Episode Title:
FACADE

Episode Info:
Season 04 | Episode 03 | 69

Original air date:
Wednesday, October 6, 2004

Writer(s):
Holly Harold

Director:
David Carson

Series regulars:


Tom Welling
(Clark Kent)

Michael Rosenbaum
("Lex" Luthor)

Kristin Kreuk
(Lana Lang)

Allison Mack
(Chloe Sullivan)

Jensen Ackles
(Jason Teague)

John Glover
(Lionel Luthor)

Annette O'Toole
(Martha Kent)

John Schneider
(Jonathan Kent)
Guest stars:


Erica Durance (Lois Lane)


Brianna Brown ('Scabby Abby')


Brianna Brown (Abigail Fine)


Julianne Christie (Elaine Fine)


Michael Ironside (Sam Lane)


Eric Johnson (Whitney Ford)

Co-stars:


Lee Rumohr (Brett Anderson)

Rob Freeman (Coach Quigley)

Next / Previous Episode:


Ratings:

Viewers:
4.93
Overnights:
5.0/ 8
Adults (18 - 49):
2.2/ 6
Images:

Senior year of high school begins; A girl's makeover turns ugly; Lois writes her first article; Clark goes out for the football team.

What's up with Clark: Clark's has aspirations to be Smallville High's quarterback. He hasn't tried out for the football team because of his super abilities. But he's tired of sitting on the sidelines and forges his dad's signature to get on the team.

What's up with Lois: Lois' father stops by and tells her she can't go to college, cause she didn't get enough credits to graduate, she's headed back to high school. Chloe is excited to have her cousin at school and gets her to join the staff of the Torch. Lois is reluctant, but takes on a story about plastic surgery after a girl named Abby shows up with a new look.

What's up with Abby: As a freshman, Abby was dubbed "Scabby Abby" and ridiculed by the football team, and most of the school. After three years of high school hell, she tells her mom, a plastic surgeon, she wants to look beautiful. Her mom is ecstatic, but only because she can test out her new kryptonite technique which completely changes a person's body. Despite the ethical and health questions, they proceed and Abby is stunning.

What's up with Jason: Lana's beau turns out to be a former football stud and becomes assistant football coach at Smallville high, so he can be close to his love.

What's up with Lana: Lana does research on her mysterious tattoo and tries to get it removed, but is told it's not ink, but branded under the skin and probably impossible to get rid of without a full skin graft.

What's up with the Kents: Jonathan isn't happy when Martha tells him Lex has agreed to let her manage the Talon, but tells her he'll support her.

What's up with Brett: Brett is a football hot head. Freshman year, he nicknamed Abby, "Scabby Abby," but he's hot for the new and improved Abby. The two makeout in the shower, but when Brett looks in a mirror after kissing her he flips out. All he sees is a hideous version of himself looking back. He runs out the school and is hit by a car driven by Lois.

How it ends up: Abby's mom is evil. She resents Lana for being naturally beautiful and when she learns Lana knows Abby and Brett were kissing before he freaked out, she manipulates Abby into getting rid of Lana. Abby sneaks into a back room where Lana is waiting for a surprise from Jason. She kisses a blindfolded Lana, who is shocked to find out it's Abby and not Jason kissing her. When Lana next looks in a mirror she freaks out and the mirror falls on her cutting her face.

The Torch team is hot on the story. Lois posses as a girl in search of an extreme makeover and goes to see Abby's mom. Meanwhile Chloe and Clark dig up more information on the procedure and what's really behind Abby's makeover. Abby's mom discovers Lois' true intentions and sedates her. She starts the procedure on her, which without the right settings will drive her insane. Clark breaks into the office and breaks the machine used in the procedure, but is knocked back by the kryptonite in it. Lois picks him up and fights off Abby's mom. Lana and Brett are given a chemical that reverses the affect from the kiss and besides a cut on her cheek, they're fine.

Jonathan's not happy Clark's on the football team, his powers give him too much of an advantage. But Clark tells him he wants his own life, to do what he wants to do. Jonathan respects that and decides to teach his son how to play quarterback.

