 |
|
|
|
(Provided by Michael Mavrogiannis, author of Excruciating Baseball Lists)
Which Catcher caught a Pitcher's debut game? The below data includes all games played 1969-2003, as well as 1963 and
1965-1968 for the American League. List only includes those catchers who have 5
or more debutants. Decision in ALL CAPS was credited to debutant.
Suggested by New York broadcaster Suzyn Waldman.
The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet.
Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at 20 Sunset Rd., Newark, DE 19711.
RED = Hall-Of-Fame Catcher
BLUE = Current Catcher
| Carlton Fisk 15 | 6/25/1972 Lynn McGlothen, BOS at MIL, LOST 2-0 5/25/1977 Mike Paxton, BOS vs MIN, LOST 9-4 7/26/1977 Don Aase, BOS vs MIL, WON 4-3 CG 4/10/1978 Allen Ripley, BOS at CLE, lost 5-4 9/5/1978 Bobby Sprowl, BOS at BAL, LOST 4-1 8/16/1979 John Tudor, BOS vs CHA, won 7-5 7/13/1980 Bob Ojeda, BOS vs DET, won 8-4 7/21/1985 Bill Long, CHA vs CLE, lost 4-3 8/11/1985 Joel Davis, CHA vs MIL, WON 4-1 9/15/1987 Jack McDowell, CHA vs MIN, WON 6-2 4/28/1990 Jerry Kutzler, CHA vs TOR, WON 5-4 8/2/1990 Alex Fernandez, CHA at MIL, won 4-3 5/31/1991 Ramon Garcia, CHA vs OAK, won 5-4 9/2/1991 Roberto Hernandez, CHA vs KCA, WON 5-1 4/10/1993 Rod Bolton, CHA vs NYA, LOST 12-0 |
| Brad Ausmus 14 | 4/23/1994 Donnie Elliott, SDN vs PHI, won 8-2 5/10/1994 Jose Martinez, SDN vs CIN, LOST 5-0 5/24/1994 Joey Hamilton, SDN vs SFN, WON 6-3 6/22/1995 Glenn Dishman, SDN vs COL, LOST 3-2 4/2/1998 John Halama, HOU vs SFN, LOST 9-2 6/20/1998 Scott Elarton, HOU vs CIN, won 9-8 4/9/1999 Beiker Graterol, DET at NYA, LOST 12-3 4/14/1999 Jeff Weaver, DET vs MIN, WON 7-1 7/17/1999 Dave Borkowski, DET at HOU, lost 3-2 8/1/2000 Adam Bernero, DET at ANA, won 6-3 6/24/2001 Tim Redding, HOU vs CIN, won 7-5 6/18/2002 Kirk Saarloos, HOU at MIL, LOST 7-1 9/2/2002 Jeriome Robertson, HOU at TEX, LOST 7-2 6/21/2003 Rodrigo Rosario, HOU at TEX, WON 9-5 |
| Benito Santiago 14 | 9/17/1986 Ed Vosberg, SDN vs SFN, won 5-4 9/20/1986 Ray Hayward, SDN at HOU, LOST 10-6 9/21/1986 Jimmy Jones, SDN at HOU, WON 5-0 CG SHO 8/1/1987 Eric Nolte, SDN at HOU, WON 6-0 8/11/1989 Andy Benes, SDN vs ATL, LOST 6-5 8/11/1991 Ricky Bones, SDN vs CIN, WON 13-0 9/8/1992 Doug Brocail, SDN at SFN, lost 6-5 6/11/1994 Kurt Miller, FLO at PIT, LOST 10-4 6/25/1996 Rafael Quirico, PHI at CIN, LOST 9-1 8/8/1996 Matt Beech, PHI at ATL, WON 4-1 5/12/1997 Chris Carpenter, TOR at MIN, LOST 12-2 4/29/1999 Kyle Farnsworth, CHN at FLO, WON 5-2 5/19/2001 Ryan Jensen, SFN at ATL, won 6-3 4/26/2003 Jerome Williams, SFN at PHI, LOST 10-2 |
| Don Slaught 14 | 7/18/1982 Derek Botelho, KCA at BOS, WON 9-0 4/6/1984 Mark Gubicza, KCA vs CLE, LOST 2-0 6/26/1985 Bob Sebra, TEX at SEA, lost 5-4 9/10/1985 Jose Guzman, TEX at OAK, LOST 10-3 4/10/1986 Bobby Witt, TEX vs TOR, lost 11-10 7/24/1986 Mike Loynd, TEX vs CLE, WON 7-3 9/30/1986 Kevin Brown, TEX vs OAK, WON 9-5 5/26/1987 Bob Malloy, TEX at DET, lost 8-7 8/3/1988 Dave Eiland, NYA at MIL, lost 6-5 8/6/1990 Randy Tomlin, PIT at PHI, WON 10-1 CG 7/26/1992 Paul Wagner, PIT at ATL, won 5-4 7/31/1992 Tim Wakefield, PIT vs SLN, WON 3-2 CG 6/24/1995 John Ericks, PIT at MON, LOST 5-0 5/18/1996 Shad Williams, CAL at NYA, LOST 7-3 |
