alt.tv.nickelodeon Presents: The Nicktoon Rewards 2004: Results
Once again, I had to fiddle with my vote gathering process. This year, only 5 categories had second round runoffs, and only one of those was to break a tie (Biggest Surprise). Anyways, the votes are in, and here are your winners:
1: Best Holiday Special
Arnold's Christmas, HA!: 8
 "The Santa Experience", Rugrats: 2
MLAATR's Xmas ep: 1
"Operation Valentine", TWT: 1

2: Worst Holiday Special
"Stimpy's First Fart", R&S: 4
 "Christmas Every Day", FOP: 3
Write ins:
Zim's Christmas special: 1

3: Most Overrated Episode
"SpongeBob BC", SpongeBob: 9
 "SpongeBob Meets The Strangler", SpongeBob: 3
"Race Across New Zealand", Rocket Power: 1
"Plankton's Army", SpongeBob: 1

4: Most Tasteless Episode
"Phoebe's Little Problem", Hey Arnold!: 4
The "Mermaid Man and Barnacle Boy" eps, SpongeBob: 4
 "That's Life", FOP: 2
"Dark Harvest", Zim: 2
"Stimpy's First Fart", Ren and Stimpy: 2
"Karate Choppers", SpongeBob: 1
Write ins:
The one where Spongebob broke his butt: 1

5: Best Parent(s) or Parental Figure(s)
Lois, Ginger: 5
 Cosmo and Wanda, FOP: 2
Nigel and Marianne, Thornberrys: 2
Ray, Rocket Power: 2
Phil and Pookie, Hey Arnold!: 1
Hugh and Judy, JN: 1
Write ins:
Kira, Rugrats/AGU!: 1

6: Worst Parent(s) or Parental Figure(s)
Bob and Miriam, HA!: 9
 Timmy's parents, FOP: 5

7: Biggest Surprise
"Island of the Menehune", Rocket Power: 2 (2)
"No Hope For Courtney", As Told By Ginger: 2 (2)
"Secret Origin of Denzel Crocker", FOP: 2 (2)
 Danny Phantom, as a whole: 2 (1)
"Power Play", Rocket Power: 1
"The Finster Who Stole Christmas", AGU!: 1

8: Best Hairstyle
Jimmy: 4
 Arnold: 2
Ginger: 2
Gerald: 1
Nadine: 1
Eliza: 1
Write ins:
Otto: 2
Libby: 1

9: Outstanding Hairstyle Change
Ginger: 4
Eliza: 4
 Lil: 3
Kimi: 2
Cindy: 1

10: The Marshall and Lance Memorial Award for Biggest Quitter
Otto, Sam and Twister, RP, "The Big Day": 3
 Reggie, RP, "Rainy Days and Sundaes": 2
Doug and Skeeter, Doug, the one with the go-kart race: 1
Susie, AGU!, "Runaround Susie": 1

11: The "Path Not Taken" Award
 Arnold's map, HA!: 9
 Ray's marriage, RP: 3
Debbie/Eliza bonding, Thornberrys: 2
Lois' marriage, Ginger: 1
Write ins:
"The end of 'Channel Chasers' I felt would have been the perfect place to end FOP as a series, but that's just me." -- I R Joey

12: The "Not Much Luck With Pets" Award
Eugene, HA!, "Eugene's Pet": 9
 Chuckie, Rugrats, "I Remember Melville": 3
Rocko, the one with the turtle: 2
Write ins:
Timmy, FOP, "That's Life": 1

13: The Golden Apple for Best Teacher
The decimal results in this poll are a result of this poll being misconfigured as a multiple choice poll at Nickdisk.
Mr. Simmons, HA!: 3.33
 Mrs. Gordon, ATBG: 2.50
Conroy Blanc, RP: 2
Winifred Fowl, JN: 1.33
Madame Zorski, ATBG: 0.50
Ms. Slovak, HA!: 0.33
Write ins:
Mr. Lancer, DP: 1

14: The Rotten Apple for Worst Teacher
Denzel Crocker, FOP: 7
Ms. Bitters, Zim: 2
Horace Wilter, ChalkZone: 1
Mr. Lancer, DP: 1
(There was also one write in without any specification.)

15: Outstanding Sibling Rivalry
Doug/Judy, Doug: 4
 Twister/Lars, RP: 3
Helga/Olga, HA!: 3
Vicky/Tootie, FOP: 2
Stu/Drew, Rugrats/AGU!: 2

16: Most Painful Backstab
Dodie and Macie, Ginger, "Wicked Game": 4
 Tommy, AGU!, "Truth or Consequences": 3
Tommy, AGU!, "Tweenage Tycoons": 3
Gerald, HA!, "Arnold's Valentine": 2
Patrick, SBSP, "I'm With Stupid": 1
Tommy, AGU!, "It's Cupid, Stupid": 1

17: Best Episode of 2004
"Island of the Menehune", RP: 4
 "Eliza Unplugged", TWT: 2
"Lucky 13", AGU!: 1
"One of a Kind", DP: 1
"Grandpa's Packard", HA!
"The Finster Who Stole Christmas", AGU!
"Miss Nose it All", AGU!
"Saving Cynthia", AGU!
"Parental Bonding", DP
"What You Want", DP: 1
(There was also one write in without any specification.)

18: Worst Episode of 2004
"SpongeBob BC", SB: 6
 "Phoebe's Little Problem", HA!: 2
"Splitting Images", DP: 2
"Izzy or Isn't He?", AGU!
"Class Clown", FOP
"Odd Couple", FOP
"Who's Your Daddy?", FOP
"Homewrecker", FOP
"Baby Face", FOP
"Mr. Right", FOP
"Shelf Life", FOP
(There was also one write in without any specification.)

19: Best Moment of 2004
The Daniel Stark run-in, "The Big Day", RP: 5
The flash forward, "The Wedding Frame", ATBG: 4
The kiss, "Eliza Unplugged", Thornberrys: 3
Noelani saves Ray and co., "Island of the Menehune", RP: 2
The Valentine's Dance, "It's Cupid, Stupid", All Grown Up!: 1
The party, "Lucky 13", All Grown Up!: 1
Write ins:
The Fake Out Make Out, DP: 1

20: Biggest Disappointment of 2004
Where's Ginger?: 9
Where's the wedding?, RP, "The Big Day": 6
New MLaaTR season pushed back: 3
Helga gets just one scene and Gerald gets none, HA!, "Phoebe's Little Problem": 1
Write ins:
"I'm annoyed that we're still on Season 1 for Danny Phantom, even though they should be done by now..." -- DarkGojira

21: Best Guest of 2004
Cancer survivor Daniel Stark as himself, Rocket Power, "The Big Day": 5
Tim Allen as game show host, Jimmy Neutron, "Win, Lose, and Ka-Boom!": 3
Alec Baldwin as elder Timmy Turner, FOP, "Channel Chasers": 3
Shaun White as himself, Rocket Power, "The Big Day": 1
Alyssa Milano as game show contestant April, Jimmy Neutron, "Win, Lose, and Ka-Boom!": 1
Homeless girl Carla, Rocket Power, "New Girl On The Block": 1
Write ins:
Tito's nephew Leilani, Rocket Power, "Island of the Menehune": 1