Lois' first story is a huge success, life changing according to her fan mail. Chloe can sense she's excited and the two go off to watch Clark get dunked in the dunk tank.
OFFICIAL DESCRIPTION:
PLASTIC SURGERY HITS SMALLVILLE

Clark faces a surprising new foe in the form of a shy high school girl (guest star Brianna Lynn Brown) who turns to plastic surgery to enhance her looks and boost her popularity. However, things go awry when she discovers that her kryptonite - enhanced beauty causes harm to anyone she kisses - and she decides her next victim will be Lana. Meanwhile, Jason and Lana continue to hide their relationship from Clark.

Michael Rosenbaum, Allison Mack, John Glover, Annette O'Toole and John Schneider also star. David Carson directed the episode written by Holly Harold.

QUOTES:
Dr. Fine (to Abby): You're going to have a senior year no one will forget.

Lois (to Clark): Nice arm farmboy.

Lois (to Chloe): It's the varsity version of Dante's Seventh Hell.

General Lane: Not to worry, Lo - I'm sure Clark will be happy to show you around.
Clark and Lois: Around where?

Chloe (to Lois): Either she spent the whole summer at a collagen farm or I've been shopping at the wrong makeup counter.

Lois (to Chloe): That's the problem with high school. It's all a facade.

Jonathan (to Martha): I've always known you wanted more than this ol' farm. I'm not going to be the one to stand in your way.

Jason (to Clark): Football is just a game. If you want to change, you'll have to do that yourself.

Jason: It was strange. (Clark) kind of opened up to me today.
Lana: You have no idea how strange that really is.

Brett (to Abby): Maybe if I'd been more patient, I'd have seen who you really are - the most beautiful girl in school.

Brett (to Abby): New face. Same old boring Scabby.

(In the men's locker room)
Clark: Last I checked you were missing some prerequisites for being in here.
Lois: So you have been checking me out.

Lex: What's with this fascination with ancient writings?
Lana: School project.
Lex: Must be the same project Clark's always working on.

Lex (to Lana): For people so different, you have remarkably similar interests.

Dr. Fine (to Lana): You're not the first one to walk in with tattoo remorse, but you are the first one without ink.

Lex (to Jason): I guess the polite thing to do is cough and let you know I'm standing here, but that always seems so forced, doesn't it?

Lex (to Jason): Lana deserves the best. I hope you're it.

Jason (to Lana): I tell you you're beautiful because of who you are, not what I see... the reasons I love you - it's not something you can see in a mirror.

Chloe: Now I'm off to see Clark Kent in a wet T-shirt. Care to join me?
Lois: Like I haven't seen that before.

MUSIC:
Song:"My Happy Ending"
Artist: Avril Lavigne
Album: Under My Skin

Song: "Eight Half Letters"
Artist: Stereoblis

Song: "F**k N' Spend"
Artist: High Speed Scene
Album: High Speed Scene

Song: "Ghetto"
Artist: John Gold
Album: The Eastside Shake

Song: "What Do You Do In The Summer(When It's Raining)"
Artist: Beu Sisters

Song: "Devils And Angels"
Artist: Toby Lightman
Album: Little Things

RECAP:
In flashback to his freshman year, we see Clark meet up with Whitney and bail out a young girl, "Scabby Abby," who three years later undergoes some experimental treatment to gain good looks. In the present, Lois suggests that Clark go out for football before her dad shows up to reveal she failed her last semester in high school and she'll have to go back for a semester.

At school a new girl arrives who Clark recognizes as a much more attractive Abby. Lana shows up and we find out Jason is now the school coach. They are concealing their relationship from Clark and everyone else, who ends up applying for the team without Jonathan's knowledge and does well in the tryouts (where Abby, as a cheerleader) is also present.. Meanwhile, Martha is hired by Lex to manage The Talon.

