(The Indian Practitioner, (1984): 11, 1045.)

SEPTILIN in Otolaryngology

S.N. Luley,
Reader and Head of the Department of E.N.T.

and

V. Kalbande,
Student, E.N.T. Department.,
Indira Gandhi Medical College, Nagpur.

 

INTRODUCTION

Septilin is an Ayurvedic preparation which contains antibacterial and anti-inflammatory principles.

Septilin has been reported by Behl and Tripathi1 to stimulate phagocytosis. Cahn and Hirsh2 demonstrated the presence of an antibacterial protein, phagocytin, in the cytoplasmic granules of polymorphs. Pagocytin has an antibacterial effect on both gram-positive and gram-negative organisms.

Septilin produces a rise in the phagocytic coefficient, which corresponds with clinical coefficient, which corresponds with clinical improvement in chronic infections resistant to the commonly used broad-spectrum antibiotics. Septilin improves the defence mechanism of the body. Septilin is excellently tolerated and can be given for prolonged periods without developing drug resistance or untoward reactions. Similar observations have also been made by Gadre,3 Lakshmipathi,4 Vishwakarma5 and Sheth.6

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This study on Septilin was conducted at the Dept. of E.N.T., Indira Gandhi Medical College, Nagpur from September 1983 to February 1984. In all, 182 patients attending the E.N.T. Out-patients’ Dept. were included in this study. Out of these, 100 patients completed a 3 weeks’ course of drug treatment and only they were evaluated.

The patients selected were having tonsillopharyngitis, chronic suppurative otitis media or chronic maxillary sinusitis. All the patients had also taken other drugs in the past without much improvement.

In some cases swabs of the throat, ear and nose were taken for culture and sensitivity tests before starting Septilin treatment. The same bacteriological examinations were repeated after completion of treatment.

Each patient was reviewed after a week and the progress was noted, depending on the improvement in signs and symptoms. The results were classified into four groups, i.e. "Very Good", "Good", "Fair" and "Poor".

OBSERVATIONS

Out of the 100 patients, 57% were females and 43% males. The maximum number of patients (47%) were in the 21-30 age group. The youngest patient was 5 years old and the oldest 60.

 

Table 1 : Showing the age and sex incidence

Age group

Total no. of patients

Male

Female

0 to 10 years

2

2

11 to 20 years

24

6

18

21 to 30 years

37

16

21

31 to 40 years

21

10

11

41 to 50 years

10

5

5

Above 50 years

6

4

2

Total

100

43

57

In tonsillitis and pharyngitis

In 60 patients with tonsillitis and pharyngitis the commonest symptom was discomfort in the throat which was present in all cases and showed improvement in 50% of them. Dryness of the throat improved in 89%, halitosis in 86%, pain in the throat in 62% and sticky secretions disappeared in 63% of cases.

Table 2 : Showing signs and symptoms in tonsillopharyngitis before and after treatment

 

Signs and
Symptoms

No. of patients
before treatment

No. of patients
who improved after treatment

  Symptoms

1.

Discomfort in the throat

60

30 (50%)

2.

Pain in the throat

53

33 (62%)

3.

Sticky secretions

22

14 (63%)

4.

Dryness

36

32 (89%)

5.

Halitosis

29

25 (86%)

 

Signs

1.

Congestion

59

37 (63%)

2.

Follicles

31

25 (81%)

3.

Post-nasal secretions

40

32 (80%)

4.

Fever

18

18 (100%)

In chronic suppurative otitis media

Out of the 25 cases of chronic suppurative otitis media, the ears became dry in 17 patients (68%). Improvement in other signs and symptoms included headache (100%), foul smell (71%) and deafness (24%). There was no change in the tympanic membrane perforations.

Table 3 : Showing signs and symptoms in chronic suppurative otitis media before and after treatment

 

Signs and
Symptoms

No. of patients
before treatment

No. of patients
who improved after treatment

1.

Ear discharge

25

17 (68%)

 

Mucoid

(15)

(11) (73%)

 

Mucopurulent

(4)

(2) (50%)

 

Purulent

(6)

(4) (67%)

2.

Foul smell

7

5 (71%)

3.

Headache

3

3 (100%)

4.

Deafness

25

6 (24%)

 

Conductive

(22)

(6) (27%)

 

Mixed

(3)

5.

Tympanic membrane perforations

25

 

Central

(19)

 
 

Subtotal

(3)

 
 

Total

(3)

 

In chronic maxillary sinusitis

15 cases of chronic maxillary sinusitis completed the treatment. Table 4 shows significant improvement in sinus tenderness in 100%, headache in 87% and nasal discharge in 80% of cases. Reduction in the size of the inferior turbinate, though in only 50% of cases, is also significant. More prolonged treatment would seem necessary in these cases.

Table 4 : Showing signs and symptoms in chronic maxillary sinusitis
before and after treatment

 

Signs and
Symptoms

No. of patients
before treatment

No. of patients
who improved after treatment

1.

Headache

15

13 (87%)

2.

