Responses to My Readings
Zhu, Xi 1 (1127-1200 CE)
1.
A small square pond 2 reflects like a mirror.
The reflections of light 3 and clouds 4 pace back and
forth together 5.
I wonder how the water has become so clear.
It is because running water flows from its source 6.
2.
Spring water swelled the river last night.
A large boat floats as lightly as a feather.
When grounded at the dock, it was difficult to move 7.
Today it sails smoothly midstream 8.
Notes
1 Yuan-hui, Zhong-hui, Hui-an, Hui-weng ("weng" means "old man"), Kao-ting-xian-sheng
("xian-sheng" means "mister"), Yun-gu-lao-ren ("lao-ren" means "old man"), Cang-Zhou-bing-sou
("bing-sou" means "sick, old man"), and ni-weng were Xi Zhu's other first names.
His ancestors lived in Wu-yuan-xian City (present day Wu-yuan City in Jiangxi
Province) in Hui-zhou-fu County. Xi Zhu was born in You-xi City in Nan-jian-zhou
County (present day San-ming County) during the Southern Song dynasty. His
father died when he was fourteen years old. Later, he followed his mother as
they moved to Chong-an-xian City in Jian-yang County. Honoring the wishes
expressed in his father’s will, he studied with Yuan-zhong Hu, Zhi-zhong Liu,
and Zi-hui Liu. Zhi-zhong Liu married his daughter to Xi Zhu. In 1147, Xi Zhu
passed the local exam because of his outstanding comprehension of Zen
philosophy. The examiner, Zi Cai, commented, "Xi Zhu has a vision for the
nation. He will be a great man someday." In 1148, Xi Zhu passed the Advanced
Exam. In 1151, he was appointed mayor's secretary at Tong-an-xian City in Chuan-zhou
County. In 1153, he studied under the tutelage of Tong Li, a third generation
disciple of Hao Cheng, and established his own philosophy of idealism. Tong Li
gave Xi Zhu a new first name, Yuan-hui ("Yuan" means "seek"; "hui" means "hidden
meanings"). After finished his term as mayor, he resigned his office and
traveled to various academies of classical learning to promote his philosophy.
Xi Zhu was a master of "Li-xue (study of principles; metaphysics)", a school
of philosophy founded by scholars during the Song dynasty who attempted to
search for the common roots of various classics of Chinese philosophy. Following
the legacies of Dun-yi Zhou, Hao Cheng, and Yi Cheng, the founders of Li-xue, Xi
Zhu forged Confucianism, Buddhism and Taoism in one stove with one flame and
carried Li-xue forward. The main theme of his philosophy is to be respectful:
one should study and practice the principles of virtue and control desire. Xi
Zhu advocated studying the phenomena of nature to understand the underlying
principles and then putting the principles of virtue into practice through
self-examination. Here are some of his important ideas: The principles of nature
and the principles of virtue are one; the principles of virtue and spirits are
inseparable: the principles in nature govern spirits and spirits embody the
principles in nature; the principles of virtue are more fundamental than
spirits; comprehension of principles and practice of virtue stimulate each other
and lead one toward ever greater understanding.
In 1163, Xi Zhu wrote to Emperor Xiao-zong and proposed to him three
suggestions: 1. Study the phenomena of nature to understand the underlying
principles. 2. Fight against the Kingdom of Jin rather than negotiate peace with
them. 3. Appoint the wise and able to government positions. Emperor Xiao-zong
offered Zhu a position but neglected his suggestions. The emperor's court was
full of capitulators. Consequently, Xi Zhu resigned his position and returned to
his hometown. In 1164, the Kingdom of Jin signed a peace treaty with the Kingdom
of Song under the condition that the latter had to treated former like an uncle.
Xi Zhu turned his energy towards a continuation of developing and promoting his
philosophy. The emperor court recruited him several times, but he declined all
the offers.
During this period, his hometown suffered a flood, a famine, and then a riot.
These incidents inspired Xi Zhu to design a relief plan for disasters. His
method of providing disaster relief was to first donate several scores or
hundreds of hectoliters of grain and then store them in a grain depot. If there
was a temporary shortage, the depot would loan grain to disaster victims. In the
winter, the victims would repay the loan with 20% interest. In years with poor
harvests, the interest charge was reduced to 10%. In years of famine, there was
no interest except for a small charge of three liters of grain. Later, Xi Zhu
enforced his method in Fujian Province. Then other provinces followed his
example, as did later generations.
In 1178, through Prime Minister Hao Shi's recommendation, Xi Zhu was
appointed to command the troops in Nan-kang District. During this period, he
established Bai-lu-dong Academy of Classical Learning and gave lectures there.
His school regulations were as follows:
"The Goals of education: Take good care of one's parents, be loyal to the
emperor, love your spouse, respect seniors, and be trustworthy.