At her locker, Abby is confronted by a football player, Brett, and the two end up in the boy's locker room. But Abby starts feeling strange and Brett imagines his face starting to decay in a mirror. He runs out into traffic and Lois accidentally hits him. While Lois checks out the team, Clark investigates and finds a necklace that Abby dropped. Meanwhile Lana goes to Abby's mother, a doctor, who is puzzled by the "tattoo." Lana gets suspicious and Abby's mother sends Abby off after Lana. She is meeting with Jason in a drama room filled with mirrors and when he goes off Abby slips in and kisses her. Lana starts the same facial-decay hallucination and knocks a mirror onto herself, ending up in the hospital.

Lois is investigating the thing for the newspaper and signs up for treatment at Dr. Fine's clinic. She tapes the interview and Dr. Fine finds out and knocks her out. Chloe and Clark put things together and that Abby's spreading her serotonin levels to her victims, causing them to hallucinate. Clark arrives just as Lois is being subjected to Dr. Fine's "procedure" and he rescues her just in time. But the procedure involves liquefied kryptonite and Dr. Fine knocks out the weakened Clark, leaving Lois to finish the job.

Clark and Jonathan resolve their issues about Clark joining the team while Lana is reassured that Jason isn't interested in her because of her looks.

REVIEW:
  • Bureau 42
  • KrypotonSite
  • MediasharX
  • Smallville News
  • Superman Homepage
  • Tuesday Night Movie Club
  • TV Tvome
  • NEWS & NOTES:
  • The WB advertised this episode as "Kryp/Tuck".
  • John Glover doesn't appear in this episode.

    Superman References:

  • None.

    Credits/Appearances:

  • Eric Johnson, who played Whitney during Season One as well as in the episode "Visage" in Season Two, returned to the role of Lana's boyfriend during a flashback scene.

    Spoilers:
    Trademark Chloe snark has returned. "So many cheerleaders, so little cyanide" is one of the quips we are likely to hear. Abby is now described as "a rather homely girl with acne scars and frizzy hair." Lois makes a comment that, with all of the pressures of the new season on the football team, he will have "all the pressure of a team and a school and an entire town counting on you to be their hero." Aww. Clark is going to be Lois's hero. Although Abby claims that she saw Brett's veins go all poppy and that sort of thing, this may only be a psychological visage seen in a mirror. in other words, don't go counting on Abby making Lana ugly. It seems most just think Brett went crazy. Lois interviews a beefy football player and asks if this is the first time "Brett jumped the tracks." We get some background on Dr. Fine, and how she was overlooked when the pretty girls got their way. "With one surgery, that all changed," she said. Lois might get into trouble for snooping a bit too closely.

    There's a scene with Lana in bed at Smallville Medical Center, with Jason watching over her in vigil. "I'm sure you can't hear me, Lana, but if you had any idea how much you mean to me..." he says. Of course, "Mr. Hope-I'm-Not-Interrupting-Anything" Lex shows up behind him, also to visit Lana. Here's the spy report we received from the Templeton High School filming locations of Smallville: "Chloe is definately back. She has befriended Lois. We worked on a scene that took placee in the parking lot and in thee school. on Tuesday. Today we filmed a flashback scene to 2001 of a football prep rally. Lana is sitting on the dunk tank, and Whitney is leading the football team to the podium. He then proceeds to get Clark to try and throw a footbal at the dunk tank, which he proceeds to miss, due to his weakened power from Lana's Kryptonite nacklace. During this scene, the team mascot comes running up, and her hood is taken of by a member of the football scenee, and it turns out to be Abby, a pimple faced girl (skinny, not heavy) with glasses. The football player starts calling her Scabby Abby, which thee crowd starts chanting. Clark sticks up for her, but she runs away in tears. Th next scene takes place at the prep rally present day. Clark is now in the dunk tank, and Lois is throwing the football, cheered on by Chloe, which then drops Clark into the tank." We still don't know if Whitney's presence means Eric Johnson is returning, or if he's played by a new actor. We're hoping EJ is involved, although, he might still be honeymooning at the time of filming.

