ERRORS IN THE ENCHANTED CHRISTMAS
BEAUTY AND THE BEAST:THE ENCHANTED CHRISTMAS was released in 1997
by the television arm of Walt Disney Productions. It is a blasphemy-
a vicious insult to the fans of BATB,who were duped into believing
that a sequel was on the way.Instead,they delivered THIS. TEC is little
more than a Saturday morning cartoon.The characters have been
messed with to the point where their personalities change. I mean,
it's rather obvious that the makers of TEC barely watched BATB.(And
they have the nerve to acknowledge BATB in the credits! Robby Benson
and Paige O'Hara deserved better,and Tim Curry does his best with
what little he's given. Paul Reubens is Fife,one of the most annoying
animated characters ever-"Oooh,my SOLO,my SOLO!" Solos are one thing
Paul Reubens knows how to perform,I suppose,so he almost had the-
very phallic-character down.
I am a firm believer in the parallel universe theory. I believe
that somewhere,there is a whole universe where the characters of
BEAUTY AND THE BEAST are real people...it's a place of undying love
and beauty...wouldn't that be cool? Well,if it was good enough for
Einstein,it's good enough for me. TEC is set in a completely different
universe in relation to BATB.It's undeniable. The errors made in this
movie completely nullify the possibility that the two are even related.
This is a list of errors that I compiled while watching
TEC-in disgusted horror,I might add. This list contains cold hard
merciless facts,and if you cannot handle it...that's just tough.
1. FACT: Chip's hair is brown. Here,his hair is blond. Also,the
original voice of Chip(Bradley Michael Pierce)is conspicuously absent.
That's NOT Chip!
2. Ty Burr of ENTERTAINMENT WEEKLY commented on the cheaply animated
characters,and I agree. There's just the barest resemblance,and I
refuse to believe that Mrs. Potts's face shrank into her skull and
Belle's eyes changed shape. (They had SIX YEARS to animate this!)
3. FACT: Beast is quite agile.He scales walls.He jumps with the
agility and grace of a cat. Why can't he stay on his feet on the
ice?(I like the fact that they were smart enough to realize that
there's a moat down there,however.)
4.Where was Forte in the original film? The same goes for Angelique
and Fife! I don't see them in the ballroom at the end,nor in any
part of the castle!
5. "Will you do me the honor,old friend?" OLD FRIEND?! WHAT? WHAT
FRIENDS?! (Such is my complaint with Michael Tunnel's BEAUTY AND THE
BEASTLY CHILDREN-besides the fact that it even exists.)
6. FACT: In the original movie,Beast's room was cluttered with
junk-busts,ripped paintings,a broken bed,etc. Are we supposed to
believe that Forte is in or around there? Well,he WASN'T in BATB!
7.FACT: Cogsworth,in BATB,reacts immediately to Lumiere's flames.
Here,why does he react so slowly? He's MADE OF WOOD!
8.Since when is Cogsworth tempted with food? He seems to be on a diet
in BATB. Did you notice that? He reacts almost NEGATIVELY around food.
"Glass of water,crust of bread..." He must come from a family of
large men(I sure do!)
9. FACT: Beast is not an idiot.I refuse to believe that he wouldn't
realize what Forte was doing.
Okay...now we have an especially bad scene. Beast remembers the
night when he was transformed by the Enchantress.Which happens to
be at Christmastime...yeah,RIGHT...This whole scene actually proves
that this was actually taking place in a parallel universe.
10.(1) FACT: The Enchantress appeared first as an UGLY old woman.
Here,she looks like my GRANDMOTHER. Actually,she looks like Granny
(Tweety's owner?) What happened to "repulsed by her HAGGARD
appearance...?"
(2) At the beginning of BATB,the stained-glass shows her bent,
hunched over,but NOT HERE. She has no deformity,and I'm pretty sure
that the wrong eye is closed. Plus,there was a tooth jutting out of
her mouth...and it's not there in TEC.
(3) She's also wearing a red cloak here.In the stained glass,
she wears a green...whatever...that becomes a gown.
(4) The Prince refused her TWICE,not once,as shown here. And the
line with which he refuses her..."I don't need a rose." What rocket
scientist came up with THAT line? I don't need a rose? She did that
to him because of "I don't need a rose?" I DON'T think so.I can't
accept the "Please accept this rose..." line either. It's cold as
hell outside,you're standing there dying of the cold,and the door opens.
You look up at the guy and say,"Please accept this rose,etc..."
What planet are YOU from? Say hi,hello,sir,I'm really cold,see my
chattery teeth,god you're a hunk,awfully big for an 11-year-old,
mothers lock up your daughters...
(5) FACT:The Enchantress had LONG blonde hair.Here it's lemony
yellow and noticeably shorter.Plus,in the stained-glass,her eyes
are closed.So why are they open here?