Order of Study: study comprehensively, ask questions, contemplate, make a
clear distinction between right and wrong, and practice one's beliefs.
Cultivation of virtue: Be honest to earn trust, be benevolent to earn
respect, control anger and desire, and correct mistakes.
Participating in society: prioritize virtue rather than profit when
conducting business; promote virtue without considering rewards.
Ways to get along with people: Do as you want to be done by; if one fails due
to lack of assistance, one should use introspection to correct one's faults."
Xi Zhu's school regulations became the example for other schools in China and
had far-reaching influence on later generations.
In 1181, through Prime Minister Huai Wang's recommendation, Xi Zhu was
appointed chief official in charge of tea and salt sales in the eastern part of
Zhejiang Province. He investigated corruption and tried to impeach corrupt
officials including Huai Wang. Wang ordered someone to attack Zhu's philosophy
and call it "fake philosophy". Xi Zhu was dismissed from his position.
In 1187, Xi Zhu became the chief official in charge of punishment at both
Gan-zhou City (present day Gan-xian City) and Jiang-zhou City (present day
Jiu-jiang City). Before long, Prime Minister Huai Wang resigned and Zhu's school
of philosophy became the orthodox school of Confucianism. Several years later,
through Prime Minister Ru-yu Zhao's recommendation, Xi Zhu became Emperor Ning-zong's tutor and advisor. When he taught Emperor Ning-zong The Great
Learning, he also criticized government. Zhu's criticism displeased the
emperor. Soon after, Xi Zhu was accused of interfering with government affairs
and banished from the emperor's court.
In 1190, Xi Zhu was the mayor of Zhang-zhou City in Fujian Province. At that
time, many tenant-peasants paid property taxes for landlords. Xi Zhu proposed to
verify the deeds and tax the landlords. His proposal was strongly opposed by
landlords and was never carried out. Xi Zhu was so angry that he resigned his
position in protest.
In 1193, Xi Zhu served in Hunan Province. Out of his busy life, he found time
to renovate Yue-lu Academy of Classical Learning and gave lectures there.
In 1195, Prime Minister Ru-yu Zhao, a patron of Xi Zhu, was forced to resign
by the influential official, Tuo-zhou Han. Because Xi Zhu had joined Zhao to
attack Han, Han initiated a campaign to attack Zhu's philosophy. In 1196, Zhu Ye
proposed to burn all the books written by Xi Zhu and fail any examinee who would
quote Xi Zhu's work when taking the Advanced Exam. Ji-zu Shen took the
opportunity to falsely accused Xi Zhu of ten crimes and proposed to sentence him
to death. The emperor's court branded Xi Zhu "fake master", his philosophy "fake
scholarship", and his followers "fake disciples". Anyone who studied Xi Zhu's
philosophy and was recommended to be a government official would be declined. Xi
Zhu was too popular to be sentenced, but he never saw his reputation restored
during his lifetime. In 1313, Emperor Ren-zong of the Yuan dynasty restored the
civil service exams. The examiners adopted Xi Zhu's Annotations of the Four
Books (the four books are The Great Learning, The Doctrine of the
Mean, Confucian Analects, and The Works of Mencius) as the
standard textbook for designing exam questions. In 1368, Emperor Tai-zu founded
the Ming dynasty. The following year the civil service exams also began to use
Xi Zhu's Annotations of the Four Books for designing exam questions. From
then on, any scholar who wanted to acquire a government position had to study Xi
Zhu's work.
Xi Zhu served four emperors: Gao-zong, Xiao-zong, Guang-zong, and Ning-zong.
At the peak of his career, he was appointed to Director of Bao-wen (treasured
writings) Tower and responsible for updating documents, literary classics, and
historical books. Xi Zhu was famous for his commentary on the Confucian
classics. He is considered the most distinguished scholar of Confucianism since
Mencius.
2 A small square pond is in the shape of a book.
3 "The reflection of light" refers to "wisdom, inspirations,
enlightenment, etc."
4 "The reflection of clouds" refers to "questions, difficulties,
obstacles, frustrations, etc."
5 This line says, "Comprehension and questions stimulate each other
and lead one toward ever greater understanding."
6 "Source" and "running water" refer to the origin and drive of development.
The elegance of achievements results from the creativity of many generations; a
successful scholar should constantly learn new things to stimulate his thoughts;
one should not expect sudden success.
7 This line says, "It is difficult to learn a trade in the beginning.
Consider writing as an example. At first, one may follow a master's steps by
imitating his style. Once one masters one style of writing, one will easily
understand other styles of writing. Hard work will eventually allow one to
establish one’s own style."
8 This line says, "A breakthrough results from hard work. When the
conditions are ripe, success will come."