  • THE TORCH:
    SKIN DEEP
    Behind the Mask of the High School Facade
    By Lois Lane

    Mirror, Mirror on the wall...ever think you're maybe a bit too harsh? I mean, why is it that just as the importance of being cool is at its height, puberty kicks in and cripples us with all things awkward? What are you telling us - that all the non-Lindsay Lohans are just supposed to deal?

    This year alone, some 75,000 cosmetic surgeries will be implemented on kids. Kids. As in, under the age of eighteen, not allowed to vote, kids. The same I-can't-even-get-a-sunflower-tattoo'd-on-my-ankle-without-parental- consent 'tween can go under the knife, get pumped with chemicals, nipped, tucked, stitched and switched, all with a thumbs-up from Mom.

    I'm a fan of wanting to put the best foot forward, but when plastic surgery is a suggestion of a parent, a ref needs to blow the whistle. It's hard enough for some of us to maneuver the hallways without mom and dad also reminding us to suck it in. So, an afternoon of downing triple caps at the Talon got me thinking about teen pressures. The desire to fit in consumes almost every aspect of our high school experience.

    Senior Abby Fine used to hide in a Crow's mascot costume to dodge a daily barrage of insults. Her mother, a plastic surgeon who recently found herself on the other side of the clipboard, saw a reflection of her own insecurities in her acne-scarred daughter. So desperate to rid Abby of imperfection, Dr. Fine implemented an untested surgical procedure that left Abby with the power to make people see themselves as ugly with a single kiss. After sharing a smooch with football player Brett Anderson, it became clear - high school is a game of facades. Though Brett seemed like a pillar of confidence, the kiss triggered a Serotonin imbalance that exposed his innermost fears. He didn't add up. He wouldn't fit in. He might as well die.

    It doesn't matter how thick your pads are or how high your pom-poms wave, high school puts every student through the ringer. When everyone seems to have it so together, we have to remind ourselves that nobody does. We'll all commit the occasional fashion blooper, we'll all break out with an occasional blemish, we might drop the occasional pass or receive the occasional B. High school is four years where we're exposed to a new experience every single day and we're allowed to be awkward and overwhelmed.

    In ten years I bet we look back and realize two things. One, everyone was desperate to fit in. And two, whether it be a team, a clique, a club or a bra-size, no one really knew what exactly they were trying to fit in to or why it was so important at the time. We just knew it felt like life or death. And then I bet we laugh.

    AFTER ELLEN (Malinda Lo, October 7, 2004):
    Smallville Exploits Lesbianism, Again

    Lesbian kisses between straight characters generally don’t occur on television until sweeps periods, but Smallville jumped the gun this week when Lana Lang and a female villain-of-the-week shared a deadly kiss. Although this episode, titled "Facade," was by no means as outdated and exploitative as Smallville's previous lesbian exploitation attempt (a second-season episode titled “Visage” which featured a psycho-killer lesbian), it’s difficult to say that “Facade” represents progress.

    “Facade,” the third episode of the fourth season of the WB’s popular teen drama, was written by Holly Harold, one of Smallville’s few female writers, and centers on the evils of plastic surgery. It opens with a flashback scene set during Clark Kent's (Tom Welling) freshman year at Smallville High, as he witnesses the football team making fun of a girl with pronounced acne. Bursting into tears, the girl runs away from their taunting shouts of “Scabby Abby,” and the episode fast-forwards three years to the present time. Abigail Pine (played by Brianna Lynn Brown) is about to undergo plastic surgery, and her mother, a brittle blonde with an obsession for perfect features, is the doctor in charge. As a glowing green shell with needles poking out of it descends onto Abigail, who is strapped down to an operating table, her mother insists, “Everyone will love you when they see the real you, the one that’s been inside you all along.”

    When the new-and-improved Abigail returns to school, she’s no longer “Scabby Abby”; instead she looks like a cookie-cutter blonde beauty queen. She immediately catches the eye of football player Brett, who lures her into the boys’ locker room shower with some Teutonic grunting and much fondling of her surgically sculpted chin. But when they kiss, Abigail passes something onto Brett that makes him go crazy. He hallucinates that his face is melting off and runs madly into the parking lot, straight into a car driven by the young Lois Lane (Erica Durance).