| Bob Boone 12 | 4/13/1973 Larry Christenson, PHI vs NYN, WON 7-1 CG 6/27/1973 Mike Wallace, PHI at NYN, WON 7-1 CG 7/5/1979 Dickie Noles, PHI vs NYN, LOST 3-2 5/26/1980 Bob Walk, PHI vs PIT, won 7-6 4/5/1984 Ron Romanick, CAL vs BOS, lost 7-4 5/1/1985 Kirk McCaskill, CAL vs TOR, LOST 6-3 7/27/1985 Tony Mack, CAL at TOR, LOST 8-3 7/1/1986 Mike Cook, CAL vs CHA, LOST 5-3 7/29/1986 Ray Chadwick, CAL at OAK, LOST 4-2 9/10/1986 Willie Fraser, CAL at CLE, won 7-6 7/7/1988 Terry Clark, CAL at CLE, WON 7-1 8/21/1990 Jim Campbell, KCA vs MIN, won 8-7 |
| Gary Carter 12 | 9/16/1976 Larry Landreth, MON vs CHN, WON 4-3 9/9/1977 Hal Dues, MON at PIT, WON 2-1 8/6/1978 Scott Sanderson, MON at CHN, lost 4-3 9/7/1978 Bob James, MON vs NYN, LOST 9-4 6/12/1980 Charlie Lea, MON vs SDN, WON 9-1 7/17/1983 Greg Bargar, MON at ATL, WON 3-1 4/15/1985 Bill Latham, NYN at PIT, LOST 4-1 6/9/1986 Rick Anderson, NYN vs PHI, lost 3-2 6/2/1987 Tom Edens, NYN at LAN, lost 6-3 9/24/1988 David West, NYN at SLN, WON 14-1 7/31/1990 Rafael Novoa, SFN vs HOU, won 3-2 6/9/1992 Jonathan Hurst, MON vs NYN, lost 6-5 |
| Kirt Manwaring 12 | 9/5/1988 Trevor Wilson, SFN vs SDN, LOST 7-4 9/12/1988 Dennis Cook, SFN at SDN, WON 4-2 9/6/1992 Larry Carter, SFN at SLN, LOST 5-3 5/29/1993 Greg Brummett, SFN at ATL, WON 6-3 8/29/1993 Salomon Torres, SFN at FLO, WON 9-3 7/24/1995 Jamie Brewington, SFN at FLO, WON 8-3 9/16/1995 Shawn Estes, SFN at PIT, LOST 10-2 4/5/1996 Osvaldo Fernandez, SFN at FLO, WON 7-1 5/11/1997 John Thomson, COL at PHI, LOST 3-1 5/18/1997 Bobby Jones, COL at NYN, lost 10-4 6/25/1998 Mike Saipe, COL vs HOU, won 6-5 7/21/1998 Mark Brownson, COL at HOU, WON 5-0 CG SHO |
| Joe Oliver 12 | 7/16/1990 Chris Hammond, CIN vs MON, won 8-3 8/9/1991 Mo Sanford, CIN at SDN, WON 5-1 9/1/1992 Tim Pugh, CIN vs MON, LOST 5-2 9/5/1992 Bobby Ayala, CIN vs NYN, won 6-5 7/3/1993 Larry Luebbers, CIN vs PIT, WON 5-3 6/24/1995 Brian Givens, MIL at DET, LOST 7-2 9/19/1996 Curt Lyons, CIN at PIT, lost 6-4 5/27/1997 Brett Tomko, CIN vs PHI, LOST 2-1 6/3/1998 Seth Greisinger, DET at TOR, LOST 5-1 6/27/1998 Brian Powell, DET vs CIN, lost 6-5 8/8/2000 Joel Pineiro, SEA at CHA, WON 12-4 4/6/2001 Christian Parker, NYA vs TOR, LOST 13-4 |
| Joe Girardi 11 | 8/22/1989 Joe Kraemer, CHN vs CIN, LOST 7-2 5/20/1990 Shawn Boskie, CHN at HOU, WON 5-1 CG 8/9/1990 Lance Dickson, CHN vs SLN, LOST 3-1 5/19/1993 Lance Painter, COL at SDN, LOST 7-3 7/26/1994 Mark Thompson, COL at SDN, WON 6-5 7/19/1995 Bryan Rekar, COL vs PHI, WON 5-3 5/25/1996 Ramiro Mendoza, NYA at SEA, WON 5-4 7/10/1997 Hideki Irabu, NYA vs DET, WON 10-3 4/9/2000 Scott Downs, CHN at CIN, lost 8-7 9/23/2000 Joey Nation, CHN vs SLN, LOST 6-5 5/22/2002 Mark Prior, CHN vs PIT, WON 7-4 |
| Lance Parrish 11 | 5/25/1978 Steve Baker, DET at BAL, lost 2-1 5/31/1979 Pat Underwood, DET at TOR, WON 1-0 7/8/1979 Dan Petry, DET at MIL, LOST 3-1 7/28/1979 Bruce Robbins, DET at TOR, LOST 3-0 4/12/1981 Howard Bailey, DET vs TOR, LOST 6-2 5/31/1981 George Cappuzzello, DET at BAL, won 5-4 8/4/1990 Joe Grahe, CAL vs OAK, won 6-5 9/25/1990 Scott Lewis, CAL at TEX, WON 8-2 9/10/1991 Kyle Abbott, CAL vs TEX, LOST 6-1 5/15/1994 Jon Lieber, PIT at PHI, LOST 1-0 7/29/1995 Giovanni Carrara, TOR vs OAK, WON 18-11 |