Nasal obstruction

13

10 (77%)

3.

Nasal discharge

10

8 (80%)

4.

Post-nasal discharge

5

3 (60%)

5.

Foul smell

4

3 (75%)

6.

Deviated nasal septum

7

7.

Sinus tenderness

9

9 (100%)

8.

Hypertrophy of the inferior turbinate

8

4 (50%)

Bacteriological examinations

Before treatment, bacteriological examinations and sensitivity tests were done in 25 cases. After treatment they showed sterile cultures in 19 cases (76%) and no change in 6 cases (24%). Table 5 shows the details.

Table 5 : Bacteriological examinations

Sl.

Diagnosis

Before treatment

No. of

After treatment

No.

 

Micro-organisms found

Sensitive to

patients

Swab sterile

No change

1.

Tonsillo-pharyngitis
(15 cases)
Gram +ve cocci

P.
A.
S.
G.

15

12

3

2.

Chronic suppurative
otitis media
(5 cases)
Gram –ve bacilli


Gram +ve cocci

G.
S.

P.
A.
S.
G.

4


1

3


1

1


3.

Chronic maxillary sinusitis
(5 cases)

Gram –ve cocci

P.
S.
G.
A.
E.

5

3

2

 

Total

   

25

19

6

P. = Pencillin, A. = Ampicillin, S. = Streptomycin, G. = Gentamycin, E. = Erythromycin

DOSAGE

The dosages employed were as follows:

(a) In adults — 2 tablets, t.i.d.

(b) In children — 1 tablet, t.i.d.

Therapy was continued for 3 weeks in all the patients. Only in 8 cases was the treatment continued for 5 weeks. Clinical improvement was noticed in 34 cases from the 1st week, 33 cases from the 2nd week and 18 cases from the 3rd week.

No other antibacterial agents were used during the trial. Only in some cases antihistaminics, gargles and nasal decongestants were employed as required.

 

RESULTS

The following critieria were used to assess the results:

(i)

Very good—when there are subjective improvement, disappearance of signs and the swab became negative.

(ii)

Good—when there was subjective improvement, partial improvement in signs and the swab became negative.

(iii)

Fair—when there was only subjective improvement.

(iv)

Poor—no change seen.

As Table 6 reveals, "Very Good" results were seen in 6%, "Good" in 61%, "Fair" in 19% and "Poor" in 14% of cases.

Table 6 : Showing the results

 

Very good

Good

Fair

Poor

Total

Tonsillo-pharyngitis

5

36

13

6

60

Chronic suppurative otitis media

1

14

4

6

25

Chronic maxillary sinusitis

11

2

2

15

Total no. of patients

6
(6%)

61

(61%)

19
(19%)

14
(14%)

100
(100%)

SUMMARY

1. The main aim of our study was to establish an effective alternative to common antibiotics which are used extensively in spite of their higher cost and toxic side-effects. Both these important factors decide the course of treatment in the majority of cases in our country. Septilin is an antibacterial agent which is economical and does not cause any side-effects evern after prolonged administration in full doses (2 tablets t.i.d.).

2. Our study comprised 100 patients suffering from various E.N.T. infections. Forty-three were males and 57 females.

3. There were 60 cases with tonsillitis and pharyngitis, 25 with chronic suppurative otitis media and 15 with chronic maxillary sinusitis.

4. In adults, the dosage of Septlin was 2 tablets t.i.d. In children it was 1 tablet t.i.d. Therapy was continued for 3 weeks in all patients.

5. The result were as follows:

(i)

Very good

6% of cases

(ii)

Good

61% of cases

(iii)

Fair

19% of cases

(iv)

Poor

14% of cases

The cases in our study had taken other aemotherapeutic agents previously without much relief. In such resistant cases, a cure rate of 67%, (i and ii above) for Septilin is really noteworthy.

6. The significant improvement in signs and symptoms in tonsillitis, pharyngitis, chronic suppurative otitis media and chronic maxillary sinusitis proves the efficacy of Septilin.

 

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

We are thankful to the Dean, Indira Gandhi Medical College and Supt. General Hospital, Nagpur, the Prof. of Microbiology and The Himalaya Drug Co., Bombay for helping us to conduct this study.

REFERENCES

1.

Behl, P.N. and Tripathi, R.L., Aspects of Allergy and Applied Immunology (1975): VIII, 137-145.

2.

Cohn, Z.A. and Hirsch, J.G., J. exp. med. (1960): 112, pp. 983 and 1105.

3.

Gadre, K.C., Shah, H.A. and Dehnugara (Miss), A.P., Probe (1964): 3, 99.

4.

Lakshmipathi, G. and Venugopal Rao, B., J. Ind. med. Assoc. (1962): 4, 174.

5.

Vishwakarma, S.K., Probe (1979): 2, 85.

6.

Sheth, Shantilal, C., Tibrewala, N.S., Warerkar, U.R. and Karande, V.S., J. Ind. med. Prof. (1959): 5, 2767.