; Bo Diaz {6-7}; Ozzie Virgil {8-13} | |
1988 | Terry Steinbach {1-5}; Tim Laudner {6-9} | Gary Carter {1-7}; Lance Parrish {8-9} | |
1989 | Terry Steinbach {1-6}; Mickey Tettleton {7-9} | Benito Santiago {1-3}; Mike Scioscia {4-6}; Tony Pena {7-9} | |
1990 | Sandy Alomar Jr. {1-6}; Lance Parrish {7-9} | Benito Santiago {Injured}; Mike Scioscia {1-8}; Greg Olson {9} | |
1991 | Sandy Alomar Jr. {1-4}; Carlton Fisk {5-9} | Benito Santiago {1-6}; Craig Biggio {7-9} | |
1992 | Sandy Alomar Jr. {1-5}; Ivan Rodriguez {6-9} | Benito Santiago {1-4}; Darren Daulton {5-9}; Tom Pagnozzi {PH 8} | |
1993 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-5}; Terry Steinbach {6-9} | Darren Daulton {1-6}; Mike Piazza {7-9} | |
1994 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-10}; Mickey Tettleton {PH 7} | Mike Piazza {1-8}; Darren Fletcher {9-10) | |
1995 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-7}; Mike Stanley {8-9} | Mike Piazza {1-6}; Darren Daulton {7-9} | |
1996 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-6}; Sandy Alomar Jr. {7-9}; Dan Wilson {PH 9} | Mike Piazza {1-7}; Todd Hundley {8}; Jason Kendall {9} | |
1997 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-5}; Sandy Alomar Jr. {6-9} | Mike Piazza {1-3}; Javy Lopez {4-7}; Charles Johnson {8-9}; Todd Hundley | |
1998 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-6}; Sandy Alomar Jr. {7-9} | Mike Piazza {1-5}; Javy Lopez {6-9}; Jason Kendall {PH 9} | |
1999 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-5}; Brad Ausmus {6-9} | Mike Piazza {1-4}; Mike Lieberthal {5-7}, Dave Nilsson {8-9} | |
2000 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-5}; Jorge Posada {6-9} | Mike Piazza {Injured}; Jason Kendall {1-4}; Mike Lieberthal {5-9}; Joe Girardi | |
2001 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-5}; Jorge Posada {6-9} | Mike Piazza {1-4}; Charles Johnson {5-9} | |
2002 | Jorge Posada {1-5}; A.J. Pierzynski {6-11} | Mike Piazza {1-4}; Damian Miller {5-9}, Benito Santiago {10-11} | |
2003 | Jorge Posada {1-5}; Ramon Hernandez {6-9}; Jason Varitek | Javy Lopez {1-5}; Paul Lo Duca {6-9} | |
2004 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-5}; Victor Martinez {6-9} | Mike Piazza {1-4}; Johnny Estrada {5-8}; Paul LoDuca {9} | |
2005 | Jason Varitek {1-5}; Ivan Rodriguez {6-9} | Mike Piazza {1-4}; Paul LoDuca {5-9} | |
2006 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-4}; Joe Mauer {5-9}; A.J. Pierzynski | Paul LoDuca {1-5}; Brian McCann {6-9} | |
2007 | Ivan Rodriguez {1-4}; Jorge Posada {5-9}; Victor Martinez {PH 8} | Russell Martin {1-6}; Brian McCann {7-9} | |
2008 | Joe Mauer {1-4}; Jason Varitek {5-6}; Dioner Navarro {7-15} | Geovany Soto {1- }; Russell Martin { - }; Brian McCann { - } | |
2009 | Joe Mauer {1-8}; Victor Martinez {9} | Yadier Molina {1-7}; Brian McCann {8-9} | |
2010 | Joe Mauer {1-5}; John Buck (6-9); Victor Martinez {DNP} | Yadier Molina {1-4}; Brian McCann {5-9} | |
2011 | Alex Avila {1-5}; Matt Wieters {6-9} | Brian McCann {1-4}; Yadier Molina {5-8}; Miguel Montero {9} | |
2012 | Mike Napoli {1-5}; Matt Wieters {6-9}; Joe Mauer {@1B 8-9} | Buster Posey {1-5} Carlos Ruiz {6-9}; Yadier Molina |
1981 | Gary Carter (Montreal Expos) |
1984 | Gary Carter (Montreal Expos) |
1988 | Terry Steinbach (Oakland A's) |
1996 | Mike Piazza (Los Angeles Dodgers) |
1997 | Sandy Alomar, Jr. (Cleveland Indians) |
2010 | Brian McCann (Atlanta Braves) |