| Rick Cerone 10 | 4/10/1977 Jerry Garvin, TOR vs CHA, WON 3-1 9/6/1977 Mike Darr, TOR vs BOS, LOST 11-2 4/10/1979 Phil Huffman, TOR at CHA, WON 10-2 8/13/1979 Butch Edge, TOR at OAK, WON 4-2 9/17/1982 Stefan Wever, NYA at MIL, LOST 14-0 6/1/1985 Steve Shields, ATL at PIT, lost 6-3 7/25/1985 Joe Johnson, ATL at PHI, won 3-2 4/10/1986 Juan Nieves, MIL at CHA, won 8-5 9/15/1987 Al Leiter, NYA vs MIL, WON 4-3 7/10/1988 Steve Curry, BOS at CHA, LOST 4-1 |
| Terry Steinbach 10 | 9/17/1986 Rick Rodriguez, OAK vs TEX, LOST 4-0 9/11/1991 Todd Van Poppel, OAK vs CHA, won 6-5 7/18/1995 Steve Wojciechowski, OAK at MIL, LOST 4-0 5/26/1996 Bobby Chouinard, OAK at BAL, LOST 6-1 6/11/1996 Willie Adams, OAK at CLE, lost 6-5 7/26/1997 Shane Bowers, MIN vs BAL, lost 2-1 4/5/1998 Eric Milton, MIN vs KCA, WON 10-1 4/7/1999 Mike Lincoln, MIN vs TOR, LOST 9-3 7/24/1999 Mark Redman, MIN vs SEA, won 10-3 8/24/1999 Jason Ryan, MIN vs BOS, LOST 7-1 |
| Jim Sundberg 10 | 9/14/1975 Jim Gideon, TEX vs CHA, won 9-8 7/19/1976 Tommy Boggs, TEX vs BOS, won 4-3 9/14/1976 Len Barker, TEX vs CAL, lost 6-4 7/28/1978 Paul Mirabella, TEX at CHA, WON 9-5 7/11/1979 Jerry Gleaton, TEX at CHA, lost 5-3 9/8/1980 John Butcher, TEX at OAK, WON 6-2 CG 8/27/1982 Mike Smithson, TEX at BAL, LOST 3-1 CG 9/13/1982 Mike Mason, TEX at MIN, LOST 2-0 9/2/1988 Scott May, TEX at TOR, lost 7-6 7/24/1989 Wilson Alvarez, TEX vs TOR, LOST 6-3 |
| John Flaherty 9 | 6/14/1995 Pat Ahearne, DET vs NYA, LOST 12-3 9/4/1995 Clint Sodowsky, DET vs CLE, WON 3-2 4/1/1998 Rolando Arrojo, TBA vs DET, WON 11-8 5/5/1999 Ryan Rupe, TBA vs KCA, won 10-7 6/12/1999 Mickey Callaway, TBA at MON, WON 5-3 9/1/1999 Dan Wheeler, TBA at BAL, LOST 3-1 8/4/2000 Travis Harper, TBA vs BAL, lost 10-9 7/20/2002 Luis De Los Santos, TBA at TOR, LOST 12-10 6/28/2003 Brandon Claussen, NYA at NYN, WON 9-8 |
| Darrin Fletcher 9 | 6/10/1991 Andy Ashby, PHI at CIN, LOST 9-3 7/6/1992 Kent Bottenfield, MON at LAN, lost 4-3 7/8/1992 Bill Risley, MON at LAN, WON 4-1 7/7/1993 Kirk Rueter, MON vs SFN, WON 3-0 8/21/1995 Tavo Alvarez, MON vs LAN, LOST 7-2 4/4/1996 Jose Paniagua, MON at CIN, WON 10-2 9/20/1998 Roy Halladay, TOR at TBA, won 7-5 7/17/2000 Pasqual Coco, TOR vs NYN, lost 7-5 8/4/2001 Brandon Lyon, TOR vs BAL, WON 2-1 |
| Ivan Rodriguez 9 | 5/2/1992 Roger Pavlik, TEX at CHA, won 4-1 8/8/1993 Steve Dreyer, TEX vs SEA, WON 7-1 4/10/1994 Rick Helling, TEX at BAL, won 8-7 6/16/1994 John Dettmer, TEX vs OAK, LOST 6-4 7/28/1995 Scott Taylor, TEX vs BOS, LOST 6-2 7/25/2001 Justin Duchscherer, TEX vs BAL, WON 6-5 8/8/2001 Joaquin Benoit, TEX vs DET, lost 19-6 9/19/2002 Ben Kozlowski, TEX at SEA, won 12-7 5/9/2003 Dontrelle Willis, FLO vs COL, won 5-4 |
| Bruce Benedict 8 | 4/13/1982 Joe Cowley, ATL at CIN, won 8-5 5/13/1982 Ken Dayley, ATL vs SLN, LOST 10-9 4/10/1983 Craig McMurtry, ATL vs SDN, WON 4-3 4/12/1983 Rick Behenna, ATL vs CIN, WON 4-1 8/22/1984 Mike Payne, ATL at PIT, LOST 7-2 9/10/1984 Zane Smith, ATL at HOU, WON 3-1 7/23/1988 John Smoltz, ATL at NYN, WON 6-1 4/13/1989 Derek Lilliquist, ATL at SDN, WON 4-1 |
