Owens-Brockway, the largest glass manufacturer in the United
States, has about two dozen manufacturing plants scattered across the
country. One of its drink bottling plants is located in Lakeland,
Florida, a public power community roughly halfway between Orlando and
Tampa along Interstate 4. Owens-Brockway is a top area employer and one
of the city-owned electric system's largest customers. So when
Owens-Brockway and a dozen other large industrial customers asked
for lower electric rates, Lakeland's managers listened intently and
responded by offering all 13 Of its largest customers - including
Pepperidge Farms, Juice Bowl, Florida Tile, Bee Gee Shrimp, Publix
Supermarkets, and air bag manufacturer Breed Technologies - a 20
percent tariff reduction. To qualify, new or existing customers must
have a 12-month average load factor of 60 percent or more and a demand
exceeding one megawatt. implicit in the tariff rate is a promise: if
Lakeland's prices get out of line, customers can request a rate
reduction. If rates don't come down, the contract is null and void, and
the company can buy its power elsewhere.
In today's environment, I'd rather do business with a supplier who
wants to work with me and intends to keep my business," explains David
G. Cesio, director of energy services for Xenergy, an energy services
subsidiary of New York State Electric & Gas, which oversees
Owens-Brockway's corporate energy account. "Owens decided to stay with
[Lakeland] and work with them because they have done everything to make
doing business with them a real pleasure." That, according to Cesio, is
in marked contrast to the majority of utilities, which vigorously
resist negotiation.
Unlike its privately owned competitors, Lakeland was able to
accommodate its customers' needs because the city owns its utility
services and, therefore, did not have to get permission from state
regulators to offer incentive or contract rates. Moreover, Lakeland did
not have to wait for state or federal regulators to settle big-picture
issues associated with electricity restructuring, and they certainly
did not have to be ordered by government Fiat to participate in a more
competitive marketplace.
As Cesio's experience with Lakeland demonstrates, business
executives who seek low electric rates, reliable power, unparalleled
customer service, and new and innovative service offerings are finding
it makes good business sense to relocate or expand in one of the more
than 2,000 public power communities across the United States. No matter
where a firm relocates or expands, chances are good that public power
already is there. There are public power systems in every state except
Hawaii, ranging in size from Holyrood, Kansas, with 316 meters, to Los
Angeles, with 1.3 million customers. Community-owned systems also
operate in such large cities as Anaheim, Austin, Memphis, Orlando,
Omaha, Phoenix, San Antonio, and Seattle. And a large portion of New
York State's electricity comes from a state-owned public power system.
In fact, 20 percent of all industrial power users are already located
in public power communities.
These numbers are growing every day, for one simple reason: Cities
recognize that business and industry are very important members of
their communities, And that means they're much more willing than other
utilities to go the extra mile for their customers. "Cities could well
be more sensitive to the needs of customers than an investor-owned
utility, which traditionally hasn't seemed to care about large
electricity users," opines John Anderson, executive director of the
Electricity Consumers Resource Council, a Washington, D.C. based member
organization composed of large industrial electric users.
Further, many public power entities are themselves wholesale power
customers, and cities - or groups of cities - can band together in
search of lower wholesale energy prices. Since public power operates on
a not-for-profit basis, any savings in electricity prices are passed
along directly to the customer-owners of the system, rather than being
siphoned off by profit-taking shareholders. In fact, net income for
investor-owned utilities in 1996 was $20.3 billion, according to the
Edison Electric Institute. Private utilities paid $14.8 billion in
common stock dividends in 1996, while earnings per share totaled $2.13.
Of course, making a profit is what business is all about. In public
power communities, however, those profits are returned to citizens in
the form of lower prices. The price differences can be substantial. For
instance, in New Hampshire, where only five cities and towns own their
own utility systems, industrial customers of private power utilities
pay, on average, nearly two cents per kilowatt hour more for their
electricity than those in public power communities: 9.6 cents/kWh as
compared to 7.9 cents/kWh. For commercial customers, the story is
similar: 11.3 cents/kWh in private power communities versus 9.9
cents/kWh in public power communities. Overall, commercial customers of
private power systems pay nearly 20 percent more for electricity.
Public power utilities are far more likely to increase competitiveness
by controlling costs, reducing work forces, renegotiating contracts, or
paying down high-cost debt, according to Standard & Poor's.
While lower prices are a compelling reason to locate in a public
power community, they are not the only one. Public power provides a
level of service unequaled by private rivals. As was the case with
Lakeland, public power utilities are already showing large customers
they mean business. In fact, several public Power communities,
including those in Los Angeles and Phoenix, currently offer service
guarantees that reward the customer - and penalize the utility - if a
power problem isn't fixed within minutes of a service call.
Also, because many municipalities operate more than one utility,
all the necessary permits - water, electric, sewer, natural gas,
wastewater - can be arranged within one office, during one visit. In
fact, many city-owned utility managers are glad to run interference for
large customers with other local government agencies. What's more, many
communities offer comprehensive computerized site selection databases
allowing businesses to shop for suitable sites without leaving the
office. Numerous public utilities operate hand in hand with the local
economic development agency, allowing them to help craft a package of
incentives tailored to the needs of individual businesses.
And, if you've ever wished your company could take up its concerns
directly with the CEO of the local utility, you'll be glad to know that
it's not only possible in a public power community, but encouraged.
That's because the top official lives and works nearby, not in another
time zone. Local ownership and control means you don't have to argue
with faceless customer service representatives on the end of a
long-distance telephone line.
Community ownership takes on new meaning in the wake of merger
activity in the private utility sector. As of mid-1997, 17 proposed
mergers between private utilities were awaiting federal approval. in at
least one, the merged entity would control 100 percent of the retail
market.
Public power communities offer a number of innovative services as
well, such as broadband telecommunications services for businesses
seeking high-speed voice, video, and data communications capabilities.
Some provide lower-priced telephone service, others help customers
reshape energy usage, and still others provide a single utility bill
for multiple locations.
Across the United States, public power is taking a proactive role,
aggressively seeking ways to reduce costs and provide better customer
service. In many regions, municipal utilities have formed marketing
alliances or power pooling arrangements; in some cases, they are
teaming up with power marketers - or even investor-owned utilities - to
market electricity and natural gas to wholesale and retail electric
customers. Some are forming regional coalitions to shop for new power
supply contracts, while others swap power with different electric
systems to average out peak loads.
In short, the advantages of locating or expanding in a public power
community are so outstanding that cities across the country are
exporting forming their own public power systems. Nationwide, public
power systems provide lower energy prices, reliable electric power,
unparalleled customer service, and value-added services that flow
directly to the bottom line. Public power communities want your
business - and they'll do what it takes to get it.