Blog Tools
Edit your Blog
Build a Blog
RSS Feed
View Profile
« June 2005 »
S M T W T F S
1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30
You are not logged in. Log in
Entries by Topic
All topics  «
Misc.
Poker
Politics
Religion
Television
Sleepless in Fulham: Rambling and gambling by David Young
Tuesday, 14 June 2005
Portuguese beach rampage.
Topic: Politics
Of all the things I could mention to illustrate the decadence of Western Europe, few could match the story of the mass rampage that took place on a beach near Lisbon last Friday. If the story has slipped under your radar, the facts are these: a group of 500 young people from the city invaded the beach, robbing and attacking people in packs of thirty. The police were woefully outnumbered and only made three arrests. They fired shots into the air but could do little else. Victims later described the attackers as 'gangs', a word which in Portugal has come to refer to African immigrants.

While that's shocking enough, the truly sickening part is the spin that has been attached to the story by the BBC's Alison Roberts in her video report from the scene. Check out the story here:

Portugal youths in beach rampage

Then click on this video link:

and feel your jaw hang when she says 'Portuguese holidaymakers can only hope a fashion for it does not develop', before stressing that the authorities 'may worry about racial tensions worsening'.

How insulated from reality is the elite that controls our media! In the world of Alison Roberts, Portugese citizens, who pay tax to their authorities in return for the maintenance of order, should hope that such attacks don't become a fashion.

Hope?!

As for the idea that the authorities are supposed to worry about future racial tensions, I can guarantee Miss Roberts that the damage has already been done. To state the facts again: 500 adolescents swarmed the beach and attacked innocent people; 497 returned home free.

When I used the word 'decadence' in the first paragraph, I did not use it in any pejorative sense. I was being entirely literal. Such attacks take place because a criminal underclass feels that the willingness to maintain order has decayed and that everything is up for grabs.

Tuesday, 14 June 2005 - 7:27 PM BST

Name: JRS

Are you truly shocked & sickened by what Miss Roberts said? Or is it some artistic hyperbole.

Its a common news phrase. Having watched Sept-11th on TV I could only hope it wouldn't happen again. What was I supposed to do? Patrol the skies?

And what do you expect Portuguese holidaymakers to do? Form a vigilante group? I find it unlikely that Miss Roberts meant that Portugal is relying solely on the hopes and prayers of holidaymakers to avoid similar scenes.

Wednesday, 15 June 2005 - 4:17 AM BST

Name: David Young

The Portugese people should expect that it never happens again. The best way to ensure that would be to have arrested far more than just three people out of five hundred. And 'racial tensions' should be the least of the government's worries. Why worry about a potential future problem when you have a serious existing problem now? The surest way to inflame racial tension would be to go soft. It would be a gift to racist groups and parties, who could sell themselves as the only 'tough on crime' solution.

To respond to your question, yes, if push came to shove then citizens should have the right to fight back. Remember that in a free society, the people award the state a monopoly on the use of violence, in return for the state ensuring order for the people. The authority comes from the bottom up, not the top down. If the state neglects its duties then the people should petition the state for a return of the right to force.

In the US, it's taken as a given that citizens have the right to bear arms. To Americans this is common sense, as in the event that you are attacked, you are on the scene and the police aren't. As I shall explain in a later post, I'm not sold on the idea of allowing gun ownership yet, but if it crime gets worse then it's something we should consider. The crime that took place in Portugal could never have happened in Texas. The attackers would have known that they had no chance of making it back home alive. That's why despite the impression you might get from TV cop dramas, Americans have far far far lower rates of home burglary than we do.

DY

Wednesday, 15 June 2005 - 6:08 PM BST

Name: JRS

"Why worry about a potential future problem when you have a serious existing problem now?"

I'm glad you're not a policy-maker

View Latest Entries