| Catcher | Team | |||
| 1 | Johnny Bench | i | Cincinnati Reds 1967-1983 | |
| 2 | Bob Boone | v | Philadelphia Phillies 1972-1981 | |
| 3 | Roy Campanella | e | Brooklyn Dodgers 1948-1957 | |
| 4 | Gary Carter | s | Montreal Expos 1974-1984 | |
| 5 | Mickey Cochrane | u | Philadelphia Athletics 1925-1933 | |
| 6 | Del Crandall | q | Milwaukee Braves 1953-1963 | |
| 7 | Rick Dempsey | b | Baltimore Orioles 1976-1986 | |
| 8 | Andy Etchebarren | a | Baltimore Orioles 1962-1975 | |
| 9 | Carlton Fisk | c | Boston Red Sox 1969-1980 | |
| 10 | Bill Freehan | l | Detroit Tigers 1961-1976 | |
| 11 | Rich Gedman | d | Boston Red Sox 1980-1990 | |
| 12 | Jerry Grote | t | New York Mets 1966-1977 | |
| 13 | Gabby Hartnett | f | Chicago Cubs 1922-1940 | |
| 14 | Jim Hegan | k | Cleveland Indians 1941-1957 | |
| 15 | Sherm Lollar | h | Chicago White Sox 1952-1963 | |
| 16 | Charlie Moore | r | Milwaukee Brewers 1973-1986 | |
| 17 | Steve O'Neill | j | Cleveland Indians 1911-1923 | |
| 18 | Lanch Parrish | m | Detroit Tigers 1977-1986 | |
| 19 | Jamie Quirk | n | Kansas City Royals 1975-1988 | |
| 20 | Del Rice | w | St. Louis Cardinals 1945-1955 | |
| 21 | Johnny Roseboro | o | Los Angeles Dodgers 1958-1967 | |
| 22 | Muddy Ruel | z | Washington Senators 1923-1930 | |
| 23 | Ray Schalk | g | Chicago White Sox 1912-1928 | |
| 24 | Mike Scioscia | p | Los Angeles Dodgers 1980-1994 | |
| 25 | Jim Sundberg | y | Texas Rangers 1974-1983 |