| Todd Hundley 8 | 7/2/1994 Jason Jacome, NYN at SDN, LOST 4-1 7/26/1994 Juan Castillo, NYN at SLN, won 10-9 6/17/1995 Bill Pulsipher, NYN vs HOU, LOST 7-3 7/17/1995 Jason Isringhausen, NYN at CHN, won 7-2 4/4/1996 Paul Wilson, NYN vs SLN, won 10-9 9/7/1999 Eric Gagne, LAN at FLO, lost 2-1 8/20/2001 Carlos Zambrano, CHN vs MIL, LOST 10-2 8/6/2002 Steve Smyth, CHN at SFN, lost 11-10 |
| Ron Karkovice 8 | 7/31/1991 Jeff Carter, CHA vs TEX, won 10-8 5/27/1993 Jason Bere, CHA vs KCA, LOST 6-4 6/19/1993 Scott Ruffcorn, CHA at CAL, LOST 5-4 4/30/1995 James Baldwin, CHA at BOS, won 17-11 6/2/1995 Brian Keyser, CHA vs DET, won 5-4 7/19/1995 Mike Sirotka, CHA vs BOS, LOST 5-3 7/29/1995 Mike Bertotti, CHA at BAL, WON 7-4 9/8/1995 Luis Andujar, CHA at OAK, WON 7-3 |
| Tony Pena 8 | 9/2/1981 Bob Long, PIT at LAN, LOST 6-2 9/4/1982 Lee Tunnell, PIT at LAN, WON 1-0 7/23/1983 Jose DeLeon, PIT vs SFN, WON 5-2 9/6/1986 Stan Fansler, PIT at ATL, LOST 4-2 5/14/1988 Cris Carpenter, SLN vs ATL, lost 7-5 7/5/1991 Kevin Morton, BOS vs DET, WON 10-1 CG 6/23/1993 Aaron Sele, BOS vs MIN, WON 3-1 8/1/1997 Scott Eyre, CHA at ANA, LOST 9-1 |
| Paul Casanova 7 | 6/1/1966 Dick Bosman, WS2 at BOS, WON 6-3 8/19/1967 Dick Nold, WS2 vs KC1, LOST 5-1 9/14/1968 Gerry Schoen, WS2 vs NYA, LOST 4-1 5/19/1971 Mike Thompson, WS2 vs BAL, LOST 4-1 6/20/1971 Pete Broberg, WS2 vs BOS, lost 4-3 9/1/1972 Jimmy Freeman, ATL vs PHI, WON 11-5 CG 9/10/1973 Wenty Ford, ATL vs SFN, WON 10-4 CG |
| Ron Hassey 7 | 9/5/1981 Tom Brennan, CLE vs CAL, WON 4-2 5/10/1982 John Bohnet, CLE at SEA, lost 6-4 8/21/1983 Mike Jeffcoat, CLE vs SEA, LOST 7-2 5/16/1984 Steve Farr, CLE vs BOS, LOST 5-2 4/11/1986 Bob Tewksbury, NYA vs MIL, WON 3-2 7/7/1986 Scott Nielsen, NYA at TEX, WON 14-3 9/19/1987 Adam Peterson, CHA vs SEA, won 10-8 |
| Ron Hodges 7 | 9/3/1973 Craig Swan, NYN vs PHI, LOST 6-3 9/13/1974 Nino Espinosa, NYN vs CHN, lost 4-3 9/16/1974 Randy Sterling, NYN at MON, WON 3-2 4/15/1979 Neil Allen, NYN vs PHI, LOST 6-3 7/7/1982 Brent Gaff, NYN vs SFN, LOST 3-2 <8/17/1982 Rick Ownbey, NYN at CIN, LOST 9-2 9/1/1984 Calvin Schiraldi, NYN vs SDN, won 10-6 |
| Charles Johnson 7 | 8/18/1997 Kirt Ojala, FLO vs PIT, lost 7-2 4/2/1998 Rafael Medina, FLO vs CHN, lost 8-7 9/9/1999 Matt Riley, BAL at MIN, won 6-5 7/24/2000 John Parrish, BAL vs NYA, LOST 4-3 9/4/2001 Josh Beckett, FLO vs CHN, WON 8-1 5/12/2003 Jason Young, COL vs NYN, LOST 9-6 7/25/2003 Chin-hui Tsao, COL vs MIL, WON 7-3 |
| Terry Kennedy 7 | 9/12/1980 Al Olmsted, SLN at PHI, won 5-0 4/12/1981 Chris Welsh, SDN at SFN, lost 7-6 7/17/1982 Andy Hawkins, SDN vs MON, LOST 4-1 5/9/1987 Jeff Ballard, BAL at CHA, won 15-6 9/10/1987 Jose Mesa, BAL at BOS, lost 5-4 8/3/1989 Russ Swan, SFN at LAN, LOST 6-3 9/2/1990 Paul McClellan, SFN at NYN, LOST 10-6 |
| Milt May 7 | 7/4/1971 Bruce Kison, PIT at CHN, lost 9-7 9/7/1974 Paul Siebert, HOU vs SDN, lost 8-4 4/11/1977 Dave Rozema, DET at TOR, lost 5-3 6/30/1980 Bill Bordley, SFN vs CIN, WON 8-4 4/7/1982 Alan Fowlkes, SFN at LAN, lost 9-2 4/17/1983 Mark Calvert, SFN vs CIN, LOST 12-3 9/5/1983 Alfonso Pulido, PIT at SLN, lost 7-6 |
| Phil Roof 7 | 7/3/1966 Jim Nash, KC1 at DET, WON 10-4 7/20/1969 Vida Blue, OAK at CAL, LOST 7-3 6/4/1970 Ray Peters, MIL vs CLE, LOST 8-4 4/13/1971 Bill Parsons, MIL vs OAK, LOST 2-0 CG 4/14/1971 Jim Slaton, MIL at CHA, WON 2-0 9/14/1974 Jim Hughes, MIN vs KCA, LOST 13-3 5/15/1976 Pete Redfern, MIN at CAL, WON 15-5 |
