The more I read about Marilyn Manson, the more I
have to feel for the guy.
It's not that I admire him as a musician -- I generally find each
new song he releases to be more unlistenable than the one before,
although I begrudgingly admit I like "The Man That You Fear" (if
that's even the title; it slips my mind); and I feel that if he
weren't such a damned freak he'd probably have never gotten
any media attention at all -- but I do respect his convictions, at
least as regards to religion.
(Why do I say this? Well, I personally feel that real Satanists,
as in Anton Levay's group -- as opposed to dumbass kids who think
gutting sheep is kewl -- get an unnecessarily bad rap. If they'd just
call themselves human-worshippers, they'd get a lot more respect.
Satanism's tenets, if followed by more people, would possibly result
in a better, more orderly society where people would be more inclined
to help, and less inclined to harm, one another. But I digress.)
And the more I read about Marilyn Manson, the madder I get at
these right-wing Christian groups who try to block his band from
performing in their hometowns. He has the right to his opinions; and
people have the right to attend his shows. But more than the sheer
oppressiveness of these people, I'm angered by the fact they seem to
think lying about someone is okay.
Lying? About what?, you might ask.
Simply put, if Marilyn Manson and his band did even half the
things they're accused of having done in concerts, they would all be
in prison right now. Or maybe an asylum.
He's wiped his ass with an American flag, simulated oral sex on
his guitarist, and ripped pages out of a Bible. So what?, I ask. No
one in that audience has had a gun held to his/her head -- they knew
what they were in for when they bought the tickets.
If they have to lie about him, they're obviously unable to
stand up to his ideas. They're not holding some crucial card,
otherwise they would be able to criticize him on fair terms.
Underlying all this is the claim by many a Christian conservative
that "If he were out there attacking Islam or gays, he'd be condemned
as a bigot, but Christianity is fair game."
To my mind, that is one of the most vapid statements I have ever
heard.
First off, a lot of what he says about Christianity -- that much
of the church stands in opposition to things that harm no one; that
much of the church tells its followers to never ask questions; that
the church has a hell of a lot of blood on its hands -- are all
completely true. There are a lot of great people who are Christians,
but the religion has a record that is far from spotless.
Secondly, although I'd never presume to speak for Marilyn Manson,
his criticisms of Christianity could be extended to some, if not all,
the world's major religions. Islam, or at least the fundamentalist
variety that makes its way onto the evening news here in the states,
is not exactly a bastion of freethought.
Third, it's not like Christianity is a minority religion in the
United States. The percentage of Americans who profess to be
Christian is high enough that the church is not in a position of
powerlessness to where criticisms are going to, over the course of a
generation, completely undermine its power base.
To be completely honest, I cannot think of a situation in modern
America where a Christian's freedom of religion is regularly
violated. Our currency says "In God We Trust;" people are asked to
swear on the Bible before taking office or testifying in court;
churches are completely tax-free; and legislators across the country
are slavishly laboring to kiss the Christian Coalition's butt and
turn Christianity into a state religion by permitting verbal prayer
in schools, giving tax dollars to parochial schools and taking real
science out of the classroom in favor of creationism.
(There's a huge file on the Secular Web that talks about this
sort of thing -- it's titled "Life In Our
Anti-Christian America", and is a must-read for those on either
side of this issue.)
On the other hand, non-Christians have to look at all this
preferential treatment and ask, "What about my rights?" If your kid
leaves his classroom during the prayer, he'll get the shit kicked out
of him on the playground. If you're not photographed coming out of
some church, you'll never win an election you're in; gay and lesbian
parents have a hard time getting to parent their own children simply
for not believing in a few verses of the Bible.
Fourth, let's be honest -- this is a religion based on martyrdom.
If it's not Jesus dying for the sins of humanity, then it's St.
Stephen getting stoned out in the town square. Christians are told,
right there in the Bible, that persecution is a good thing -- it
supposedly brings them closer to God.
Some Christians look for antagonism that's simply not there. When
I told a friend once that I was an Atheist, he took it as a personal
insult. He reacted as though I was choosing not to believe,
and furthermore, as if I were thinking, "Well, I'll not believe in
God, so I can hurt his feelings."
I guess I can see where these people are coming from, a little
bit. Some of us do come across as feeling that anyone who has
religious beliefs is a fool; but others of us are just apathetic
about the whole thing.
Is Christianity singled out for harassment? Perhaps. But the
reason is, even when it's not the majority religion of an area, it's
probably the most actively proselytizing. As the Pagan bumper sticker
reads, "God protect me from your followers." The tradition of
persecuting non-Christians in the U.S. goes back to the Puritans, who
fled religious oppression back home to come set up their own brand of
the same thing.
Why is Christianity such a target? Because it's the biggest, most
aggressive bull out there. This sort of criticism is healthy -- it
serves to keep the church in check. As long as everyone plays nice,
there's no need to slam Christianity -- but actions like the Southern Baptists' Disney boycott deserve all
the fire they draw.
So, to Christians who feel so "oppressed," I challenge you this:
If you don't like Marilyn Manson, or even Jason Tippitt, criticizing
the Christian faith, you can very easily put an end to it. Prove
yourselves better than the bad press makes you sound.
Do better than trying to take away people's health insurance.
Fight for freedom instead of against it. And then I, at least, will
commend you instead of criticizing you. I will probably still
disagree with your religion, but at least I will be able to respect
it.
Jason R. Tippitt
Martin, TN
September 15, 1997
Updated February 18,
1998
God is Dead -- Now What?