|  |  | 
  
    | 
        
          | Page last edited on 13 April, 2003
           |  |  |  Hinduism vs. HindutvaBy P.R. Ram. This extract is from chapter 3 ('Hindutva
Movement') of the book 'Fascism of the Sangh Parivar' published by EKTA
(Committee for Communal Amity), 1999. 
  
    | Hinduism | Hindutva |  
    | 1. A collation of multiple traditions:
      Brahminism - Shramanism Tantra, Kabir and Tukaram, etc | 1. Politics of Hindu Elite, drawing from
      Brahminical Hinduism |  
    | 2. Brahminism: Caste sytem, the Dominant ethos | 2. Brew of Brahminical Hinduism and Nationalism |  
    | 3. Brahminism projected as the Hinduism
      initially in 6-10 century, then in early 19th century, Brahminical
      Hinduism projected to be synonymous with Hinduism. | 3. Aims at Hindu Rashtra (Nation) based on
      Brahminical Hinduism |  
    | 4. Shramanic traditions: Constant rebellion:
      attempt to escape the clutches of Brahminism: Conversion to Buddhism
      (early times And now after the lead given by Ambedkar). Vivekananda said: Why amongst the poor are so many Mohammedans..., to
      Escape the tyranny of the Zamindar and the priests. | 4. Led initially by Brahmins: Banias: even now
      dominant Leadership From upper castes. |  
    | 5. 'Dharma' (Religion) is a mix of Humanism and
      caste based religious duties. | 5. Political expression through sangh parivar
      now, earlier Hindu mahasabha and RSS. |  
    | 6. Semitisation process being spearheaded by SP
      Holy deity: Ram, Holy Book: Gita, clergy: Shankaracharyas, etc/ | 6. A mix of fundamentalism and Fasicm (see
      table) |  
    | 7. Its proponents claim it to be tolerant and
      catholic. cf: earlier it's attitude to shudras, cf: Now its attitude to
      muslims. | 7. VHP bring in the stink of fundamentalism in
      the essentially fascist politics of RSS, BJP and Bajrangdal. |  Note: VHP (Vishwa Hindu Parishad - World Hindu Council), BJP (Bharatiya
Janata Party - India's Peoples Party), Bajrangdal, etc are wings of the Sangh
Parivar (Family of Organisations), the parent organisation being RSS (Rashtriya
Swayamsevak sangh - National Volunteer Organisation). |