| Mike Stanley 7 | 9/5/1990 Scott Chiamparino, TEX vs CLE, won 3-2 8/9/1992 Sam Militello, NYA vs BOS, WON 6-0 9/11/1992 Sterling Hitchcock, NYA vs KCA, won 2-1 7/23/1993 Mark Hutton, NYA vs CAL, WON 5-2 8/8/1993 Domingo Jean, NYA at MIN, won 8-6 5/23/1995 Mariano Rivera, NYA at CAL, LOST 10-0 7/25/1997 Brian Rose, BOS vs ANA, lost 8-5 |
| Mickey Tettleton 7 | 9/7/1988 Curt Schilling, BAL vs BOS, won 4-3 9/13/1988 Pete Harnisch, BAL at BOS, LOST 6-4 9/18/1988 Bob Milacki, BAL at DET, WON 2-0 8/19/1990 Anthony Telford, BAL vs OAK, WON 3-2 6/29/1991 Rusty Meacham, DET vs CLE, WON 9-4 6/20/1992 Buddy Groom, DET at CHA, LOST 3-1 4/20/1994 Jose Lima, DET vs KCA, LOST 11-6 |
| Dave Valle 7 | 9/5/1988 Erik Hanson, SEA at MIN, LOST 2-0 9/8/1990 Rich DeLucia, SEA at BOS, lost 10-2 5/18/1991 Pat Rice, SEA at NYA, WON 4-1 6/16/1992 Mike Walker, SEA vs CHA, won 9-6 4/10/1993 John Cummings, SEA vs BAL, LOST 5-3 4/17/1993 Mike Hampton, SEA at DET, LOST 20-3 9/8/1993 Roger Salkeld, SEA at BAL, lost 6-3 |
| Dan Wilson 7 | 5/16/1993 John Roper, CIN vs COL, WON 14-2 7/18/1994 George Glinatsis, SEA vs BAL, won 7-5 8/18/1995 Bob Wolcott, SEA vs BOS, WON 9-3 6/5/1996 Matt Wagner, SEA at CLE, lost 13-5 8/9/1997 Ken Cloude, SEA vs CHA, LOST 5-2 4/7/1999 Freddy Garcia, SEA vs CHA, WON 7-3 7/6/1999 Gil Meche, SEA at ANA, lost 8-2 |
| Sandy Alomar 6 | 4/15/1990 Kevin Bearse, CLE at CHA, LOST 4-1 6/29/1990 Charles Nagy, CLE vs CAL, LOST 7-2 8/7/1993 Julian Tavarez, CLE at BAL, LOST 8-6 4/4/1997 Bartolo Colon, CLE at ANA, lost 8-6 6/24/1997 Jaret Wright, CLE vs MIN, WON 10-5 8/12/2003 Neal Cotts, CHA at ANA, won 10-4 |
| Johnny Bench 6 | 5/16/1971 Ross Grimsley, CIN vs MON, LOST 9-3 7/7/1974 Tom Carroll, CIN vs SLN, WON 2-1 9/12/1974 Pat Darcy, CIN vs ATL, WON 6-2 5/25/1977 Tom Hume, CIN at SFN, LOST 6-5 6/21/1977 Paul Moskau, CIN at PHI, won 10-5 6/14/1980 Joe Price, CIN at SLN, lost 4-3 |
| Bo Diaz 6 | 5/31/1983 Charles Hudson, PHI at LAN, LOST 4-1 9/1/1983 Tony Ghelfi, PHI vs SFN, WON 4-2 5/23/1987 Pat Pacillo, CIN vs PIT, LOST 3-2 8/19/1988 Norm Charlton, CIN at SLN, LOST 10-4 8/25/1988 Keith Brown, CIN vs SLN, WON 4-1 6/6/1989 Scott Scudder, CIN vs SFN, won 4-3 |
| Jim Essian 6 | 4/9/1978 Alan Wirth, OAK at CAL, LOST 3-2 4/10/1978 John Henry Johnson, OAK vs SEA, WON 1-0 6/11/1978 Mike Morgan, OAK vs BAL, LOST 3-0 CG 6/23/1978 Tim Conroy, OAK at KCA, won 5-4 6/28/1979 Brian Kingman, OAK at KCA, lost 7-6 8/13/1981 Reggie Patterson, CHA at BOS, LOST 9-6 |
| Mike Fitzgerald 6 | 4/7/1984 Dwight Gooden, NYN at HOU, WON 3-2 7/1/1985 Floyd Youmans, MON vs SLN, won 3-2 5/12/1987 Ubaldo Heredia, MON vs ATL, LOST 5-2 9/15/1988 Randy Johnson, MON vs PIT, WON 9-4 9/14/1990 Brian Barnes, MON vs PIT, won 4-2 6/21/1991 Chris Haney, MON at CIN, LOST 7-3 |
| Ed Herrmann 6 | 6/20/1969 Paul Edmondson, CHA at CAL, WON 9-1 CG 9/8/1969 Bart Johnson, CHA at SE1, LOST 2-1 6/7/1974 Joe Henderson, CHA vs BOS, won 8-6 7/18/1976 Dan Larson, HOU at MON, WON 14-1 CG 7/20/1976 Bo McLaughlin, HOU at PIT, won 4-3 9/14/1976 Mark Lemongello, HOU at ATL, WON 4-3 |
