SEARCH ZDNET







AMD, Apple, or Intel?

AMD, Apple, or Intel?
Today's chip choices prove that good things come in threes.

From PC Magazine
April 1, 1999

In the market for a new computer? Lost amidst the hoopla surrounding cheap -- and free -- PCs -- is the fact that high-end systems are coming down to prices that were unthinkable even a year ago. And if the $1,800 to $3,400 price tags on these systems are still too rich for your blood, don't miss our round-up of 400-MHz Intel Celeron systems.

Here's a cheat sheet on the pros and cons of each of the processors used in the majority of today's high-end systems. And don't forget to check computershopper.com for the latest system prices. Happy hunting!

AMD K6-IIIAMD K6-III
At a Glance: AMD offers a high-performance chip at a low-budget price. If you're a thrifty shopper and don't need the zippiest system on your block, look no further.
Price Range: $1,800 to $2,500
Pros: Low-price, high performance. PC Magazine tests show systems based on the 450-MHz K6-III are nearly as fast as those based on the 500-MHz Pentium III (though shop wisely, as components can play a big role in K6-III system performance).
Cons: Solid 3-D performance, though not on par with the Pentium III. Fewer manufacturers to choose from.
Read More:
K6-III: AMD Aims High
Check Prices: AMD K6-III systems

Mac G3Apple Macintosh G3
At a Glance: In PC Labs tests, the G3-based 400-MHz Power Mac beat a 500-MHz Pentium III on several business and graphics tests.
Price Range: $2,999 for a 400-MHz system (not including monitor).
Pros: G3-based systems are strong performers, especially for graphics use. Easy to set up, easy to use.
Cons: More expensive than the competition (especially once you add a monitor). Ships without removable storage or a modem. Despite recent growth, the installed base is still much smaller than that for Windows-based systems, posing potential file-sharing and cross-platform compatibility problems.
Read More:
G3 Vs. Pentium III, Apple Power Mac G3 Check Prices: Mac G3 systems

Intel Pentium IIIIntel Pentium III
At a Glance: Systems based on Intel's highly-publicized new chip promise better multimedia performance through Streaming SIMD Extensions, which are special instructions coded into each chip.
Price Range: $2,000 to $3,400, depending upon configuration
Pros: Typically only slightly more expensive than Pentium II systems, and SIMD extensions can mean awe-inspiring graphics...
Cons: ...if only more software was optimized for it.
Read More: Pentium III: Total Coverage
Check Prices: Pentium III systems

Which system would you recommend to your friends and relatives? Have we missed any big pros or cons? Tell the world in Talkback.
Talkback Articles
Post TalkBack
 Nothing can beat Pentium... - Sangarapillai Sivashankar
 How can PCMag be trusted... - Thomas Paine
 Like many, I thought the... - Tom Carpenter
 No historical perspectiv... - Phil Jones
  What Happend to CYRIX?... - WM.Preece
  What Happend to CYRIX?... - WM.Preece
 Why should it matter....... - Peter Mills
 Yes! for surfing the int... - JumpJoe
 I have two AMD systems, ... - Stanton E. Baxter
 One note. The G3 **does... - Drew
 AMD k6-3 is tested on a ... - Mike
 No Cyrix because they're... - Robert Schleihauf
 I'm pretty sure my dual ... - Julian Haley
 AMD Rules! Not too long... - David Ingels
 I'm concerned about the ... - Billy R. Jones
 I have a computer in fro... - Terry Mickelson
 Thomas Paine: Shut up... - Tom
 Give Apple a fair shake.... - Kelly Dedman
 I recently saw benchmark... - Matt Boswell
 Just more biased reporti... - Mickey Smith
 After everybody has said... - Mark Saxon
 I have been running both... - John R. Averbeck
 Tell everybody to purcha... - Davious
 Zdnet you and cnet are i... - Glenn Robinson
 I own a packard Bell wit... - jim garraway
 Even better still, why d... - James Lee
 PM G3, $2999 DOES includ... - Will Hoyt
 You forgot the $1879 G3 ... - Lukas Hauser
 





Copyright (c) 1998 ZDNet. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of ZDNet is prohibited. ZDNet and the ZDNet logo are trademarks of Ziff-Davis Publishing Company.