| # | Catcher | Yankee Years | ||
| Yogi Berra | a | 1904-1910 | ||
| Rick Cerone | b | 1908-1915 | ||
| Pat Collins | c | 1915-1918 | ||
| Bill Dickey | d | 1918-1920 | ||
| Thurman Munson | e | 1921-1925 | ||
| Brian Dorsett | f | 1926-1928 | ||
| Truck Hanna | g | 1928-1946 | ||
| Elston Howard | h | 1946-1963 | ||
| Red Kleinow | I | 1955-1967 | ||
| Matt Nokes | j | 1969-1979 | ||
| Jorge Posada | k | 1980-1987 | ||
| Wally Schang | l | 1988-1989 | ||
| Don Slaught | m | 1989-1990 | ||
| Jeff Sweeney | n | 1990-1995 | ||
| Roxy Walters | o | 1995-2010 |