| Bob Kearney 6 | 9/11/1982 Chris Codiroli, OAK vs CHA, LOST 2-0 4/10/1983 Bill Krueger, OAK vs CAL, WON 11-4 6/24/1983 Curt Young, OAK at TEX, LOST 6-2 4/7/1984 Mark Langston, SEA vs MIL, WON 3-2 5/25/1985 Brian Snyder, SEA vs DET, lost 3-2 6/13/1985 Bill Wilkinson, SEA vs KCA, LOST 4-3 |
| Tim Laudner 6 | 5/15/1982 Pete Filson, MIN at DET, lost 5-4 6/6/1982 Frank Viola, MIN vs BAL, lost 7-5 9/11/1983 Jay Pettibone, MIN vs KCA, LOST 3-1 CG 5/1/1984 Ed Hodge, MIN at SEA, lost 11-8 4/13/1985 Rich Yett, MIN at SEA, lost 8-7 6/29/1989 Mike Dyer, MIN vs CAL, LOST 10-3 |
| Mike Lieberthal 6 | 4/6/1996 Rich Hunter, PHI vs CIN, LOST 8-4 6/7/1996 Carlos Crawford, PHI at HOU, LOST 11-5 6/14/1998 Carlton Loewer, PHI vs CHN, WON 4-2 CG 6/11/1999 Randy Wolf, PHI vs TOR, WON 8-4 6/23/2000 Dave Coggin, PHI at MON, WON 13-6 7/24/2002 Brett Myers, PHI at CHN, WON 4-2 |
| Mike Macfarlane 6 | 9/10/1990 Hector Wagner, KCA vs TOR, LOST 6-1 7/28/1992 Dennis Moeller, KCA at TOR, LOST 6-4 9/6/1992 Ed Pierce, KCA vs CHA, won 3-2 5/2/1995 Vaughn Eshelman, BOS at NYA, WON 8-0 7/17/1995 Jeff Suppan, BOS vs KCA, LOST 4-3 5/10/1998 Blake Stein, OAK vs CHA, LOST 4-3 |
| Brent Mayne 6 | 5/23/1995 Jim Pittsley, KCA at TOR, lost 10-6 4/29/2001 Shawn Chacon, COL vs CIN, won 14-7 7/26/2001 Chris George, KCA at SEA, LOST 4-0 6/18/2002 Shawn Sedlacek, KCA at MON, lost 5-4 9/20/2002 Wes Obermueller, KCA vs CLE, LOST 6-2 8/3/2003 Jimmy Gobble, KCA vs TBA, WON 2-0 |
| Junior Ortiz 6 | 9/6/1983 Ron Darling, NYN vs PHI, LOST 2-0 7/1/1986 Rich Sauveur, PIT vs PHI, lost 5-4 6/25/1990 Scott Erickson, MIN vs TEX, WON 9-1 9/12/1992 Dave Mlicki, CLE at CHA, won 5-3 9/15/1992 Alan Embree, CLE at TOR, LOST 5-4 7/6/1993 Albie Lopez, CLE at OAK, won 11-8 |
| Buck Rodgers 6 | 9/11/1963 Aubrey Gatewood, LAA vs BOS, WON 4-1 CG 4/18/1965 Rudy May, CAL vs DET, lost 4-1 9/20/1965 Jim McGlothlin, CAL vs BAL, LOST 4-2 5/30/1966 Minnie Rojas, CAL vs CLE, WON 5-1 6/15/1966 Clyde Wright, CAL at MIN, WON 8-1 CG 8/21/1966 Ramon Lopez, CAL at WS2, LOST 7-4 |
| Mike Scioscia 6 | 8/9/1987 Shawn Hillegas, LAN vs ATL, WON 5-2 7/19/1988 William Brennan, LAN at SLN, LOST 3-2 8/13/1988 Ramon Martinez, LAN vs SFN, won 2-1 7/3/1990 Terry Wells, LAN vs CHN, won 7-6 8/1/1990 Jim Neidlinger, LAN vs SFN, lost 2-1 7/3/1992 Pedro Astacio, LAN vs PHI, WON 2-0 CG SHO |
| Ted Simmons 6 | 9/30/1969 Santiago Guzman, SLN vs PHI, LOST 4-3 10/1/1969 Reggie Cleveland, SLN vs PHI, won 6-5 7/16/1972 Don Durham, SLN vs CIN, LOST 4-1 7/21/1975 Eric Rasmussen, SLN at SDN, WON 4-0 CG SHO 6/19/1979 John Fulgham, SLN at SDN, WON 7-2 CG 9/15/1980 Andy Rincon, SLN at CHN, WON 5-1 CG |
| Ozzie Virgil 6 | 6/25/1983 Kevin Gross, PHI at NYN, WON 4-2 8/17/1987 Tom Glavine, ATL at HOU, LOST 11-2 9/5/1987 Kevin Coffman, ATL vs MON, LOST 4-1 9/8/1987 Pete Smith, ATL vs SDN, WON 4-2 6/28/1988 German Jimenez, ATL vs SFN, LOST 13-7 9/20/1988 Kevin Blankenship, ATL vs SFN, LOST 7-4 |
| Chris Widger 6 | 9/2/1997 Mike Thurman, MON vs BOS, won 6-5 4/3/1998 Javier Vazquez, MON at CHN, LOST 6-2 5/23/1998 Carl Pavano, MON vs PHI, won 3-2 7/23/1998 Jeremy Powell, MON at CHN, LOST 2-1 6/8/1999 Dan Smith, MON vs BOS, WON 5-1 8/16/1999 Tony Armas, MON at SFN, LOST 7-4 |
| Paul Bako 5 | 6/16/1998 Denny Harriger, DET vs MIN, LOST 8-5 5/11/2000 Jason Grilli, FLO vs ATL, WON 5-4 6/13/2000 Chuck Smith, FLO at PHI, lost 4-3 9/2/2002 Ben Diggins, MIL at CHN, LOST 17-4 7/22/2003 Sergio Mitre, CHN at ATL, LOST 8-4 |
