Cybersovereignty: Digital Diné

Frances K. Vitali

Author Outline:

Abstract | Acknowledgement | Problem & Context | Research Context | Literature Review | Historical Context | Theoretical Assumptions | Context of Case | Entry Vignette | Problem Question | Description of Case | Analysis of Themes | Assertions | Closing Vignette | References | Appendices |

"To forget one’s indebtedness is the greatest crime a person can commit." – Simon Bolivar

"Treasures of the heart are the most valuable of all." - Nichiren Daishonin

"Great ideas spring not so much from noble intelligence as from noble feeling." – Fyodor Dostoevesky

"You must do the thing you think you cannot do." – Eleanor Roosevelt

"Intelligent and kind people are beautiful. They inspire trust and a sense of reassurance in those around them." - Daisaku Ikeda

"Being deeply loved by someone gives you strength, while loving someone deeply gives you courage." – Lao-Tsu

"The stories we tell not only explain things to others, they explain them to ourselves." - Donald Norman

"We are chords to other chords to other chords, if we're lucky, to melody." - Joy Harjo

ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS

"To forget one’s indebtedness is the greatest crime a person can commit." – Simon Bolivar

I am thankful to all who have helped and supported me in the process of the dissertation research. Your generosity, support, kindness and wisdom have been appreciated and have contributed to the final product.

For those individuals who have provided me with exceptional challenges, I thank you for strengthening my personal stamina, determination, and convictions.

"If you want to share a vision or tell the truth, you pick up your pen and take your chances." – Nikki Giovanni

"Treasures of the heart are the most valuable of all." - Nichiren Dashonin

Navajo Dine’ leaders, chapter officials, community members, educators, and advocates, who so unselfishly give of yourselves to the people, it is an honor to know you.
"Baa ahéhee' nisin" to:

  • Lake Valley Chapter House officials and community members;

  • Lake Valley Senior Citizens Center staff and elders;

  • Lake Valley Navajo School principal, students, faculty and staff;

  • Dine’ College students and staff; Crownpoint Branch Director, Irene Charles-Lutz, and GED Instructor, Rick Lutz;

  • Navajo Communications External Affairs Manager Francis Mike

  • Robert Moore (Navajo) and Dianne Guitterez (Navajo) formerly of ATIIN, one of the first Native American cybertrade businesses in New Mexico;

  • Cultural mentors: New Mexico State Library Tribal Libraries Program Associate, Jean Whitehorse and Lake Valley Chapter House Community Service Coordinator, Etta Tso;

  • Alice T. George, Navajo Translator;

  • Technical mentors: shideezhi Gail Burnside and sik’is Devona Devore;

  • Research mentor Dr. Joanne McCloskey for her guidance;

  • Dr. Paul Zolbrod for honing my path into orality and literacy;

  • Dissertation consultant Dr. Evangeline Parsons-Yazzie;

  • Telecommunications advocates New Mexico State Senator Leonard Tsosie and New Mexico State Representative Ray Begaye;

  • National Indian Telecommunications Institute Development Director Lisa Nelmida and CEO Karen Buller.

"Great ideas spring not so much from noble intelligence as from noble feeling." - Fyodor Dostoevesky

"Enormous gratitude is extended to:
  • Professors, staff and students at Emporia State University School of Library and Information Management, in particular, Anita Woods and Candice Kistleman;

  • Kansas State University Libraries, staff and administration during my Multicultural Graduate Internship;

  • Molly Royse and Pramila Tummala of the KSU Libraries Multicultural Research and Resource Center who continued as my mentors during my Multicultural Graduate Internship;

  • Emporia State University William Allen White Library, Kansas State University Hale Library, and San Juan College Library Circulation and Interlibrary Loan staff for their tolerance of the continual renewal of my library materials;

  • New Mexico State Library Tribal Libraries Program Advocates Alison Freese and Jean Whitehorse for asking me to be a part of the Native American Access to Technology Pilot Program at Lake Valley, New Mexico. Their ongoing commitment to tribal libraries and tribal community centers is commendable;

  • Bill and Melinda Gates Foundations New American Access to Technology initiative in recognizing and generously acting on the Indian Country digitl divide on the Navajo Nation;

  • Native American Access to Technology (Bill and Melinda Gates Foundations) Grant Program Manager, Jessica Dorr, who has become a valuable networking friend and technical advisor;

  • Dr. Hilary McLellan for her intellectual generosity;

  • Drs. Brian O'Connor and Roger Wyatt for keeping me on a focused path;

  • Dr. Jack Glazier for his knwoledge about qualitative research;

  • Tripod Homepage Studio free web hosting.

"You must do the thing you think you cannot do." – Eleanor Roosevelt

To my parents, who instilled in me the vital spirit of freedom and responsibility to do whatever my heart desired!

Drs. Anthony and Cynthia Vitali, for the privilege of their computer and Internet while writing the dissertation proposal. I am still in debt to you both.

"Intelligent and kind people are beautiful. They inspire trust and a sense of reassurance in those around them." - Daisaku Ikeda

It was a privilege to work with and to be guided by the genuinely caring, creative scholars and artists of my dissertation committee mentors. Drs. Brian O’Connor, Roger Wyatt, Paul Zolbrod, and Jack Glazier, thank you for your understanding, support, wisdom, protection, guidance, and belief in me through my zone of proximal development within this project and the doctoral program in general.I value your friendship and academic scholarship.

"Being deeply loved by someone gives you strength, while loving someone deeply gives you courage." - Lao-Tsu

Thank you to Michele DeLese for providing a comfortable home, care, nurturance, support, and friendship - a true benefactor! Your continual encouragement contributed to maintaining a healthy and happy balance during the doctoral research experience.

"The stories we tell not only explain things to others, they explain them to ourselves." - Donald Norman

"We are chords to other chords to other chords, if we're lucky, to melody." - Joy Harjo

Personal Appendix

Top of Page

Author Outline:

Abstract | Acknowledgement | Problem & Context | Research Context | Literature Review | Historical Context | Theoretical Assumptions | Context of Case | Entry Vignette | Problem Question | Description of Case | Analysis of Themes | Assertions | Closing Vignette | References | Appendices |

Frances Vitali, author

updated April 16, 2000