    Meanwhile, the perfectly perky Lana Lang (Kristin Kreuk) has returned to Smallville from her trip to Paris, where she met the handsome football star Jason Teague (Jensen Ackles). Jason can’t bear to be parted from Lana, so he has moved to Smallville and taken a job as the high school’s assistant football coach. This means they can be together—but only in secret (teachers obviously can’t date students). On her way back from a secret assignation with the assistant coach, Lana sees Abigail and Brett getting close in the hallway, and after she finds out that Brett has been hospitalized, she asks Abigail about his mysterious behavior.

    Freaked out that Lana will somehow link Brett’s accident to her evil smooching, Abigail tells her mother, who orders her to take Lana down before she has a chance to destroy her operation. Abigail finds Lana back in the high school drama room, where she is sitting blindfolded, surrounded by costumes and glittering lights, waiting for a birthday present that Jason is about to bring to her. Abigail kisses Lana on the lips, and Lana briefly responds before she realizes that it’s not Jason. When she pulls off her blindfold and sees Abigail, both girls look disgusted and shocked. Abigail apologizes, but it’s too late—Lana begins to go crazy, and when she looks in the mirror she sees her face rotting off.

    It turns out that Abigail’s plastic surgery increased her serotonin to unsafe levels, and whenever she kisses anyone, she transmits that serotonin to them. This causes them to hallucinate that their faces are melting off. At the end of the episode, after Lois and Clark have saved the day, a quick wrap-up scene explains that Abigail’s mom has been locked into a psych ward, and Abigail is fine and will be returning to school next week.

    In comparison to the crazy lesbian stalker in Season Two's “Visage," “Facade” is a model of good behavior: Abigail doesn’t have an obsession, lesbian or otherwise, with Lana; it’s her evil mother who bullies her into doing the bad deed. And “Facade” is clearly a less exploitative episode than “Visage,” if only because at the end of the episode it doesn’t appear as though Abigail’s classmates are condemning her for kissing Lana (in fact it’s not clear that anyone knows they kissed at all).

    But there is no avoiding the fact that both Abigail and Lana look disgusted by their kiss. Abigail might have been having feelings of remorse about driving her friend crazy, and Lana’s reaction might have been one of shock (especially since she was expecting her boyfriend), but viewers get to see two young actresses looking freaked out by the fact that they just kissed another girl.

    Lana’s psychotic hallucinations about her face melting off fall in line with the overall story, which is a morality tale about the dangers of wanting to fit in too badly (via plastic surgery, our society’s fairy godmother). But the fact that her hallucinations come immediately after her kiss with Abigail also suggests that her rotting features are a punishment for kissing a girl—especially because Lana appears to lean into the kiss before she realizes she isn’t kissing Jason.

    The problem with the kissing goes beyond the metaphorical damnation of lesbianism, however. The WB’s advertising for “Facade” prominently featured the kiss between Abigail and Lana, titillating viewers with the tagline “A town’s obsession with beauty has seductive side-effects.” This clearly exploits lesbianism for ratings, and while everybody does it (although usually during sweeps months), that doesn’t make it acceptable.

    Given the negative consequences of the kiss and disgusted reactions of the two girls, this scene doesn’t exactly build up any sense of gay pride—far from it. That would still be okay, if there were ever any actual lesbian characters on the show to offer alternate (read: more positive) portrayals. But while sinister lesbian activity is acceptable fare for Smallville, lesbian affection borne of any kinder, gentler motives—like, say, genuine attraction between women—is apparently off-limits.

    At the same time, “Facade” demonstrated that, despite a sometimes saccharine, family-values feel (it is, after all, about Superman), Smallville has several great female characters, particularly the ass-kicking Lois Lane (who ends up saving Clark in this episode) and her spirited cousin, Chloe (Allison Mack). Let’s hope that in the future, Smallville’s producers focus on these girls, rather than dredging up tired old lesbian clichés that only underline homophobic stereotypes.