| Jody Davis 5 | 6/8/1982 Tom Filer, CHN at PHI, LOST 5-2 7/30/1985 Steve Engel, CHN vs SLN, LOST 11-3 9/14/1986 Drew Hall, CHN at PIT, LOST 9-2 5/31/1988 Jeff Pico, CHN vs CIN, WON 4-0 CG SHO 9/10/1989 Tommy Greene, ATL at CIN, lost 5-4 |
| Einar Diaz 5 | 5/21/2000 Paul Rigdon, CLE vs NYA, WON 6-1 5/24/2000 Tim Drew, CLE at DET, lost 10-9 4/8/2001 C.C. Sabathia, CLE vs BAL, won 4-3 8/21/2002 Ricardo Rodriguez, CLE vs OAK, LOST 6-0 8/12/2003 Juan Dominguez, TEX vs DET, LOST 7-4 |
| Mike Difelice 5 | 8/4/1997 Manny Aybar, SLN at NYN, LOST 4-2 8/29/1997 Sean Lowe, SLN at KCA, won 9-7 6/6/2001< Joe Kennedy, TBA at TOR, WON 6-2 4/20/2002 Josh Pearce, SLN at MIL, lost 5-3 5/1/2003 Kyle Snyder, KCA at BOS, lost 6-5 |
| Barry Foote 5 | 5/26/1974 Dennis Blair, MON at PHI, WON 5-1 9/8/1976 Gerry Hannahs, MON at SLN, won 8-7 9/18/1976 Joe Keener, MON vs SLN, LOST 7-4 9/6/1980 Randy Martz, CHN vs CIN, LOST 6-1 5/4/1981 Gene Nelson, NYA at CAL, WON 4-2 |
| Russ Gibson 5 | 4/14/1967 Billy Rohr, BOS at NYA, WON 3-0 CG SHO 6/11/1967 Gary Waslewski, BOS vs WS2, lost 8-7 5/3/1970 Migel Puente, SFN vs PHI, lost 13-6 8/1/1970 Don Carrithers, SFN at PHI, LOST 6-1 9/5/1971 Jim Willoughby, SFN vs HOU, LOST 5-3 |
| Mike Heath 5 | 7/2/1978 Dave Rajsich, NYA vs DET, won 5-3 7/12/1983 Gorman Heimueller, OAK at BAL, LOST 3-1 6/3/1986 Greg Mathews, SLN at HOU, WON 3-1 8/29/1988 Steve Searcy, DET at CHA, LOST 3-2 8/17/1989 Brian Dubois, DET vs NYA, LOST 2-1 |
| Carlos Hernandez 5 | 8/27/1998 Stan Spencer, SDN at PHI, WON 8-1 4/29/2000 Rodrigo Lopez, SDN vs ATL, lost 7-4 5/30/2000 Adam Eaton, SDN vs MIL, WON 6-3 6/20/2000 Brian Tollberg, SDN at ARI, WON 3-1 8/20/2000 Britt Reames, SLN vs PHI, LOST 6-0 |
| Fred Kendall 5 | 9/8/1969 Mike Corkins, SDN at HOU, LOST 9-2 4/26/1974 Dave Freisleben, SDN vs PHI, WON 6-2 CG 5/21/1974 Dan Spillner, SDN at HOU, LOST 5-4 4/16/1976 Dave Wehrmeister, SDN at HOU, LOST 4-1 9/25/1976 Bob Owchinko, SDN at ATL, LOST 11-8 |
| Jason Kendall 5 | 5/21/1996 Matt Ruebel, PIT at COL, lost 12-10 6/24/1996 Elmer Dessens, PIT at MON, LOST 11-3 8/25/1998 Sean Lawrence, PIT at ARI, WON 9-6 4/9/1999 Kris Benson, PIT vs CHN, WON 2-1 5/13/2000 Brian O'Connor, PIT vs MIL, won 11-8 |
| Tom Lampkin 5 | 4/4/1997 Matt Morris, SLN at HOU, lost 3-2 4/15/1997 Brady Raggio, SLN at FLO, WON 9-3 4/2/1998 Cliff Politte, SLN vs LAN, won 8-5 4/28/2002 Ben Howard, SDN at PIT, lost 3-2 5/10/2002 Dennis Tankersley, SDN at ATL, lost 7-3 |
| Buck Martinez 5 | 8/12/1971 Lance Clemons, KCA at WS2, lost 2-1 4/17/1978 Randy Stein, MIL at BOS, LOST 9-2 5/27/1980 Rickey Keeton, MIL vs SEA, WON 4-1 8/30/1982 Mark Eichhorn, TOR vs BAL, LOST 6-3 8/2/1983 Matt Williams, TOR vs NYA, WON 13-6 |
| Bob Melvin 5 | 6/8/1986 Terry Mulholland, SFN vs CIN, won 3-1 7/29/1986 Kelly Downs, SFN at LAN, LOST 2-1 8/4/1991 Mike Mussina, BAL at CHA, LOST 1-0 8/21/1991 Arthur Rhodes, BAL at TEX, won 4-3 9/12/1993 Nate Minchey, BOS at CLE, WON 11-1 CG |
| Dale Murphy 5 | 9/14/1976 Al Autry, ATL vs HOU, WON 4-3 9/15/1976 Rick Camp, ATL vs HOU, LOST 4-3 9/13/1977 Mickey Mahler, ATL at SFN, lost 8-7 4/8/1979 Rick Matula, ATL at HOU, LOST 2-0 5/19/1979 Tony Brizzolara, ATL vs SFN, lost 4-2 |
