Erica has also been in Lucky Stiff in the role of Rita LaPorta (the comedic lead) , the crazy Jersey gal who thinks she has offed her lover who stole six million bucks from her casino manager husband. It is a really silly, clever well written early work of Ahrens and Flarety (Ragtime and Once On This Island) The cast needs to be small playing multiple roles and it has to be done in a small theatre. They also have to have excellent comedic timing so for these reasons, it is rarely done.

Another show that Erica has done is Rags where she played the role of Bella (the ingenue). It is a story very similar to Ragtime in the sense that it deals with the hardships of the Immigrants. Bella wants to get out and see the world but her father is very strict. There is a great song called Rags where Erica got to bust a move.. but tragically Bella dies in a factory fire which leads to this whole workers rights demonstration. The script leaves a lot to be desired, but the music is pretty great. The show Rags was on Broadway for a week but it bombed in a major way. It is hardly ever done these days.