(6) FACT: The Prince is dressed quite regally in the stained glass.
Here,he's dressed in a white poet's shirt and black pants.I WANT THAT
SHIRT!
(7) He closed the door before she cursed him.And he doesn't scream
convincingly while he's being transformed. He sounds like she just
stomped his toes.
11. WHAT boiler room? I mean,it's great that they have heat,but...
and why did the boiler have to be alive?
12.FACT: The castle grounds have been rearranged.Those damn developers
from POLTERGEIST went and moved the forest,and then brought it back.
13.They had no bat problem in BATB.How did the bats from the woods
get into the castle?
14. FACT: Beast never used no double negatives in BATB.Here,he says
"There won't be no Christmas!" and that ain't never something he'd say.
15.FACT:Beast's cheeks do not puff out as they did here. The line
about "getting her a little something" sucks. So does Beast yelling
for Cogsworth.He never did that in BATB.(Actually,I think it's a
misguided homage to SUPERMAN..."Miss TESSMACHERRRRRRRRR!" They stole
that,and ripped off SLEEPER, VOLTRON and A CHARLIE BROWN CHRISTMAS-
among other things. Did I mention that most of the script sucks?
I could've dined on wood chips and pencil lead,waited a few hours,
and pulled a better script out of my anus. Where was Linda Woolverton
when we needed her? Probably far away from here.(Have you seen her
interviews? She's a very intelligent,articulate woman.) IT TOOK FOUR
PEOPLE TO WRITE THIS!
16.FACT: Nobody in BATB ever mentions Christmas.NOT ONCE.
17. How come no one else can hear Forte except Beast,Belle and Sultan?
And why can't they hear him from INSIDE the castle?
18."You lazy old clock!" (Come on,this is Lumiere,the man who said,
"You...you overgrown pocketwatch!" and "You look so...so..." Silence
can be a weapon,folks.
19.Why didn't Belle say "Thank you for saving my life again..."
after Beast rescued her from the lake? She obviously had time. Beast
dried her off.(Hypothermia KILLS.) So he kept her warm...and then
threw her in the dungeon? Come ON. Beast isn't stupid. He could have
figured out what was happening there,evil organ or no evil organ.
Blame the writers.
20.FACT: I'm really sorry to have to say this...but Beast can't read!
So how can he read Belle's story? He hasn't even given her the library
yet...
21.FACT:The wolves had pupils in their eyes,and now they are only
glowing yellow sockets.
22.FACT:Snowboarding did not exist in the 18th century.(Don't ask.)
23.FACT:Lumiere and Cogsworth are good friends,even though they
seem to be enemies sometimes.(Spock/McCoy relationship)"A Cut Above The
Rest" is completely unneccessary.
24.FACT: The rose is enchanted. The bell jar isn't.Why are they
concerned about the jar when it's about to fall? The rose is floating.
(Although it IS a beautiful jar...)
25.There was no real suspense in this film. Forte was a mere
annoyance-another standee in the long line of cliched cartoon villains
who lack what it takes to win. Gaston would've kicked in his pipes.
There was an element of foreshadowing in this film. "Don't Fall In
Love" was tedious,because you already know it doesn't work. (And
who came up with the green energy angels? Yech. (just a note-my
mom is an organist,and so I know something about organs.All they
had to do was turn Forte off!(although ripping the keyboard free
and doing a Kurt Cobain with it worked just as well.)
26.Now for two mistakes noticed by a friend of mine who shall be
known as Racer X. (1) The bandage that Belle dressed Beast's wound
with is gone. You know,that wound caused by the wolves? I don't think
that would've healed overnight.(2)The pooch seems to have de-aged.
(I think it's a puppy,though.) (3)This is a complaint shared by us
both:Why don't Belle and the Prince have a child or children?(It's
only a parallel universe,but what the hell,right?) It's obvious that
their relationship is going to involve sex at the end of BATB-the
way they LOOK at each other is indication enough-(and I believe they do
have a child)and they're not present for the story, which is being told
by Mrs. Potts in flashback.My guess is that they're having a celebration
of their own,if you know what I mean.)
It's now time for the one thing they did right:The final scene,out
on the balcony.
27.I found it interesting that the door opens-there ARE two doors,
you know,not just one-on Belle and the Prince on the balcony,gazing
into each others' eyes,holding each other close. Then the Prince
gestures WAIT. He pulls a present from his jacket,momentarily
surprising Belle. He waits in eager anticipation as Belle opens the
package...and there's a rose inside.She smiles when she sees it,
and then looks up at him,and he's smiling too. They turn,with their
arms around each other,to look at the night sky,filled with stars.
I don't know how to explain it. It's like realities suddenly shifted
in a way that our eyes cannot decieve,showing us the truth after
being exposed to the lie.