| Charlie O'Brien 5 | 9/1/1990 Julio Valera, NYN vs SFN, WON 6-5 8/14/1993 Bobby Jones, NYN at PHI, WON 9-5 7/22/1994 Brad Woodall, ATL at SLN, LOST 3-2 5/26/1998 Jim Parque, CHA vs NYA, lost 7-5 6/3/2000 T.J. Tucker, MON vs BAL, won 7-4 |
| Tom Pagnozzi 5 | 4/25/1987 Joe Magrane, SLN at NYN, WON 3-2 8/15/1991 Rheal Cormier, SLN vs NYN, WON 4-1 4/9/1992 Donovan Osborne, SLN vs NYN, lost 7-1 7/8/1993 Allen Watson, SLN vs ATL, WON 7-1 7/21/1994 John Frascatore, SLN vs ATL, LOST 6-1 |
| Mark Parent 5 | 7/31/1992 Richie Lewis, BAL at BOS, WON 4-3 4/29/1995 Esteban Loaiza, PIT at PHI, WON 3-2 6/21/1995 Steve Parris, PIT vs SFN, lost 6-5 5/21/1997 Edgar Ramos, PHI at CHN, LOST 7-0 6/7/1997 Ryan Nye, PHI at PIT, LOST 9-2 |
| Eddie Perez 5 | 6/11/1997 Chris Brock, ATL at COL, lost 9-6 9/7/1998 Bruce Chen, ATL at NYN, lost 8-7 9/16/2002 Brian Tallet, CLE at BOS, WON 7-1 8/2/2003 David Manning, MIL at MON, LOST 7-1 9/3/2003 Luis Martinez, MIL vs CIN, won 9-6 |
| Tom Prince 5 | 8/8/1988 Rick Reed, PIT vs NYN, WON 1-0 7/30/1991 Paul Miller, PIT at ATL, lost 10-3 8/10/1991 Hector Fajardo, PIT vs SLN, won 11-5 8/29/1993 John Hope, PIT vs SDN, LOST 11-0 5/26/2001 Brad Thomas, MIN vs OAK, won 7-6 |
| Mike Redmond 5 | 8/17/1999 A.J. Burnett, FLO at LAN, WON 6-1 9/8/1999 Michael Tejera, FLO vs LAN, won 5-4 5/4/2002 Nate Teut, FLO at MIL, LOST 6-4 9/3/2002 Justin Wayne, FLO at NYN, LOST 11-5 9/7/2002 Nate Robertson, FLO at PIT, LOST 4-1 |
| Jeff Reed 5 | 6/11/1986 Allan Anderson, MIN vs TEX, lost 6-2 6/19/1987 Jeff Fischer, MON at SLN, won 8-7 7/3/1996 Jamey Wright, COL at SFN, won 3-2 9/7/1999 Brian McNichol, CHN vs CIN, LOST 10-3 8/3/2000 Phil Norton, CHN at SDN, lost 6-5 |
| Scott Servais 5 | 4/9/1992 Butch Henry, HOU vs CIN, won 6-5 5/16/1996 Amaury Telemaco, CHN vs HOU, WON 13-1 5/27/1997 Jeremi Gonzalez, CHN at PIT, WON 8-7 4/12/1998 Kerry Wood, CHN at MON, LOST 4-1 4/21/1999 Joe Nathan, SFN vs FLO, WON 4-0 |
| Kelly Stinnett 5 | 4/4/2001 Chris Reitsma, CIN vs PIT, lost 6-5 5/16/2001 Brian Reith, CIN vs ARI, LOST 2-1 6/16/2001 Lance Davis, CIN vs COL, lost 8-7 6/19/2001 Jose Acevedo, CIN vs MIL, LOST 10-8 8/2/2003 Josh Hall, CIN vs SFN, won 5-4 |
| Gene Tenace 5 | 5/29/1972 Dave Hamilton, OAK at TEX, WON 7-1 7/29/1973 Glenn Abbott, OAK vs TEX, won 7-4 4/10/1975 Mike Norris, OAK vs CHA, WON 9-0 CG SHO 4/10/1977 Bob Shirley, SDN at CIN, WON 12-4 9/20/1980 George Stablein, SDN vs ATL, won 3-2 |
| Bob Tillman 5 | 4/13/1963 Dave Morehead, BOS at WS2, WON 3-0 CG SHO 4/14/1963 Jerry Stephenson, BOS at WS2, lost 7-6 6/19/1963 Bob Heffner, BOS vs DET, WON 9-2 CG 4/23/1965 Jim Lonborg, BOS at BAL, LOST 4-2 10/2/1969 Mike McQueen, ATL vs CIN, lost 8-3 |
| Butch Wynegar 5 | 4/6/1978< Roger Erickson, MIN at SEA, WON 5-4 5/7/1980 Albert Williams, MIN at BAL, lost 8-6 <6/5/1981 Brad Havens, MIN at DET, LOST 2-0 6/30/1983 Ray Fontenot, NYA vs BAL, won 4-3 8/7/1984 Jim Deshaies, NYA vs CHA, LOST 6-3 |
| Greg Zaun 5 | 9/29/1996 Andy Larkin, FLO at HOU, lost 5-4 4/5/1997 Tony Saunders, FLO vs CIN, won 4-3 4/4/1998 Brian Meadows, FLO vs MIL, LOST 6-2 5/23/1998 Joe Fontenot, FLO vs PIT, LOST 10-4 9/22/2001 Mike MacDougal, KCA at CHA, lost 5-4 |
