Which 2000 Catchers

Catch Thieves?

STATS Inc.
2001 Baseball
Scoreboard

(Minimum 500 innings caught in 2000)

By Thom Henninger

 

The King is dead. Long live the King.

Well, he isn't really dead, but after leading all major league catchers in caught-stealing percentage for five straight seasons, Ivan Rodriguez has been dethroned as the King of this category.

To be fair to the game's premier backstop, Rodriguez' 2000 campaign ended in late July with a fractured thumb. While Rodriguez was healthy, opponents smartly avoided running on him. The minuscle total of 34 attempted steals demonstrates how his mere presence on the field deters the running game. He allowed just .24 stolen bases pewr nine innings in 2000, far and away the lowest number of steals per nine among all catchers who caught at least 500 innings last summer.
Using the same minimum, here are the best of 2000 at catching thieves:

Take a look at the following chart. It lists the runners each catcher caught stealing (CCS), the stolen bases (SB) while he was behind the plate, the caught stealing percentage (CS%), the runners he picked off (CPk), the stolen bases allowed per 9 innings (SB/9), and the runners caught stealing (PCS) and picked off (PPk) by his pitchers.

Catcher Team CCS SB CS% CPk SB/9 PCS PPk
Blanco Henry MIL 38 28 0.576 2 0.34 1 2
Matheny Mike STL 46 44 0.511 3 0.38 3 1
Ausmus Brad DET 32 42 0.432 1 0.31 6 3
Rodriguez Ivan TEX 14 20 0.412 1 0.24 5 6
Kreuter Chad LA 14 21 0.400 0 0.32 5 3
Castillo Alberto TOR 16 25 0.390 3 0.45 1 0
Santiago Benito CIN 12 19 0.387 0 0.28 2 1
Lieberthal Mike PHI 24 44 0.353 0 0.44 5 2
Gonzalez Wiki SD 23 45 0.338 2 0.60 2 1
Diaz Einar CLE 17 34 0.333 0 0.49 2 1
Johnson Mark CWS 19 38 0.333 0 0.57 9 4
Molina Ben ANA 34 70 0.327 1 0.58 6 4
Redmond Mike FLA 21 44 0.323 0 0.68 2 2
Milabelli Doug SF 21 45 0.318 1 0.64 1 0
Miller Damian ARI 22 50 0.306 1 0.56 11 5
Posada Jorge NYY 30 70 0.300 1 0.53 4 5
Estalella Bobby SF 22 52 0.297 1 0.59 4 2
Hernandez Carlos SD-STL 24 57 0.296 0 0.89 1 3
Wilson Dan SEA 13 31 0.295 0 0.41 7 1
Reed Jeff CHC 12 30 0.286 1 0.48 4 0
Girardi Joe CHC 25 63 0.284 1 0.65 13 3
Kendall Jason PIT 34 87 0.281 1 0.61 4 7
Johnson Charles BAL-CWS 20 54 0.270 0 0.46 4 2
Stinnett Kelly ARZ 19 52 0.268 0 0.77 4 5
Widger Chris MON-SEA 19 53 0.264 1 0.70 1 1
Flaherty John TAM 27 79 0.255 1 0.78 2 1
Bako Paul HOU-FLA 14 41 0.255 1 0.63 7 1
Mayne Brent COL 17 54 0.239 0 0.60 2 3
Meluskey Mitch HOU 18 64 0.220 1 0.74 2 1
Alomar Jr. Sandy CLE 21 75 0.219 0 0.83 2 1
Hernandez Ramon OAK 19 68 0.218 1 0.58 8 3
Fletcher Darren TOR 20 73 0.215 0 0.72 1 5
Lopez Javier ATL 18 69 0.207 2 0.57 5 3
Hundley Todd LA 19 76 0.200 0 0.98 5 3
Taubensee Eddie CIN 12 50 0.194 0 0.76 2 5
Casanova Raul MIL 9 39 0.188 1 0.67 2 0
Varitek Jason BOS 24 104 0.188 0 0.87 10 3
Zaun Greg KC 13 57 0.186 0 0.88 0 1
Eusebio Tony HOU 8 37 0.178 0 0.62 2 4
Fordyce Brook CWS-BAL 11 55 0.167 0 0.68 5 2
Piazza Mike NYM 16 110 0.127 0 0.96 16 7
MLB Average   20 53 0.278 0.7 0.61 4 3
 

The new caught-stealing king in 2000 was Milwaukee's Henry Blanco, who took over a majority of the Brewer's catching duties after he arrived from Colorado in the four-team Vinny Castilla trade a year ago. Blanco gave the Brewers the defensive component they were looking for in a catcher. He posted a solid .991 fielding percentage and threw out 57.6 percent of all baserunners trying to steal.

Interestingly, the runnerup to Blanco also changed teams prior to the 2000 season. Mike Matheny moved from Toronto to St. Louis via free agency, and reached career highs in games played, hits, doubles, RBI, walks and the three hitting percentages. He topped his career year with a stellar .994 fielding percentage and a 51.1 percent success rate in nailing opposing baserunners.

Other than Pudge Rodriguez, Brad Ausmus is the only other catcher to return to the top five in this category from the 1999 season. [See 1999 Thieves] Ausmus boosted his caught-stealing percentage from 35.2 percent in '99 to 43.2 percent last summer. While Blanco and Matheny played on new teams in 2000, Ausmus makes his move this offseason. In December 2000 he was dealt from Detroit to Houston in a six-player trade that shipped young backstop Mitch Meluskey to the Tigers.

When it comes to stopping the running game, the Astros win out by dealing for Ausmus. Meluskey's caught-stealing percentage in 2000 was below the league average at 22 percent, and he allowed a very high .74 stolen bases per nine innings. Ausmus, on the other hand, ranked second behind I-Rod by giving up just .31 steals per nine.

Now that we've come back to Pudge, look for a healthy Rodriguez to return to the top of the pack in catching basestealers during the 2001 campaign. After all, in the five seasons prior to 2000, his league-leading caught-stealing percentage inched upward each year to a career high 52.8 percent in 1999. He retired more than half of all baserunners attempting to steal against him in the three years prior to last season, and in both '98 and '99 his lead over the second-best catcher at nailing basestealers was more than 14 percentage points.

So, to Henry Blanco, who suffered a rotator cuff injury late in 2000 that remains a concern this spring, we say, "Long live the King."



Hall Of Fame Catchers List of Catchers All-Star Catchers Post Season League Awards Batting Fielding Records Greatest Catcher 800 Games Caught HOME - Front Page Equipment Skills & Drills Articles About Catchers Trivia Quizes Quotes Rotisserie All-American Girls Professional Baseball Links 19th Century Current Catchers Ex-Catcher Managers Feedback HOME - Front Page HOME - Front Page Miscellaneous